Optimistic or Pessimistic?

United States
March 3, 2008 9:20am CST
Do you think we were born to be either optimistic or pessimistic? Or is it a learned trait? Is there a happy medium somewhere between the two? Which one are you? And why do you feel you are that way? For those who don't know me, I will have to say that I am more pessimistic. For many reasons... I hate feeling positive about something, only to be let down... the pain is heartbreaking! While if I remain somewhat doubtful and pessimistic, and it all turns out good.. then I am happily surprised! And if it doesn't turn out.. then I have to say.. I expected it all along. Fearing the worst and expecting nothing... either way, being a pessimist seems to soften the blown when things don't turn out. I'm not sure that I was born to be a pessimist, but I've had this thought pattern for so long that I can't remember thinking any other way. But I would like to know other's views on this. :)
6 people like this
17 responses
@sissy67 (224)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I dont think that a person is born to be either way. I think we are what we make ourselves out to be. I usually always try to be optimistic. I cant see living my life looking at the negative. A person only gets one life....make the best of it. Yes, there are ups and yes there are downs...but thats is just the way it is. My husband is a pessimist and I really hate that. It puts a damper on alot of things. I, for one, want to look forward to things, want to be happy and excited about things.....if Im let down then so be it...Ill pick up the peices and move on.
2 people like this
@sissy67 (224)
• United States
4 Mar 08
Im not sure of what ur really gettin out of my reply. I just know that by living with my husband and knowing his attitude that if he would choose to be a little happier and look more to the brighter side of things that he would prolly feel better. He usually always looks at the negatives first. I guess he is kinda like u in a way thinking that if he is already expecting the worse then it wont be too bad if he is let down. I just simply cant understand a person wanting to be that way. Im not judging anyone...I am just simply saying that I, myself, choose to be happy and take whatever life throws at me and deal with things as they happen. Id rather do that then to feel down and out about just about everything that I come face to face with in everyday life. I hope Im explainging myself to where u understand what Im saying without thinking that Im offending u or anyone else.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Mar 08
So, in essence you are saying that we are whatever we choose to be... not what life has thrown at us or how we were raised and certainly not born to be one of either? hmmmm... that sounds promising for those who have always been pessimistic... it means that they can completely change, if they WANT to, because it's all about willpower. thanks for responding :)
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Mar 08
I understood the first time.. but I thank you for making it clearer :) you are really excellent at writing with much detail and description! :) I don't let my "realistic" thinking show.. in fact, if you knew me, you would think that I'm probably the most optimistic person you know! lol! I appear to be the happiest person around... and I'm the encourager to my friends. I do have a positive outlook.... but I'm realistic enough to know that anything could happen... I keep my fears to myself and smile and go about my business, most days. I do, however have my moments where I slide and let a few close friends in on my doubts and fears.. perhaps it's just a part of being human.. it's not sunshiny every day.. there are days of rain.. and we aren't happy everyday no matter how hard we try.
• United States
3 Mar 08
I am an optimist and I definitely believe I was born that way. I had a lousy childhood and had some really hard times in my life but always knew things would get better and they always did. I do not know how people who do not look on the bright side and/or suffer from depression can enjoy life. I feel sorry for them but to always wait for the worst to happen is like being without hope and that is sad.
2 people like this
• United States
3 Mar 08
I just had to comment that I had a look at your profile and with your choice of music (which I liked) I just cannot believe you are really the 79 years of age that you have listed...? LOL
2 people like this
• United States
3 Mar 08
well, ya know.. I do take my vitamins every single day! lol!
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Mar 08
It is kind of sad, I suppose, but to me.. it seems more like a way of bracing myself for the worse.. to prevent me from falling to pieces if things fall apart. Almost like preparing for the storm that you hear is coming your way... Not being caught off guard. I do have hope though, I hope quiet a bit.. but it's the faith that I lack. You sound like my sister (I call her Miss Sunshine! lol!) If anyone were born optimistic.. it's her! and YOU! thanks for your response! :)
1 person likes this
• Philippines
4 Mar 08
Being an optimistic and a pessimistic is a learned trait. Below is a chart I have seen on the net once. For me I am the optimistic thinker..positive..Unlike the pessimist which is mostly negative in thought. I can say I am an optimist because I take negative actions to negative. Even if things are going wrong I try my best to make things right..I take the risk..When I make a mistake I learn from them and try not to make the same mistake again. Optimistic Thinking Challenge: open to change. take risks. willingness to make the effort. 'I can do it' 'I will try my best' Control: take responsibility for their actions. proactive. 'I have choices and options' 'If I make a mistake I will do whatever it takes to correct it' Commitment: tendency to persist. 'I will keep trying until it works' 'I will make it happen' Pessimistic Thinking Personalize: tendency to take the blame for everything. freeze. 'Its my fault' 'I am bad' or 'I am wrong' Pervasive: tendency to over-generalize. feel overwhelmed. 'Everything I do is wrong' 'I can do nothing right' 'I always make a mess of things' Permanent: tendency to exaggerate. 'It will always be this way' 'Nothing I do will make it change' 'It is always a mess'
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
Wow! you really did your homework on this subject! thanks!
