Are kids meant to be spoiled?
@lordwarwizard (35747)
Singapore
March 1, 2008 4:52am CST
I read an article today about how China is considering abolishing her one-child policy because of her graying population.
Just to jot your mind a little, under the one-child policy, every couple is allowed ONE child only. If you want to have more children, you have to pay a graduated (I think) fine each time. But as you know, rich people are springing up by the buckets in China so the policy is as good as defeated - but that's another story for another day.
I want to talk about what happened because of this one-child policy. During this long period of "restricted childbirth" (pls don't think constipation... :P), every family has just 1 child. This means that the child is the apple of the eye and the entire family's time, love, financial resources, etc are inevitably and generously spent on him. Consequently, these children grow up spoiled and are commonly "tyrants" in many ways. I am speaking of this in a general sense of course because exceptions definitely exist.
But is spoiling your child wrong? The child is of your blood and seed and it is understandable for you to want to give your all to him. I am not a parent yet but the last Fengshui master who checked my tail said I would over-indulge my children. :P
So, are kids meant to be spoiled? Do share your thoughts. =)
28 people like this
91 responses
@plumwish07 (4057)
• Indonesia
1 Mar 08
my dear friend,
china has those restricted about one family one child in order to control human groth ppopulation on those country. what i knowing, lots of people in china live on unwelfare condition so by having many children would not make them able to pay their daily basic life however, the size area of china is limited. if the government doesn't do this kind thing, their country would not able to be their residents place.
but in my opinion, by having one kid in a family, i don't think that the kid should be arised with spoiled manner. as like you my dear friend, i am lso not yet being a parents but i totally understand that parents always want to give everything for their child. so without realizing that they giving spoiled parenting to their only one child. its all about the parents in my opinion. in fact, i have so many relatives and friend which only having one child in their marriage but able to raise their child not too spoiling and the child also become unspoiled child.
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Hello my friend,
Just to set records straight, I was not passing criticism on China's one-child policy. All policies have their pros and cons.
I just think that with your own kids, sometimes it is hard to NOT over-indulge. You just love them too much.:P
3 people like this
@lynboobsy11 (11343)
• Philippines
1 Mar 08
I think it depends on the parents. Me I was the only child of my parents but It never happened that they spoiled me a lot. Even in material things or in my attitudes they never spoiled me. That was I'm thanking with them coz I grew old in my own. I never saw anything that they spoiled me.
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Perhaps they see independence as a more valuable trait to instill in you.:)
2 people like this
@febriantoeko (205)
• Indonesia
2 Mar 08
Very good when since clidhood we had lived independent and did with parents, will make your life happy
3 people like this
@nannacroc (4049)
•
1 Mar 08
Children should be spoiled, not with material things but with attention and love. I was asked by a Health Visitor how I was able to spoil three children. They didn't have a lot of material goods but we were always there for them. They didn't become tyrants and two of them are very good, loving mothers. Their children are also spoilt with love and attention but don't have everything materially.
3 people like this
@sneezeklenex (344)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I agree. Children should be spoiled with love and attention! It's not material things that will stay with them forever as you found in your children. It is something that will be passed on forever and ever.
3 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Lol... and the moral of the story is...?
... there is more than one way to spoil a child! :P
2 people like this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
•
1 Mar 08
i dont think kids can be spoilt. The only ones who think so are others who disapprove of A) the child getting what it wants or B) The parents giving their attention to the child.
I will continue to do the best for my kids, irrespective of if someone else approves
blessed be
3 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Sure thing, no parent can claim he mastered the art of parenting.
Do what you think best for your kids.:)
2 people like this
@ElicBxn (63594)
• United States
1 Mar 08
my neice is an only child and as a youngster a spoiled rotten brat.
Honestly, the only thing that saved her from being a total monster is the fact that if she didn't try to be nice, she didn't have any friends and she did want friends.
I'm glad I didn't have to live with her, I'd've probably had to kill her a few times, but... she's grown up pretty good.
3 people like this
@bongkarpasang (1377)
• Indonesia
1 Mar 08
umm, I don't think that one kid only in the family would always make the parents spoil the kid. I would rather agree that when the parents get their own preference towards any of their children, that child would be spoiled so much more than the others. anyway, the China policy perhaps just makes people (the parents) get scared of losing their only child, because they can only have one child (and of course, nobody wants to lose their only child) and just thinking about the only successor of the family, the child spoiling very possibly happens to these population.
however, there are also those families with many children, but one of the children just got the favor of the father / mother or even both of the parents. and they spoil this one more than the other children of the same parents. this very possibly happen too. some patrilineal community still favor a son more than any daughter. so, when they only have one son, and the rests are daughters, a spoiled son might have been raised in this family too. like the situation of a family I know. and I just feel this isn't right.
no matter how the parents love / like the children / kids, the kids still have to learn that there are rules and consequences for everything, and they just won't get everything they want in the society, so the parents should have never made the children become used to 'do whatever they want or get whatever they ask'. if the parents do that, they would only harm their kids' future in society. the kids wouldn't grow up properly and aware of the harsh situation when they enter the real world life.
so I won't recommend the parents to spoil their kids, no matter how their children become the apple of the eye. because they won't live forever for their children, right? one day these children will have to enter their own phase of life, and they must be prepared to anticipate any situation especially when their parents are not by their side any longer, and spoiling them is not the answer for their future.
