Have your children been influenced by other's beliefes.
By ebberts
@ebberts (784)
United States
March 15, 2008 1:53pm CST
The other day my son came home and was talking about religion and I ask him where he got his information. He expressed that it came from one of his friends. Some of this was in my opinion really off the wall. Would you worry about this, or trust that you have done all you can to raise him the best you could, and that his good judgment will prevail. He knows I have no belief's as he was speaking of and I know he hasn't in the past. But people have such an influence on our children. What would you do?
7 people like this
10 responses
@jennysp8 (855)
• United States
15 Mar 08
I think the conversation your son experienced was an excellent thing for his growth. Since you and your son openly talk about his day and what goes on in his life at school, this gives you an opportunity to talk more about what you believe. I would never tell your son though that his friends beliefs are wrong, because you do not want him going back tp school saying that to his friend - upsetting him. But what you can say is that its not what you believe in. Allowing our children to be exposed to all religions and beliefs will allow them to make the best decision for them in the future.
I also think that by openly talking about other beliefs, you may prevent the child from growing up to resent your current faith because he/she was shetlered from everything else - meaning they may end up thinking they were missing out on something.
I hope that makes sense...or maybe I am talking in circles....
Who knows, I have been painting all day so maybe its just the fumes talking :-)
1 person likes this
@ebberts (784)
• United States
17 Mar 08
We do talk, but he is at the age now where he likes me more to listen. He says I don't listen enough. It is so hard though when you really feel you need to say something. Also My son is 18 and not in school and the information came from a friends dad. A man I like, but had no idea what his religion was. I still like him, I just don't agree with all that he believes. My son knows what my beliefs are, and I don't force them on him. I know he used to have the same or similar beliefs, I don't know what is going on, maybe it is just a phase where he wants to know more about things. Thanks for the reply and I hope your painting turned out well. Watch those fumes. God Bless.
@vijigopi (991)
• United States
15 Mar 08
Just last week my friend was telling me about this problem. We have a community get-together every Sunday and our community children are taught a lot about our tradition and culture and beliefs. She told me how many children (all 5-9 years old) were talking about other religions and calling them cool because they were being taught that religion in school. The difficult part is that most children do not want to be unique, rather they would like to go with the stream so that they are not picked on in school or in society. I guess all we can do right now is to make them understand that different people have different beliefs and no one can say one opinion will hold good for everybody. You can give examples of how each person has a different liking for different food, or colours etc... to show that each one is unique. So, you can just teach them what your beliefs are for now and tell them they can learn a lot more about yours and other beliefs when they grow up, but that should not be a deciding factor in dealing with people or making friends. Although I studied in a Catholic school and I even went to church to pray even though I am not a Christian, I didn't leave my religion. I am still proud to belong to my religion. Although I must say that I have used some common sense to not believe in some traditions(and my school teaching has had nothing to do with it), my overall perception of my religion as a whole will be taught to my children and I do hope they will be able to make a good choice themselves too without blindly following the masses.
@ebberts (784)
• United States
17 Mar 08
I as well have tried to teach my children to be individuals. I allways incouraged them not to be folowers but to do their own thing. So far I believe they have done so. I pray they grow to trust in God and have a great life here and in the hear after. Thanks for your reply.
@4monsters4me (2569)
• United States
16 Mar 08
Well this did happen to me. My daughter came home from school one day and told me that god loved me but I was going to hell because I didn't believe.
Before that we had never discussed god or religion in our house. She had no clue who god was but because her friends believed it she automatically believed it. She was 6 at the time.
That was when I started explaining what I believe and that other people believe differently. She is almost 8 now and insists she still believes in god and now goes to a Catholic school (for educational purposes) so that effects her.
As an atheist I find it very difficult to balance my beliefs and the way I want to raise my children with what they learn from outside sources. Religion is everywhere (even before they went to Catholic school--the above mentioned incident happened at a public school).
But I trust I have started a solid foundation and they will know to question everything and not just blindly follow some religion. At the moment my daughter does that but she is still young and I think in a few years she will start to see what I did at that age and eventually follow my path. If not, I accept that as long as she comes to her beliefs after much careful thought and consideration (I don not believe in blind faith and have little respect for people that follow anything blindly).
