I love simon on American idol just for his honesty, do you like him??!!!
By yasmin02476
@yasmin02476 (292)
April 10, 2008 7:31pm CST
I have to admit not only because i am british but i love and respect simon so much for his brutally honest opinions...I know he could be a bit more sincere in his approach but you cant fault his honesty, Also randy is lovely cus even if he's negetive he does it with grace and beauty that you cant help smile, Paula well i am not sure cause she just never says anything bad but is that really a good thing....well guys what do you think!! I hope the line up never changes as i think it just messes the show up when someone new comes along...Come on be honest what do you think of Simon, Randy and Paula???????
1 person likes this
6 responses
@carolscash (9492)
• United States
11 Apr 08
I love Simon! I think that I am alot like Simon as I will say what I think and if someone doesn't like it,then that is their problem.
I am aware that he is very honest with these people as he knows a lot about the industry. I think that Randy is excellent at what he does. Paula is too nice and should give her opinion more.
2 people like this
@luckycharm00812 (621)
• United States
11 Apr 08
Most of the time I can agree with what Simon has to say. Then other times, he's not even close. I do like Randy & Paula, but sometimes I just can't stand the suger coating. Paula is one who just loves everyone, while Randy trys to be nice about his opinions. Though, if it were me up there, I would hate Simon, I do like his blunt honesty. I'd rather have someone tell me in the first sentence, than listen to them go on about it, then say they didn't like it.
2 people like this
@yasmin02476 (292)
•
14 Apr 08
thats true as honesty is the best policy thanks for your opinion and i totally agree with you...take care..x
@browneyedfatima (481)
• Philippines
16 Apr 08
I agree that Simon Cowell can be harsh and cruel sometimes but if the contestants can't take his brutal honesty then how are they going to survive the showbiz industry? I always listen to what Simon has to say because he certainly knows what he's talking about. Sometimes I feel he can read my mind and will say the same thing that I'm thinking about a certain contestant or performance.
1 person likes this
@whittby (3072)
• United States
16 Apr 08
I think there would be no show without Simon. The guy we love to hate. I don't know if I'm getting more perceptive, or he's changing, but I find myself agreeing with him half the time. Randy is knowledgeable and we'll say half way through a song "Randy is going to say that's a little pitchy!". 
Sometimes I think Paula is a little too nice, and sometimes I think it's good that she can find something positive to say to the performers - it must be so hard to be up there.
Sometimes I think Paula is a little too nice, and sometimes I think it's good that she can find something positive to say to the performers - it must be so hard to be up there. 
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
16 Apr 08
I agree with Simon more often than not. Paula is sometimes so nice that I just don't take it seriously. Randy is a little more real than she is. But Simon just straight out calls them as he sees them. I think it's funny though. Usually when he says, "I'm not being rude but..." he IS being rude. lol
@Sharky085 (23)
• Canada
16 Apr 08
I always find that I agree more with Simon then Randy & Paula. Sometimes they just absolutely LOVE a song & I HATED it, & more often than not, I say "THANK you Simon!" Although he can really be brutal sometimes, & sometimes I dont agree with him, most of the time I do.
