Should there be a minumum wage for on-line workers?

Canada
March 9, 2008 11:12am CST
Okay,some of us enjoy working for free. We don't mind spending several hours of our time,promoting a product or program,with just a crazy dream of "striking-it-rich"... to keep us working. At least that's what the ad promises...and of course,we all believe everything we read...right?? But, I'm talking about those folks who hope to buy shoes for their kids or need money to put some food on the table; shouldn't there be some law to prevent greedy,unscrupulous on-line gurus,from taking unfair advantage of these workers? Where I live, the minimum wage for a "regular job" is around $8.00 per hour. So would a $4.00 per hour minimum wage for an on-line worker...be asking too much?
5 people like this
7 responses
@GreenMoo (11834)
9 Mar 08
I don't know if there's an answer to that one. I do think there should be a minimum wage, but on the other hand many online workers (myself included) do bits and pieces throughout the day when we have a moment so it would be terribly hard to quantify. Of course, this is exactly why most on line work is classified as self employed. It saves the company dealing with taxes etc, but also avoids minimum wage legislation. I'm interested in seeing the responses to this though, and seeing if anyone can come up with a solution that's fair to both workers and those that 'employ' them.
• United States
9 Mar 08
First of all, online jobs aren't real jobs. They can't be monitored in the same way and it is completely up to the person who gets online and decides that that is how they want to make a living. If there were such a thing as a minimum wage, a lot of the opportunities that are legitimate for those who are working hard to make them work, wouldn't exist. Second of all, minimum wage in society is a bad thing any way. It causes inflation and makes it harder and harder for the minimum wage worker to make it in this world. If you need to buy shoes for your kids or money to put food on the table, and you internet job isn't cutting it, then you need to be responsible and go get a real job that pays $8/hr, just like everyone else who needs to buy shoes for their kids and put food on the table. Plus, you should have to use your own judgment for what will really work for making money online. We have to decide what we are willing to do and whether or not we should believe what we read.
• United States
9 Mar 08
Additionally, if you find the right programs, work hard enough to develop an income, you could make a lot more then $4/hr. I have been working at building an income since August. I spend about 120-180 hours a week and made $524 a month...I think I will make about $800 this month.
@jennysp8 (855)
• United States
10 Mar 08
I simply cannot believe that everyone here seems to think that working from home - online means that you do not have a real job. I have a REAL job from home - working on the computer writing articles...and guess what? I get paid? No, it is not hourly, but it is per assignment and I can take on as many assignments as I like. I actually make more money doing this then what I could do outside of the home. And no, I don't write naughty stuff or anything without morals... But to say that it is not a "real job"..... so attorneys who owe their own law firm really don't have a "real" job then...because while they can charge an hourly rate while working for a client - they are not working and charging the whole time they are at the office so I guess that isn't a "real" job... Or a car saleman who works on commission..he/she doesn't have a real job either.... Or the person who does graphic design from home who makes a killing - but because he/she does not get a solid $10/hour for every hour they work - they don't have a "real" job either????????????
• United States
10 Mar 08
I am not sure that I should even reply to this since I feel rather like you cussed my out without saying any bad words. However, being the person that I am and having a response...I will provide it. Most, and I do mean most and not all, people who sit on their computer and hope to make a living don't really view it is a small business or self employment. If they did they wouldn't be asking questions about hourly pay (which at lest for me, is sometimes more then $20/hr, and sometimes, well...crappy), they wouldn't be on hundreds of sites desperate to know if it can work and if there is a way to make it happen. They would know that small business take a lot of work. They would know that when you own your own business, especially when starting out you work more hours then the pay is worth. They would also know that it can be done. That the more you work, the more it is worth it. That you have to find programs that work for you and then you have to really stick to it. You can increase your hourly wage into something worth talking about. But most don't know that. They are hoping to make money from home sitting in their pj's. Tell them they can make thousands a month working an hour or two a day and they are dropping hundreds of dollars down the drain. Don't be offended if you are one of the few who views your job as a real job, or who views it as a small business or self-employment. Be thankful that you have the right mindset! However, most people don't, and won't. Any my point had much more to do with monitoring work at home peoples and jobs then it did defining "real".
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
10 Mar 08
do you want to pay taxes, after all what you are doing is under the table, so you are not paying taxes, minimum wage means you have to pay income tax
@subha12 (18441)
• India
10 Mar 08
i think its a very very innovative idea.i also think there should be minimum wage for online workers as well. but who is going to pay us these? i think we are paid at mylot as the wage only.
• United States
10 Mar 08
I sure do spend a lot of time researching and promoting only to barely make a dime. While I like the idea, unfortunately it will never work.
9 Mar 08
heck ya
• United States
9 Mar 08
You have a good point, I never thought about it. The only things I usually get paid for online are things I would do anyway and I make money at an off-line job and I don't have kids yet so it is not currently an issue for me personally but I definitely agree that some sort of regulation should be instated, something similar to min. wage