@ebberts (784)
• United States
18 Mar 08
I don't believe in frightning young children, and I do believe that the parents should be the ones to introduce religion or ones beliefs to them. Whether it be at home or in church. I believe in free will and that as we grow up we do make up our own minds as to what we believe. Being of Christian belief I of course hope that my children will as well believe as I do. I do have faith and that is what gets me through my days. Thank you for your reply.
@4monsters4me (2569)
• United States
17 Mar 08
That is horrible that they would tell a 4 year old something like that.
I'm not sure how the schools are now but I learned about evolution when I went to Catholic school, in 7th and 8th grade. In 8th grade I remember I had religion right after science class. In Science we would learn about evolution and were taught it wasn't technically what the church believed but it was the most scientific reasoning they had for how we got here. Then I would turn around and go to religion class and learn about creationism and the church's ideas.
They actually let us make up our own minds, although we were guided to believe what the church did. I remember being 13 and believing that god created the world but not in 7 literal days and used evolution to do it (which is what many Catholics now believe).
I enjoyed Catholic school despite my differing opinion on religion. I had a few incidents when I was little like when we did our First Communion in 3rd grade and when the other kids found out I wasn't doing it because I wasn't baptized they told me I was going to hell and refused to play with me for almost a week. (Not all of them, there were a few that were always my friends and stuck up for me).
That was an eye opener. I was like 8 or 9 years old and I was thinking if this is how good Catholics were being taught to behave then I wanted no part in it and after that I saw all the hypocrisy of the religious. I remember being in Church in 7th grade and being the only kid in our pew that was actually listening to the sermon. All the other kids were giggling, passing notes and talking, completely ignoring the priests. I knew then that I barely believed what I was being taught but I wanted badly to understand and prayed and did what I was taught in church and tried to be a good person.
I don't regret going to Catholic school. I chose to continue into high school and LOVED high school. It was a wonderful school and wish my girls could go there but it already cost over $8000 a year and by the time they are that age it will probably be over $10000.
I do my best with my kids to balance their religious learnings at church, to make sure they know not everyone believes that way. They know I don't believe in god and neither does their grandpa (who lives with us) and their father doesn't care one way or the other.
@eridaniblack (15)
• United States
17 Mar 08
At least she's having a positive experience...sort of.
My parents were Atheists/Agnostic (difficult to tell back then...) and kids at school were very mean when they found out that I didn't really 'get' Christianity, or believe in it. I had to go to therapy because one daycare I went to...the lady told me about how sinners go to Hell, and that the devil would come and get me if I don't believe, etc. I was like three or four, so it was very traumatizing.
I'd start teaching her about evolution as soon as possible. Does this Catholic school have a good science program? Do the kids learn about evolution and the Big Bang theory? If not, I'd consider switching schools, because children should be learning about these things. They aren't 'just theories' any more than gravity is 'just a theory'.
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
15 Mar 08
This is something I worry about for the future with my own child too. Children are influenced a lot by friends, the parents of friends, etc. So when it comes to religious beliefs, you really can't control everything your child hears about. I have a friend whose child is constantly being bombarded with people bashing my friend's religion and telling her son to convert to theirs, and I worry that my son will have to deal with the same thing.
In my case, I plan to teach my child about many beliefs and let him have his choice of them, but what I worry about is people teaching him intolerance. I don't want him to come home telling me that my beliefs are wrong all the time, or that I'm crazy for believing what I do.
I think in these cases all a parent really can do is teach their child as well as they can, and trust their child to make the right choices. Carefully explain that there are a lot of beliefs out there, and reinforce which ones you believe and which you don't.
1 person likes this
@ebberts (784)
• United States
17 Mar 08
I agree with you, there are far more influnces for our children than I would like. I have no problem with different religions, but I don't think people should force Their beliefs on others. I used to have lady of a different religon come by the house, and I listend and told them this was not my belief, She came back often, but we usually didn't talk about religion. I respected hers and she mine. We just liked each other as people. I've been told to just keep talking to my children that even though they act like they aren't listening, that some of it is getting through. I can only pray so. If they only knew how much we need to protect them, but they won't understand until they get children of their own. The best of luck to you and yours. Thanks for your reply.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
16 Mar 08
Hi ebberts, The only thing I would worry about would be people who are intolerant of other religions. I once had a friend who was raised Roman Catholic, but at school he had a good friend who was Hindu and he became fascinated with the idea of reincarnation. His parents were horrified. Years later when he was a successful medical doctor, he was still amused at their reaction. The fact was it didn't affect him, because no one tried to force him to believe anything, it was his own choice. As long as children keep an open mind and respect the beliefs of others, there won't be a problem. Blessings.
