difference between child abuse and raising your child right

United States
April 6, 2008 2:01am CST
The difference between child abuse and raising your child the right way has become such a problem now. Because of what they teach you in schools. When a child is bruised or suddenly get's a black eye or a broken arm or leg and god knows what else that is called physicall abuse. When a child that is usually very out going and suddenly stays more and more alone and their grades start to go down in school, they seem to be more and more keeping people out that is mental abuse. But when a mother or father punishes a child for doing something wrong by taking something away or gives them a slap on the behind or on the wrist and explaining what they did wrong so they wouldn't do it again that's raising your child right. But now a days it seems that more and more children are standing up to their parents even if they just try to talk to them and say to them well you can't tell me what to do, or you can't touch me because i will call the police. Their are so many parents that have been reported for abuse Because the child decided to lie so they can get back on their parents for some reason or another and that parent looses the rest of their children, they loose thier lives, reputations and everything else because the child is always right when they scream abuse. Abuse is their it is happening all the time around us but alot of peoples lives have been ruined at the same time because someone screamed child abuse when their was none. Do you agree with me on this?
5 people like this
6 responses
@jess368 (3368)
• United States
6 Apr 08
I agree with you. Parents have become frightened to discipline their children because of what might happen. I know in some areas it has become illegal to spank your own child! Well i think spankings work. I think that in some situations a child needs a good spanking. Time out does not work all the time. Taking away the wi does not always work either. But, if a parent is scared of what their child might do, then something is wrong here as well. Children should not decide how they will be punished. I never talked back to my mom, because she was scary. I didn't like getting in trouble, so I acted right (most of the time) What has our world come to, when the kids run the house. When they can do whatever they want, and have no repercussions, because they can call the police!!! Dont raise your kids to believe this. Dont let them watch shows, that put these ideas in there head. Parents are still the parents, and should discipline there children the way they see fit (as long as it isnt actual abuse)
2 people like this
• United States
6 Apr 08
all that you say is true. one time my son told me in school they told us that you can't touch us cause we can call the police, I looked at him and said you know what i gave you birth not the school or the police and i refuse to have any child of mine direspectful wether to me or anyone else and if i feel that you deserve a spankin you will get one even if you call the police and I will give you the spanking in front of the police and let them take me away ever since i said that to him he never mentioned the police again
3 people like this
@jess368 (3368)
• United States
6 Apr 08
Good for you! I think its wonderful that some parents still act like the parent, and dont let their kiddos run the house!
2 people like this
• United States
7 Apr 08
True enough the schools have brainwashed our children into thinking if their parent touches them they will get revenge on the parent. I have spoken with the police liason officer at my daughters school and he said this is not reaqlly true. You can not hit your child with a fist or any other object and be sure you do not leave a mark but he knows kids push this. I simply tell my kids Go ahead call the police I will have a bed and three meals and they will have nothing because they can't pay the bills and cook. I really do not get this response from them anymore. Have I ever hit my children... Yes but very rarely, I slapped my older daughter in the face once when she lied to me in public. The fact that it happened in front of her friends was more devestating than the slap hurt. She had literally pushed me over the edge. That was 5 years ago and I haven't had to slap her again. I smell a victory in that one.
@thorell (24)
• United States
6 Apr 08
In modern times, with all we know about brains and behavior, we realize scientifically that there are many ways to instill discipline in a child. Some of them work better than others, and spanking doesn't seem to work at all. When a child is spanked, the lesson they learn is that you solve conflicts through violence and that the bigger person should dominate the smaller. There are too many options available to lose your head and resort to spanking. If a child is lying about abuse and the state believes them, it's a problem with the agency lacking investigative abilities.
2 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Apr 08
sorry again but i disagree spanking is a violent act and does nothing really good. I was spanked several times and all it did was engender hate towards my father w ho was also a child molester. enough said. I grew up as a decent adult because mymom and I could talk to each other and when I did something bad she looked so hurt I knew I would never do that again.
• United States
6 Apr 08
you know we can't raise our children scientifically and i'm sorry but you are wrong sometimes a spanking is the only thing that works. If you take something away from the child he will say okay i know i'm going to get it back sooner or later but when he knows he is not going to be able to sit without smarting then he will think twice about what he did. Remember we did not say that you spank a child for every little thing that he or she do wrong but somethings do need a spanking.