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Mar 08
Ive always been a bit more pessmistic then optimistic. I think its a combination of things. Internal hardwiring, and upbrining that makes a person one or the other. I had an easy life untill my mid teens yet im more of a pessmistic person. My husband on the other hand had a difficult upbringing and he has always been an optimistic person. SO i think its a combination of envirmental factors and internal hard wiring that makes a person they way they are.
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
I really lean toward your understanding of it too! heredity has to have a part in there somewhere! thanks for taking the time to respond :)
1 person likes this
• Singapore
4 Mar 08
I am inclined to think that we have a certain bias that God didn't really make everyone equal. So some people will grow up being more optimistic or pessimistic. External factors like upbringing, school, environment will all play a role in changing or strengthening this bent.
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
Though my own thoughts on this subject varies from yours... a little, I can totally understand what you mean... and how you arrive at your conclusion. thanks for adding your input!
1 person likes this
• Singapore
4 Mar 08
i don think ppl r born 2 be either optimistic or pessimistic....it depend on the environment u grow up, the ppl u meet...al tis will then result u 2 be optimistic or pessimistic i find myself 2 be a optimistic....tis is coz i believe in myself, trust ppl & things around me....ya sometimes will be disappointed but it only a small part in our life...y should we think so much...u can choose 2 be either happy or feeling worried as it yr life...seem both u hav 2 continue living then y not choose to be happy? hav hope 4 yr future
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
I've seen people "choose" to be happy... no matter what, and still fall prey to pessimism. So I'm not completely sure that just choosing is enough. Believe it or not, not all pessimists are sad, moody, miserable people.. some are quiet happy though they see a different side to the situation compared to how an optimist may see it!
1 person likes this
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
3 Mar 08
i have always been an optimistic person.. and i am always telling my friends to always think positive. i must admit there are times where i have doubted things in my life.. but at the end of the day and my worries, my positive thinking prevails. :D and it pays to be positive...
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
It's wonderful that you have always had such a positive outlook on life.. for the most part, I have that too.. but I also know that things can change in a heartbeat and go completely wrong. I'm not really sure what that makes me... but I do encourage those around to me to ALWAYS seek the best and expect that it will come to pass. thanks for your response :)
1 person likes this
@ctrymuziklvr (11057)
• United States
4 Mar 08
I think we learn through experience what to expect in life. I was an optimist when I was younger but I've had so many bad experiences that I've become a pessimist.
• United States
4 Mar 08
You certainly aren't alone in your thinking that... I hear that a lot! and it does make sense! thanks for responding :)
@violeta_va (4831)
• Australia
3 Mar 08
I dont belive we are born one way or another I belive life makes us to be one way or another. I used to be very optimistic I always saw a dash of good or hope in every person and situation. now I still am but not as much as before I wont call my self a pesimist now but my life has not been a bed of roses so been optimistic 100% of the time is not posible for me.
2 people like this
• United States
3 Mar 08
Just as much as I don't want to believe that we are born either way.. I have to look at my sister... she has always been upbeat and happy no matter her circumstances... She is a diabetic who has lost most of her vision.. and yet, she still paints the most amazing pictures! instead of giving up and whining about not being able to see, she tries harder. She lost her daughter (it will be 2 years ago this month) and though the blow was devastating, she still woke up each morning and helped the rest of our family who were in deep mourning over our loss. She simply states that her daughter wouldn't want anyone to be unhappy over her dying. She has so many health problems and issues that most people would just give up and yet, she still smiles and keeps going. This isn't a new way of thinking for her, she has ALWAYS been the most optimistic person I have ever known.. and it appears that she was born that way.
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Mar 08
Me personally, I was an optimistic child. Heck I was an optimistic teenager and adult for a while. In the past few years, I have become something more like a pessimist. It sucks, but that is the reality of it. My kids, well for the most part seem to be all optimistic. I think your life is what makes you optimistic or pessimistic. If you are constantly betrayed and hurt when you are young, it is hard to find anything to be optimistic about.
