Piano Lessons

@Modestah (11179)
United States
March 9, 2008 1:58am CST
Do you play the piano? When did you start learning? Did you take formal lessons? I would like my children to play an instrument and I think piano is an ideal starting point. At what age do you think it is an ideal time to start lessons?
5 people like this
17 responses
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
9 Mar 08
I started when I was in first grade. I only had a few lessons before I broke my arm and so I didn't get any more. It's one thing that I wish I had learned to do. I think it's the most wonderful thing to give lessons to your kids.
1 person likes this
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
9 Mar 08
I broke my arm in the first grade, too. rollerskating, or should I say falling? I am sorry you did not get to continue with the lessons. hey, maybe it is not too late?
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
9 Mar 08
Oh oh....I broke mine roller skating too! LOL
1 person likes this
@jeseravi (337)
5 Apr 08
Well, I played for 4 years when I was little, up until I got to the really hard stuff. then I switched to the violin because I found it much more entertaining. I would say the best time to start playing any instument would be around 5-7. then you get the full feel of the music.
1 person likes this
@jeseravi (337)
5 Apr 08
sorry about the double post, I thought my computer glitched, so I made another to make sure it got on here.... and it came up as two posts... sorry
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (92514)
• United States
9 Mar 08
Both my sister and I took piano lessons. I took them from the age of 4 to the age of 15. I think age 4 is perfectly OK, as long as the parent is dedicated to the practicing. Translation is the parent has to be willing to make the child play even when they whine and cry. : ) I can play the piano, but I don't like to. My sister on the other hand loves it. I would advise you something that might save you money. If the child still doesn't like it after 5 earnest years of practicing, you might want to let them stop the lessons. My poor parents, lol. I did what I was told, but I hated it and never have used the piano. I'm no where near as good as my sister. Truthfully, I'm not that good at all.
@AmbiePam (92514)
• United States
10 Mar 08
If only she'd use her powers for good, lol.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
10 Mar 08
aw, I think you hit on something here - if the individual does not have an interest in something it does not matter how much knowledge and practice they have in it, they likely will not thrive in the subject... your sister had only one thing that you lacked, the interest.
1 person likes this
@jewilim (495)
• Philippines
10 Mar 08
I had piano lesson since i was grade 5, but i stopped after 9 years. I just got tired of being spoon fed with all the pieces. Its like memorizing a poem, but i think its much nicer if you could play songs from the heart. I mean playing the song that you have in your head. I actually learn a lot from widowing songs from the radio, esp the song "A Thousand Miles" by Vanessa Carlton. Its kinda pop classical genra, seems diffifut to play but its just simple. Anyone else here who plays by ear?
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
3 Apr 08
9 years is such a long time to give it up, nice that you continue to play on your own though!
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
3 Apr 08
I started taking lessons formally when i was 7 years old. I took them until i got to a grade level past what local teachers had...The higher teacher i had been with moved out of town.I got to Royal conservatory Grade 5/6 by the time i was about 14. I still play to this day and teach myself songs from books i buy or music i download. My piano sits at my parents place in their dining room..too huge and monstrous to move easily. Its a treasure...i was given it by my grandma who learnt to play on the same piano..and it was made in 1892. The ideal age in my opinion isnt really an age but..when you deem your child is interested and responsible enough to practice their daily as required without the daily fights.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
3 Apr 08
saundyl, it sounds like you have a lot of natural gift. what a lovely heirloom for you to have of your grandmother's too. our piano is from the mid 1800s as well, and lovely carvings - and a beast to move - sadly it was rendered unplayable during our last major move - and now it just sits taking up space and being a catch all. I keep my oil lamp collection on it , but really need to find some one who will take it and do something with it - it takes up so much room and is very inconvenient to move.
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
3 Apr 08
Not being able to play the piano because its unplayable would be so sad. We have mine tuned every few years but it is tuned to itself. If we wanted to have it tuned to other instruments we would have to have it restrung. I'm sure the fact that the piano has sat on the same chunk of land for the last 60 some years has alot to do with it not being damaged by moving..it was moved once between the old house and the new house (new when my dad was born) and has sat in the same room of the new house ever since. plus its only ever changed ends of the room once in my entire life. ps thank you for the best response, it made my day!
@jeseravi (337)
5 Apr 08
I played the piano for about 4 years, but I quit when I got to the really hard stuff. I switched to the violin, and liked it much better. I would say that the best time to start playing the piano would be around 6 or seven. Then you get the musical 'feel' of things, and you'll forever be good at stuff like that.
1 person likes this
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
10 Mar 08
My brother has 2 boys, he started them at lessons when they were quite young the older one at 3. Here is a link to his son playing for us at the age of 6, he was in 1st grade. I don't know what happened to the video on it but can hear it. http://homepage.mac.com/debs_place/iMovieTheater2.html The little guy is now in 3rd grade and will be beginning the adult curriculum shortly. His young boy is in 2nd grade but did not start lesson until he was was 5, so he is not as advanced.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
10 Mar 08
sounds like your nephews are prodigies! I am downloading the plugin to hear the video now.