2 people like this
• United States
7 Apr 08
"It is my job to instill in them that Hitting, Hurting others is not exceptable. If I did not spank her for her actions she would still be hurting her baby sister." I believe this speaks for itself.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
7 Apr 08
yes i do agree with you. It is tough being a parent now. I am very laid back about so many things but I don't beat or abuse my children. 3 are grown now. I am very strict on certain things. I am very strong on being honest, considerate and doing what is right. Raising them on my own it was the most difficult and frustrating thing to be compared by other parents by them. When they were teens..oh my...it was horrible. I am not good at holding my tongue but I do not and will not tolerate total disrespect. I didn't think I could possibly change it because one of my girls was as stubborn as me. Oh we butted heads. I never once hit her but oh did I want to. You wouldn't believe the stuff that came out of this kids mouth and mine in retaliation. She was 16 and she said some things to me...I can't repeat here. I called her a f'ing btch. Now she was in control. I was not. She said,"hmm, I think I should tell someone about this. Wouldn't they just love to here how you called your daughter a @@@@@@@@@@. I told her to go ahead and make that call.They'd probably take her away from me and she'd have to live in a shelter somewhere. I had 3 other kids I was raising. It'd probably save me money and give me a much needed break. She had also punched a hole in the door which since i was renting was going to cost. she did call the cops. Her complaint was that I yelled at her to get up and go look for a job. she'd dropped out of school. The Cops took my side and were all over her. As for the door. She had to replace it herself. She did all the leg work. I would not measure it or tell her where to go to replace it....nothing. That was 3 years ago. she's a good kid now.
• United States
7 Apr 08
I love how you handled the situation sid good for yu cause you put your foot down and took control instead of letting your daughter take control good for and I see that it paid off at the end.
• United States
7 Apr 08
I love this one. I think making the girl do everything to replace what she broke is exactly what was needed. Teens seem to live in a world all by themselves. They will defy you at every step. I can tell immediately when my 15 yr old is winding up to a stubborn streak. She starts out real strong and them all of a sudden when challenged on her behaviour she folds. She will fall into the crying stage just to make everyone feel sorry for her. I have learned that this is best ignored. Sometimes she does have a valid gripe but mainly its a game.
@gemini_rose (16264)
6 Apr 08
You are right, a lot of parents are frightened of punishing a child for doing wrong because the child seems to have much more power than a parent these days. If the child knows this they will use it against the parents as well. Real children of abuse quite often do not say anything they will just put up with it, these are the ones that need the real help, not the ones who just shout out about it because they have been told off for being naughty. So much real abuse goes undiscovered until it is too late while the innocent people are having their families ripped apart with untrue claims.
• United States
6 Apr 08
you speak the truth one hundred percent. Abused children are usually quite and keep it to them selves that's why you have to look for signs especially if you know the child and know what they were like before the abuse. They are either ashamed to say anything or afraid because they were threatened or just afraid to loose their mom and dad.
@bradhart (659)
• United States
7 Apr 08
This is more of a parental failure than anything. Parents at some point found it easier to take let other people make the rules for them and decided it was too much of a bother to fight back against the idiots taking charge. The majority of parents these days are just plain lazy when it comes to being parents too. It is easy to say I gave little johny a time out every time he steals a cookie. It is hard to say I smacked his hand or spanked the hell out of him after the third or forth time I caught him doing it. No one wants to make their kid cry, not out of love most of the time, but simply because they don't want to listen to it. parents should quit trying to be friends with their kids and act like the responsible adult in their life.
• United States
7 Apr 08
I'm sorry but it is not a parental failure when a parent who wants to dicipline their child for something they have done over and over again with a spankin but are afraid to do it because of what our system calls child abuse and the parent knows they might loose that child and the respect of the comunity because they will be labeled child abusers why because of a spanking. Their is a difference between child abuse and spanking your child with a couple of smacks on their rearend for something they did wrong.
• United States
6 Apr 08
I agree that sometimes the "system" can get too involved in private lives. When my 20 yr old daughter was about 2 someone reported me to the Human services department in our city. They (and I do not to this day know who it was) did not know that a little girl that went to the same daycare as my daughter had bit her. First I was called at work and later they came to visit me at work. I endured many questions all while I was at work. Later still they came to visit me at home to see how my daughter and I interacted. That must have satisfied the "system" because I never heard from them again. Shortly after that I was fired from my job because of all the interuptions while at work. I was a single mother and this was my only means of supporting my family. I think back now and I feel like I am glad they checked me out but I also feel that they spent too much time on me. At the time I was not happy about the interviews. Who would be. I know there are people out there really hurting children and we as a society need to be aware of how children react but we also need to get some facts straight before we destroy families lives. I love my girls and would not hurt them but not all people can say this.