• United States
3 Mar 08
For me, I think I turned my small thread of optimism (if I ever had any at all) into pessimism at a really early age, through a series of disappointments and heartbreaks. So I am going to have to agree with your statement that what happens in our childhood does affect the way we see life for the rest of our lives.. in SOME people.. not all.. but definitely, some.
1 person likes this
• India
3 Mar 08
No one born either to be pessimistic or optimistic. It is all depends up on how they acquire this character. Family, friends, circle and the society in which they move shape us to be in any one of these characters. When you don't have high expectations, you would not be affected in failures. Our experience mould our way of life. we have to make corrections on the basis of our experiences.
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
But, I'm curious... haven't you ever known someone who was optimistic despite the negativity that surrounded them or someone who was a pessimist that had a wonderful life, and surrounded by positive people... and had no reason for being the way that they were? I have to think that in some cases, people are born with the attitude that they have. but of course, I could be wrong!
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Mar 08
Im always optamistic., i think it has a great deal to do with the fact that im always happy on the oustside. even though i am mand or sad i dont show it. its like an automatic thing i do i dont know. im usually only pessimistic when i really didnt want to do it in the first place, or its somthing i think i know fir sure isnt wokring, then theres not since of getting hurt thnking it will. i think that is just how ive learned to be.
• United States
4 Mar 08
I didn't know that this is what optimism is.. to mask our real feelings and only show the positive, even when we don't feel it.. if this is true then I am a true optimist! If you knew me, you would know that I am the clown.. my friends will tell you that I don't mind being the butt of the joke if it makes someone laugh or smile. that is what picks me up when I am down. I always say that I laugh the hardest when I'm the most depressed. thanks!
@klaudyou (501)
3 Mar 08
You said it yourself....skeptical is neither optimistic, nor pessimistic....it's just doubtful. But we need to hope in something better than it is...although doubtful, but it might happen. Why expect bad things to happen, if someone told you something bad is happening soon and only you are able to stop it....are you saying that you won't move a finger? I don't think so... In my opinion our nature is to be optimistic always....only doubtful from time to time, as we know certain things are quite rare. Pessimism can only harm your intentionality and also can put you in a bad mood.
1 person likes this
@klaudyou (501)
3 Mar 08
Well...i just visited your profile... Sorry for the moralistic aproach... you might have more experience than I do in this matter... But anyhow...it's useful to be optimistic...and it's not very useful not to doubt either.... See you around!
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
ya know, you shouldn't believe everything ya read :)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I think you might be right! I'm more of a skeptic than anything! thanks for the better definition of all three! bad mood? naa!... I'm way past that! lol!
1 person likes this
• China
4 Mar 08
I think I born to be optimistic.As I take something to do,I just tell me"I can".As result of that,I will try as possilble as I can,also,I always be suceesd!
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 08
That is wonderful! I'm glad that you are a true born optimist! I wish you much success! Thanks!
@Soniasony (1827)
• India
4 Mar 08
I think man is both a mixture of optimist as well as pessimist...Optimism makes him hopeful about the future and possibility of survival and pessimism is a product of his bitter experience in his life..so its helpful for him to be cautious about his future ..I guess optimism has more to do with mind and imagination and pessimism can be practical approach..
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Mar 08
What a wise way to look at it! that sure makes sense! the practical side and the hopeful side coexisting! I like that! very well stated!
@xcellen (204)
• Indonesia
4 Mar 08
I think being a pessimistic or optimistic can be trained, well at first I think our environmental would usually shape us into an optimistic or pessimistic person, but after we grew, and able to think about our own life, we can choose how we want to think, being optimist or pessimist is merely a choice, now the hard part is when we are developed in a pessimistic environment, and so make us a pessimistic person, when trouble come, we tend to need support in our life more than people that was optimistically build from the start, but its not impossible to change :)
• United States
4 Mar 08
It would seem to me that it would be really hard to change from being a pessimist to an optimist.. or the other way around... because it would require a completely new way of thinking and I've not seen many people able to "choose" themselves into thinking a completely new and different way for very long. that would require a complete over haul on their personality and not merely just the way they look at things? LOOKING at things a certain way is the easy part but SEEING things a different way is difficult! thanks for you input! I really appreciate seeing every one's idea on this subject.
@gantwick (849)
• United States
3 Mar 08
I am optimistic. I wasn't always this way - I learned to be optimistic. When things don't meet my expectations, I look to the lesson I've learned and know that good things still await me.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Mar 08
that's a great way to look at things!
1 person likes this