If Chris Daughtry was on Idol this season, would he beat David Cook?!!

This is really a good question. I really don't know the answer. My favorite of course is also Daughtry. This groups is amazing and Chris should have win the year he was on Idol. That year it was more a popularity contest. This year David is my favorite. It's the second year that my fav is a rocker and most of the time I'm more into r&B and soul.

I think its going to be David Cook. Chris Daughtry was my favourite on his AI season next to Katherine McPhee and I was sad he went to 4th place.. I like Chris Daughtry coz he's my type of rock thing.. an addition to my fanlist Bon Jovi and Nickelback.. but David Cook is my really real rock thing.. he's my ultimate rocker dude! he's got the whole package.. my whole rocker package.. for me it's like bonjovi-nickelback-daughtry formed into one rocker being..haha.lol. its true! now i'm going nuts for this guy..hehe. he's my ultimate celebrity crush...! anyway, who would go farther..? I think lets give this time to David Cook. Chris daughtry would be an AI legend like Kelly and Carrie, lets see how DC would go in his given time.. and I think DC has more fans than CD mostly female coz mainly He is SINGLE! u know it's more popular to be a hot bachelor in the entertainment industry... when David Cook admitted on AI live that he is single.. i bet fans' votes sky rocketed to millions and even added more and more Cookie fans, nice one David! besides having great vocals, dreamy voice, rocker charm, nice personality, good family background, smart and funny, has a bachelor degree, has an obvious real music talent, great performer, versatile, can sing the phonebook, has millions of fans, positive and seems fun to be with, humble, supports to Anti-Cancer,very appreciative to his fans, articulate, height looks and body, and SINGLE... it all concludes he's the winner...its a KNOCKOUT for being a knockout! haha! forgive me for ratting this long.. I'm just so excited for his success!

To me David Cook has a why to go. I like Chris Daughtry a lot better then David Cook myself.

That really is a good question. David Cook has been really awesome, up until this last Tuesday. He is really edgy while Daughtry was pretty consistent. I like Daughtry but I think Cook could sing the phone book. My personal opinion only as Daughtry has done really well for himself, but I think I like David Cook a little better.

I love Chris Daughtry's voice and all of his songs.He would win for sure!!!

I like both of these artist, but Daughtry would beat Cook. Daughtry should have won Idol, it was shocking to me that he did not win. Daughtry at this stage in his career would beat Cook.

I like both of them, but I do believe Daughtry would beat David Cook hands down