@ebberts (784)
• United States
17 Mar 08
I guess my son is tollerent of other's religions or he wouldn't have listened to what his friend had to say, but at the same time I hope the reason he brought it up to me, was the fact that he wanted to bounce it off me. He knows I don't believe as this person does. And you want to tell them so, but you have to be carefull you don't say it in the wrong way the they feel you ar putting their friend down. That is never a good way to go, the get very defensive. Not that I would put the friend down. We like this person. Thanks for your reply. God Bless.
@lancingboy (1385)
• United States
18 Mar 08
My mom went to a Catholic school and she had a friend from India who went there too. She said nobody would sit near the girl because her lunch always smelled really bad (like squid and octopus lol). My mom said she went to sit with her friend though so the girl would have someone to talk to.
@eridaniblack (15)
• United States
17 Mar 08
I'd correct them, and reinforce the family beliefs...but I wouldn't turn it into a lecture/issue (that'll just make your kid tune you out). Just let your child know that your church doesn't feel the same way, explain the differences, and then let him make up his own mind.
Honestly, if he likes his friend's religion more...I feel children should be allowed to pursue religion in whatever way they want. I don't think that a mother/father has any inherant right to 'enforce' their religion at home, but only the right to inform their children about it and let them make their own decisions.
@ebberts (784)
• United States
18 Mar 08
I do believe everyone makes up their own minds. Of course Being of Christian Faith, I hope my Children are to. I don't tell them what to believe, but they Do know what I believe in. The son I am speaking of, was a regular Church member and has been babtised. He is going through something right now. Maybe A questionable period in his life. I pray he makes his way. Thank you for your reply.
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
19 Mar 08
I would simply let him know what my PERSONAL beliefs were BUT would also be sure to tell him that others may believe differently and thats fine too..I would also give him any resources that he may want or need to research for himself...Then I'd leave him be but leave the door open for communication...when he is old enough and ready to decide for himself he will
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
16 Mar 08
I think letting children get exposed to different views can be beneficial. You just have to be able to talk with them about it all and not only be open about what they feel on it but to be able to express your views without condemning others. It's not easy I admit but it can be done. Just because someone believes something different does not make it wrong over all just wrong for you.
I help in raising my niece and she talks with us about things she learns in school, from friends, from tv and online of course. We let her know what we believe, we also discuss other religions and correct any factual wrong knowledge (for example if she said Jesus freed the slaves from Egypt we'd let her know it was Moses and before you ask no she's never confused that).
@ebberts (784)
• United States
17 Mar 08
Its wonderfull that you can talk to her in this way. I hope it lasts for all of you. It is such a hard world, we only want to protect them, to the best of our ability, whether it is every day problems or religion. We of all faith's want the same thing for the ones we love. Thanks for your reply. God Bless.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
16 Mar 08
It depends on what belief he was talking about and what belief you practice. If you are a Christian and believe in God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Ghost, then if your son comes and says "my friend goes into the forest and dances around the maypole and paints his body blue," then you will think his friend's religion is off the wall. If you are Jewish, and your friend says that they go to a church on Sunday, and they cross themselves, you would not like it.
However, sometimes God works in our children without our knowledge and I have no idea what you believe so I cannot comment but to not say that that belief is off the wall. I would try to get as much information about that belief, to find out if it really was off the wall, or whether your son took things out of context.
@ebberts (784)
• United States
18 Mar 08
I was raised with Christian beliefs. My son's friend how ever believes in what I would not call a traditional religion. without telling what religion the person is. I will say I have never heard anything like it. And I don't believe there was any way it could have been took out of context. God does work in ways that are not of our knowledge. I believe he answers all prayers, just not as we would like, but what is best for us. thank you for your reply. God Bless.
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
27 Mar 08
I would sit down and talk openly with my child about it. I actually have talked about various religions with my children when they were young and encouraged them to find out for themselves. I have never pushed my views on them and have stressed the importance of them to question everything and come up with their own veiwpoints. He should be accepting of his friends beliefs and if you taught him to have a mind of his own, then he won't be easily influenced.