Is James a Hipercrite???

The problem with the ppl who voted Ryan out is that they all say "it was only because of Allison" as if they liked him but hated Allison too much to keep him. It will be interesting to see if he goes home tomorrow or not. If they vote him out tomorrow, I'll think everyone on James side is a hypocrite b/c they all openly hate Matt. I think he's keeping Nat around for a reason b/c he knows she is Naive. Perhaps they think that if they vote Matt out, they can talk Nat into joining their side. Yeah he was in on the backdoor thing, so he shouldn't have a problem with backdooring at all! He's just mad it didn't work in his favor. As much as I hate Matt, I wish he wasn't up there just so he could kick James butt in the game! I hope Ryan stays this week.

And I agree that some will argue that semantically he did not say "I will not backdoor Matt", however once he put matt up there, matt is technically "on the block" which is what he agreed not to do. What's worse than an outright liar? To me it's someone who twists their words to make you think you are safe and then when they go against their words they can say "I didn't technically say that I wouldn't do THAT" Kind of like when BB basically screwed over America's Vote last week and ppl on mylot pointed out that TECHNICALLY CBS didn't say the person "would" go in the house but said the "might/could" go in the house. Twisting words to me is worse then lying b/c you are obviously trying to decieve or trick people

Wow! I couldn't agree with you more!!! I think that the only ones who disagree and can find some logic into him "not breaking his agreement" are James himself, his alliance or James fans. Like you said, if you say that you are not going on the block, you are not nominated..PERIOD! Back dooring someone doesn't happen without being put on the block. I'm looking at this from a neutral prospective because I do like James, even better than Matt but I now question that. I have lost the respect that I gained for James after he agreed to that and I will not feel bad if he gets evicted next week because he had a better chance of making a deal with Matt, Natalie, and Ryan, than his own alliance (besides Chelsia). His own alliance voted him out once already!! He should have went after his disloyal alliance like Josh! Josh only voted him back in because he was scared it was Allison in the box Im sure! As much as I don't agree with Natalie's antics and behavior, I am routing for her to win HOH and cause havoc on the house after her fatal attraction is gone! lol

Yay someone agrees with me :) I knew that debate training would help ;) J/k Yeah James fans want to like James still so they will say he didn't backstab. I will say YES James was smart to put Matt up, but still, he's a hypocrite for doing so. I think James may have lost some fans with this. I don't like him, never really did even before hearing his personal history. I did like Chelsea but wonder if she was helping James break his word or not. I guess we will find out tonight who was the lead behind getting Matt on the block. I will be interested to see what to Nat happens if Matt does leave. Will she stick with her alliance? Or will she flip flop and waver? Or will she crawl up in a ball and cry? I guess I might have SOME respect for her if she makes it farther in the game WITHOUT Matt around. Right now, she's pretty much letting him make the decisions. Remember, she wanted to vote out Sharon, and he basically bullied her into voting out James.

Natalie will definitely be lost without him but she is sooo obsessed with Matt that I think she has a good chance of winning HOH if it has anything to do with endurance, just to "do it for Matty". She is the type of person that would throw herself in front of a train for a guy, even though he doesn't have the same feelings. I think her biggest mistake was voting James back into the house after evicting him. I think that Sheila is the biggest backstabber because she was the one who went back to Ryan and told him not to back door Matt and ended up getting James evicted. I don't like Matt but he only went against James last week because they were planning to back door him. I definitely like Ryan over Matt but now Natalie is going to target James if she wins HOH. (small chance)

I do agree with you 100% that he broke his word. Saying they are "not going up", to me means, he will not put them up at all. If he never preached about "his word" and everyone else's "word", then I can understand his retaliation. But it really wasn't Matt who wanted James back doored in the first place. Matt was aligned with James until he found out that James was in on the plan to back door him. At this point, I'm not really sure who I like in the game anymore. I think I like Ryan because he has stuck by his "word" and alliance pretty much and isn't into all the drama. He only put James up because he betrayed the "boys alliance".

I just think that by keeping his word, it would have kept him safe for a few weeks and out of target range. He could have let Josh, Chelsia, Sheila or Sharon go after Matt next week and then he could have had Matt and Natalie's vote if he makes it to the finals. As far as the threats go, I'm really not sure who is a threat anymore?? Sheila is showing her manipulating, double talking side...Adam is acting like he cant compete, although he came in 2nd last week and plays both sides...Sharon is a mouse in the corner that lets everyone do her dirty work...I think Natalie is a huge competitor when it comes to challenges...Chelsia has been carried by James lately and I don't think that she would have lasted if James stayed out....And Josh is aligning with everyone.. Its hard to say who the biggest threat is??

The problem with that is that no one knows for sure who will win the next HOH. It might be Matt and then he tosses Chelsia and Josh up, backdoors James and then James is never going to get the chance. So, no one can just "let" anyone else get someone else out because you never know who is going to win HOH and who will be around to get whom out the next week. That is why I think he did the right thing. I do agree that Sheila is a sneaky snake. I don't know what it is about her. How she is able to get people to see things from her point of view. Especially since, to hear everyone, no one likes her. What is with that. Sharon is all about letting others do her dirty work. Chelsia hung in for HOH pretty well and, she didn't just let go, she fell off. The others let go. So, I can't fault her for slipping. Adam is really skating. But, I sort of feel like he sincerely like James and wants to be on his side. Not to say that Adam won't flip flop back to whomever wins it Wednesday. But, for him to vote James back in showed where he really does stand as far as how he feels for James. And, the fact that he didn't toss Adam up there, I think Adam might consider that if he does win HOH soon. But, again. BB is a game of opportunity and anyone who doesn't take their best given opportunities is an idiot!