3 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
You brought up an interesting point. Favoritism can indeed spoil the kid as easily too.
Well said!
2 people like this
@febriantoeko (205)
• Indonesia
2 Mar 08
I don't Agreed your opinion because the had one of several children must in pay attention to
3 people like this
@sunshinelady (7609)
• United States
1 Mar 08
No kids are not meant to be spoiled. They are put here for us as parents to teach them how to be responsible, compassionate and loving individuals.
I for one would not want a child of mine to be spoilt. I have on son and he is not spoilt at all.
2 people like this
@sunshinelady (7609)
• United States
1 Mar 08
I did not say that I believe in the power of the rod. I don't believe in spanking a child unless it is absolutely necessary. I believe a child can be talked to and explained which goes further than the rod. If I gave you the impression that I believe in the power of the rod it was a mistaken impression on your part. I believe in teaching the respect and caring that a child should have for others. I reread my response and do not understand how you can get the power of the rod out of it. I think that kids are special little people that need nurturing and guidance to prepare them for their road of life. Because I don't believe kids should not be spoiled does not mean that I believe in the power of the rod.
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
So you believe in the power of the rod, so to speak. Make sure you have a carrot at hand to balance things up too! :)
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
I beg your pardon. I meant to say that you consider being firm to your children ideal.
2 people like this
@charms88 (7538)
• Philippines
1 Mar 08
Lol...I would love to have you as my daddy if that FengShui master you consulted was genuine. F2
Kids are meant to be spoiled by their grandparents and not the parents, lol. I tried to stray away from spoiling my bunnies too much but I tend to slip from time to time. It is not wrong to spoil our kids if they are deserving of it. If my little nuts did something like helping with the chores, setting up the table, giving me a full back massage, of course...I will treat them with a little sweets occasionally.
My own niece is an only child and I observed she have a jealousy streak in her nature. Everything she likes, she gets. I am forever nagging her mommy to stop spoiling her but its no use. Spoiling our kids to the extreme means courting future disaster.
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Unfortunately, that is not possible.
Some people might say, "Sure, next life, you can be my daughter". I am not gonna say that because I don't want to believe in reincarnation and I don't want any new cycle of this.
And yes, grandparents may spoil their grandchildren too.
The last part you mentioned - it happens with single children here usually - as least that's what I noticed. And since China is all single-child families...
2 people like this
@ayou82 (3450)
• Philippines
18 Mar 08
No they are not meant o be spoiled i guess because kids in their growing stage it is good timing to teah them well expand their knowledge of whats this and whats that and this is dangerous and this is not.. they have to explore world beyond reach and never spoil them on things that they want. Coz when they grow up they will be BasT**ds and that is not good.
2 people like this
@chrislotz (8137)
• Canada
16 Mar 08
First, I never knew that China had a restriction as to how many children a person can have. I personally, don't think that is fair or up to the government to say. I wouldn't want to be told how many children I was allowed to have.
Secondly, I don't think it is right for anyone to spoil their children. These children that are spoiled grow up and become self centered adults. Then they can have a lot of other problems if they don't get what they want when they are adults, and in a lot of cases they just take what they want. I'm not saying that this happens to all of the spoiled kids, but it does seem to happen to a lot of them.
This is just my opinion so don't berate me for it. I know of a few really spoiled adults that were spoiled when they were kids, and they have a hard time living now because they are used to getting everything they want, and life just doesn't work that way.
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
16 Mar 08
I agree. I wouldn't want to be in their shoes too... China is a... special country.
1 person likes this
@dont_pick_your_nose (2279)
• Australia
18 Mar 08
It is a person decision nhow you want your children raised and i think people are very differed on opinion and feel very strongly about their beliefs.
For me, I cant help it. I want to do it. I think life is full of hardships and i want to give my boy everything i can. I think it is hard not to poil your children. I make sure i have what we need, then i always get a few extra special things so that i feel like i am spoiling him. Giving is a good feeling.
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
18 Mar 08
Yea, you are the final decision maker.