• Philippines
9 Mar 08
Yes, I play the piano though I stopped taking piano lessons four years ago. I took formal piano lessons and even had recitals. Though I only achieved until second grade of the so-called lessons. I study the piano together with my cousin and we thought this talent would be useful for our church if we render it as our service. If your child has talent, then, you could start at 8 years old or younger. All you need is to orient your kid with the piano and if he likes it, then, you're lucky. You don't need to buy the piano. If the child doesn't want the piano thing, then, you could try orienting him some time later when he's more open-minded and willing.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
9 Mar 08
thank you for sharing your experience and advice, it is appreciated, crossf41r13
@byfaithonly (10698)
• United States
9 Mar 08
I took piano lessons when I was 10 or 11 for about 2 years then I talked my mom into letting me quit - I've reqretted it ever since :( My 2 younger sisters both started around 5 or 6 and took them for longer than I did - one now gives lessions occasionally and could be a concert pianist if she wanted.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
10 Mar 08
wow. impressive on your sister. I am sorry you have regrets. hindsight and all. I think it is great that a person can make or supplement their living by giving lessons on such a thing as a hobby or interest....
• Singapore
9 Mar 08
You guys are so fortunate! Learning how to play the piano, huh? I had dreams of that when I was young but I never got the chance. However, I doubt I have the talent for it though. My fingers are just not that nimble. I can sing pretty decently though so at least, I am not cut out from the world of music.:P
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
9 Mar 08
My eldest child missed out on it - as we were always dirt poor. he would have done quite well to have had voice lessons, he has a natural talent for singing. my youngest seems to have a natural ear towards music and I would love to groom her into it.
1 person likes this
@Daffodil20 (1754)
• India
30 Mar 08
i started playing the keyboard since i was 5 years old...but i am very sad as i never took any professional lessons...and now do i have the time. i am 20 yrs old now and i desperately want to play good piano..or keyboard...but all i know is to play only with the right hand and take out latest song tunes...and i just know 4 or 5 songs that i can play with left hand accompaniment...any suggestions?,..what shall i do?
• United States
10 Mar 08
I can play a little piano. Mostly what I've learned by ear. I've thought about taking lessons but I haven't gotten around to it. I think the ideal age to start lessons is at least elementary school age. That way if they show any interest in learning, go ahead with it.
• United States
10 Mar 08
Oops, I didn't mean to post twice. :(
• United States
10 Mar 08
I can play a little piano. Mostly what I've learned by ear. I've thought about taking lessons but I haven't gotten around to it. I think the ideal age to start lessons is at least elementary school age. That way if they show any interest in learning, go ahead with it.
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
10 Mar 08
that sounds about like me I can pick out a tune , I have friends who play by ear but play fantastically truly remarkable natural talent - but their mother is very much into the classics and opera and surrounds the home with music at all times. don't worry about the double post it happens to all of us from time to time :)
• United States
3 Apr 08
Strictly, I don't play piano, I play the piano-organ. It's different when one plays the piano. It's difficult since you have to read two, three or sometimes four separate measures consisting in two different clefs - the G and the F. At most cases, playing the piano entails one reading a separate measure to play on the right hand, and another to the left. So it's like combining two separate music to blend in to one, just to play a single piece. I play piano-organ and it's a lot easier because I only get to read one measure, and play only on G clef. Besides, I do not have to read another set of notes to play on my left hand because the corresponding chords are supplied atop each set of notes. It's a lot easier, right. But given the chance, I would have wanted to learn playing the piano because that would make me more talented. I started learning at the age of 15. I studied by myself. The school which I studied from had many piano organs in the chapel, and once in a while I would sneak from class breaks to play and teach myself how to. Technically, I did not have a formal, ie. professional teaching me, study on piano-organ either. I was merely coached for some techniques by my friends who really play well. I was once given a free tuition to study formally piano lessons, but I skipped classes and I was soon dropped out from the list. Ouch, if I could only turn back time. Anyway, learning piano is really cool. It has a lot of benefits. If you want your children to learn, you can have them started at the tender age of 5. I'm sure they would be able to learn fast because, you know, children learn fast. Goodluck. I hope your kids would enjoy their lessons.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
9 Mar 08
I never learned to play the piano but I wish I had...I just don't have good eye-hand coordination. **AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~
@kimbers867 (2539)
• United States
9 Mar 08
My daughter is 11 and was introduced to the piano this past fall in music class. She really picked it up. Even her teacher commented on it. So we bought her an electric keyboard for Christmas. I want her to take lessons but she doesn't want to, UGH. So I am on the hunt for this keyboard keying chart that she was using in school to get her to continue to play at home. I was never exposed to instruments as a kid but my husband was. He can play the guitar and sing. So I am hoping to get her to continue.
• India
10 Mar 08
No, I don't play a piano, but I think piano music is lovely. And yes, it is a wonderful idea to encourage kids to learn piano. I learned guitar but I am afraid I did not persevere. I was 'too busy' of course. But I stuck to it for around one year. I love guitar music too; so lovely!!