Ramiel Malubay... leaves American Idol...

I thought it was really sad myself. I thought she was a great singer. I also voted for her Tuesday night. I think she will still get a singing contract. I really hated to see her go. I thought and was hoping that Kristy Lee Cook would be gone.

Yeah I liked her she was cute and had an adorable voice but yeah wrong song choices killed her. Hope she does well after AI.

Well, personally I did not feel she was one of the better singers on the Show, and I wonder how she sometimes lasted as long as she did. Her song choices were Bad, and she just did never Sing and perform either like a lot of the others have. As for a Career for her, it will be yet to know as it is up to her. Only time and yrs. will tell what she decides to do from here.

Ramiele is a really good singer and I know this will be the beginning of her career. I'm really sad that she got eliminated and what worse is Kristy Lee Cook is still in the competition.

Well, it was not really meant for her. If she come shere in the Philippines she will have a career here waiting for her. Its good that she was able to get to top 10 and thats already soemthing.

She was so darn cute, that alone should bring her some success. I felt her song choices were poor too. She had such a nice voice, with the right songs to show it off, I think she would have stayed on longer. I don't think she would have won though. I'd like to see the Idol tour when it comes too.

I see..I have not seen this show lately, But I also heared from my friedns that she her performance was excellent..still we can be proud of her, she mad it that far and she was bringing our country's name! Im sure she will be given an offer in the Phils since she has made a lot of supporters already waiting for her!!!

I read about that also, I felt sorry for her. She is a good singer, I saw and heard her singing. But maybe something is in store for her in the near future.

Yup, unfortunate indeed. I was hoping for her to be the first Asian-American Idol, but well it was the choices of the Americans. To be in the final 9 is already good enough and surely that has expose her to potential contract from the recording companies.

i'm also feel sorry for her. i feel sad when i knew american idol kicked her off. song choices is also one factor like the one said in the previous post but damn it's not the end of her career right? she can prove to the remaining idols and the judges that it's their loss in eliminating her in the top 10. goodluck for ramielle! be proud to be a FILIPINO GUYS!

it is just a shame to see her go,i like her a lot , she is very talentd... i think Ms Cook shld have left instead ...

I was sad, but was not surprised to see her go. For the last three or four performances, she wasn't belting as much as she needs to. I mean, that's how she was liked for - a tiny gurl with a big voice. I am not sure why she was not capitalizing on that reputation at all. She was holding back. It's sad, really. I thought she was gonna make it to top 5, and that she would consolidate the votes of most Asians and Filipinos here in the United States. But it turned out sour. She could have stayed longer if she just choose the right songs to match her big voice. Wait for her in the Philippines though. I am sure she will land at ASAP or SOP one of these weeks.

I feel so sad when Ramielle voted off. She has awesome voice, but sometimes She just don't pick a right song for her voice. I thought for sure Cristie will be done and going home. I still believe Ramielle will gonna be popular in the Philippines and have a good career.

I didn't watch american idol because i forgot..Haha.. I was surprised to see it on the news that Ramiele got eliminated.. HAAAY.. kaasar... I wish her the best to her career even though her road to american idol has ended.. I really like her!! She's very charming and cute... but I think she won't last lng in the competition.. Good job Ramiele.. Everyone in the Philippines is very proud of you!!

I like Carley, Brooke, Michael, David Cook and Ramiel. But it's like everyother reality shows, only one can win and rest have to move aside. I agree with you that poor song choices got the better of her.

Sad to know about that..Well, it's not the end of her. She got the personality and the talent. I know she can be noticed more outside american idol. This is not the end for her but this is just the beginning. Wish her the best!

I wish she got to at least the top 3. America needs more asian singers lol. I think the gay guy named Danny who was kicked off American Idol not too long ago is also Filipino. He looks like it to me anyway. At least we still have Nicole from the Pussycat Dolls. She's Filipino too. She said that when she visited the Philipines, she cried when she sang because she was so happy to be in her family's home country.

I was sad to see her go too! She has great talent. I think the fact that she is a bit on the timid and quite side hurt her votes. The good thing is that she made it as far as she did and now the public knows to look for her and support her in any future career moves. I always find it amazing how much they have to do to compete on American Idol. They sing, dance, perform, do interviews, photo shoots, car commercials and more. I couldn't imagion.