1 person likes this
@loveyoohbaby (737)
• New Zealand
18 Mar 08
Maybe a bit but not to much other wise if they get spoiled to the max when they are young it does not teach them as they are growing up and that is when you could cause a problem when they get to adulthood when they have got all they have wished for a there life then as an adult they will also want it for the rest of there life
2 people like this
@mnsrwt123 (2057)
• India
18 Mar 08
Hmm, i also heard about this policy a few years ago, my maths teacher told me when i was in 12th,,, and he explains exactly like you did,,, And by that means you just controlling the child growth and also the burden on parents also become less...
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
18 Mar 08
Well, you can put it that way too...
1 person likes this
@wickedangel (1636)
• Dominican Republic
12 Mar 08
No, I don't think parents should spoil their child, they should be taught to respect everyone and gain acceptance into the social structure like most of us did (a good hiding on the butt didn't do any of us any harm!)
China may have a graying population but at the last count it was almost the quickest expanding country in the world, I can't remember how many millions of millions.....
In fact they got rid of so many of their daughters over the last 20 - 40 years (they being the lesser of the two sexes, I'm not in agreement here but that was their thoughts) that now their sons who are of an age to get married have found out that there are not enough females to go round!!!! Sounds like sci-fi doesn't it!? And if both your parents are not from China then you are considered to be an outsider even though both your parents are of pure Chinese lineage.
Oh dear, racism all over again....
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
15 Mar 08
Wouldn't want to discuss policies lol.
1 person likes this
@timou87 (1638)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
No, I don't think kids are meant to be spoilt. Yes, they are meant to be shielded at least for a time, as they learn the most basic skills that are needed for survival, if you can call it that, but after a certain age, maybe 4 or 5, kids should be let to make their own mistakes, and learn from them. Adults around them just need to be there to pick them up and give them advice and support them, but never to pamper and spoil them.
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Yup, parents should be there to guide them to mold them into better people.:)
1 person likes this
@manigandan18 (243)
• India
1 Mar 08
it mainly depends on the mentality of there friends and also mainly deoends on there parents and friends with whome they wander
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
1 Mar 08
I do not think children should be spoiled except when they are babies, and then we parents gradually unspoil then and get them used to life. We do it in such a way that the child feels safe and then wants to do things on their own. They learn that mummy and daddy cannot buy them a toy computer and that nice outfit and they grow up. That one-child policy in China is wrong because it leads to spoiled brats. However I believe that if it is wrong in China, then the one-child policy should be wrong everywhere else even in Europe, because right now Europeans are being persuaded to have one or no children and that is racial discrimination.
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Haha, I like the way you put it. Gradually unspoil them, eh?:P
1 person likes this
@ethanmama (1745)
• Philippines
1 Mar 08
I think there is a difference between loving and spoiling. Loving our kids means we give our kids the best of what we can afford, within reason. For example, spending for quality education, nutritious food, good medical care, not to mention spending quality time with our kids are part of loving them. So is giving in to their whims once in a while, within reason. It is teaching them what is right and what is wrong.
Spoiling, however, is different. It means that we give in to our kid's whims, whether or not such whims are reasonable or even affordable for us. It is not being able to tell our kid: "Son, we cannot afford it. If you want it, you may have to save up for it." It is defending our child's actions even if they are wrong, and not being able to discipline our kid because we cannot bear to punish them, so they get away with wrongdoings.
It is certainly within our rights to give our best for our kids, but spoiling them will not make them strong characters and would be doing them a great disservice in the future. Children should learn that some things don't come easy. Children should learn that we can't always have everything we want, that some things need effort to obtain.
Just my 2 cents...
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Hi ethanmama, has been long.:)
And yes, I see your point. We've gotta draw the line somewhere.^^
1 person likes this
@anonymili (3138)
•
12 Mar 08
No, I do not think kids should be spoiled. Parents should, of course, love their children and try to give them a good life but spoiling them is not the answer. Give your children things your parents couldn't afford when you were growing up by all means, if you can afford to, but spoil them and it'll only be their downfall. Children should be brought up to respect others and treat them as they would wish to be treated themselves. That's how I would advise people to bring up their kids. I don't have any, nor do I intend to but I've seen the end result of people who spoilt their kids too much and it aint pleasant! x
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
12 Mar 08
Their needs should at least be met. :)
1 person likes this
@steffyhoney (706)
• United States
1 Mar 08
I dont think kids should be spoiled to where they are stuck up little brats. I think you should give them what they need and as much as you can but not to over due it. If they want something I think if you think they deserve to have it then get it if not then dont. I think there has to be boundries due to the fact of growing up to be spoiled brats. I know a few people like that and wouldnt want that for my daughter at all.
2 people like this
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
1 Mar 08
Yup, I don't think I want my kids to be spoiled brats too.