can women and men truly be friends?

United States
April 12, 2008 11:57pm CST
Yes, I'm asking if women and men can be friends after having been in a relationship like in the movie "When Harry met Sally." I'm not quite sure how I think about it. There have been times when it possible to remain friends with an ex, but there have been more times where it was practically impossible to do that. I'm debating the issue because I have the opportunity to meet with an ex that I haven't seen in over two years. Before our relationship ended I had suggested that we remain friends no matter what because I held his opinion in high regard and he seemed to be the only person I knew that was willing and able to push me on to greater things. But since it's been over two years and he's making the effort to see me once again, I find myself questioning his motives. What would you recommend in this situation? Do you feel that we could be just friends? Do you believe there are no other motives behind his actions? Or would you just leave well enough alone?
3 people like this
16 responses
@pooh08 (671)
• Vietnam
14 Apr 08
The husband and the wife after they divorce, they still a friend. If the work don't have ex friends, so why they get married with others.
1 person likes this
@bellaofchaos (11538)
• United States
13 Apr 08
Wonder_grrrl66, To answer your first question Can women and men truly be friends?Yes without a shadow of a doubt they can be. Will there be some that can't, yep! Will there be some that can, yep! Here is the major question can you view a guy as just a friend and then you will have your own personal answer to that. Now on to the heart of the matter. So you and your ex broke up about 2 yrs ago but decided to remain friends becuase you valued his opinion and he was able to show and motivate you to do greater things, right? Well here's a question for you so that I can better understand the situation. Did you or he break it off? Were the circumstances of the break up riddled with ill thoughts toward one another? Did one person do something that upset the other to the point of no return or was it a mutual break up were you are more friends than a relationship and there for that was the reasoning? Sorry don't mean to be nibby but with out knowing the circumstances of the break up it's hard to give accurate advice .. Now on what I have here are the answers to the questions you have. What would you recommend in this situation? I would recommend if you decided to be friends afterwards to go out and talk what can it hurt? The worst that can happen is the guy still likes you and was hoping to try again. And here is the kicker if he signals that then tell him friends only if he can handle it you'll know. Also I'm a big fan at being point blank obvious. I would come out and ask the questions that I had for the ex. Maybe in two years he was straightening out his life and getting it in order and giving both you and him time to come to terms with the break up .. That could be why he was out of contact for so long. If it bothers you ask? When I was in elementary school I had one teacher tell me that only stupid question is the question not asked. Don't be afriad to question him after all this time if you have questions. Do you feel that we could be just friends? Personally I don't know .. I don't know you or him or the situation that caused the break up. But I can ask questions to help you find out for yourself. Do you still have feelings of any kind for him other that friendship? Are you uncomfortable at the thought of being around him? Are you still attracted to him? When I was younger I had a friend that I told no matter what happened we'd still be friends, You know what I'm still friends with him because I would rather be friends with him and have him in my life than not to have him in my life at all. Now may I ask if you never so him again would it hurt you, would you feel a loss? Do you believe there are no other motives behind his actions? His motives might be as pure as the driven snow I have no clue because I don't know him. I can offer you this you were in a relationship with him and yes people can change if they truly want to but is he the type that would have an underlying motive? Remember you haven't seen him in two years do give the benefit of the doubt you should be able to tell wether or not he has a motive with in the first few minutes to half hour. Or would you just leave well enough alone? That my dear is entirely up to you. I can not say yeah or nay to you on this. If it were me and I stated that I wanted to be friends because I respected his opinion and the way he motivated me to do things and become a better person. Then no I wouldn't leave well enough alone I would go out of my respect and curiousity and see what he truly wanted. If he wanted to hang out as friends and stayed true to format Bully for me for having the b@lls to actually go and attend a get together with him. But I did say if it was me. I wish you luck in your decision and hope that you make the best choice for you. You know all the information and therefore can make a more informative decision than all of us. But goodluck ... Out of curiousity sake , do you have feelings for him if so that does change everything. Or have you moved on and are involved and just feel awkward?
• United States
16 Apr 08
Ok, here is my advice. Since you don't have anyone on your dance card but you doubt he is the one what is the harm in going and finding out exactly what he wants or doesn't want. I'm the point blank obvious type. I say what I expect or want out of something. If I have a question I ask it. So being that you and him have similar views. I would go and meet him and hang out making sure he is very aware that it's a friendship thing at the time. If you at any time feel that there is more to it than take the risk some people do change for the people that they care for or just by growing up. He's been gone two years and as you dtated is doing very well for himself. Maybe he locked himself away to make changes .. You'll never know why he did what he did unless you ask why he was absent out of your life for two years. Now on the other hand maybe he was giving you space because you were upset and in that time frame he started to change and better himself and then didn't know how to approach you. There are a varity of reasons why he could have did what he did but you'll never know unless you go and hang out. I use to say to my friends if you don't take the chance for love what do you take it for? But I know this doesn't fit this situation so let me adjust it. If you don't take a chance to see what becomes of this friendship or the possibilities of what it to come how do you change anything or go forward or have an adventure. I'm not saying blindly follow with out questioning the person along the way but go find out follow with some questions if you head in a direction that you don't want to head then say so and get of the train or bus or what ever it is at that time. If you looking for fun and just a way to let out tension, let him know .. What ever happens be honest and open. The only way to experience new this is to be open. LOL!! TRust me on this one. I may not be much older but I have gone through a heck of a lot in my lifetime. From a severely disfunctional family and growing up at an early age to a failed marriage with a abusive idiot to some good relationships and awesome friendships .. Some things I would have never experienced if I hadn't been open to the experience. I think that we all have our issues of distrust and previous bad experiences that we need to overcome and I think wipe the slate clean and give the friendship a go. Be open and honest with both yourself and him about how your are feeling in any given situation. Take care and good luck...
@subha12 (18441)
• India
14 Apr 08
why not, if they want to be. i had seen that many times the same question is asked by many. i believe in true friendship. i am very good friends with some guys. there is niothing more tahn that. also chances are there that at first friendship, then the situation goes along to next step. the basis od realtionship is good friendship
@alcazar (761)
• India
13 Apr 08
In which era are u living dear....ofcourse...u two can be friends and if someone is asking questions even after you have cleared everything ...then i think that he/she hasnt matured yet...... think bout it....What all matters is only is that u twoo are clear about that....///thats it/.....LOL
• United States
15 Apr 08
I guess I have pretty old-fashioned thoughts at times. I just never feel totally comfortable with a guy that I've been involved with. This is probably the first time that an ex has wanted to see me again after a relationship ended. I'm not quite sure how I should approach it, so that's why I posed the question. But I will keep your thoughts in mind.
• Philippines
13 Apr 08
I do believe that men and women can be friends after all there is no gender requirements in friendship right? Being friends with your ex is another thing. For me it would depend on how you part ways with your ex. If you parted ways feeling angry to each other or having issues that were not settled as there is really no closure on your relationship, then maybe being friends with that person might not that be easy because there is always a tendency to bring up old issues especially those that remain unanswered and unfix. If on the other hand you guys parted ways calmly and you know - ok, then being friends with your ex is more than possible. In your case, I do believe that you should trust him on being friends with you again, do not expect or think of other stuff - for now, give him the benefit of the doubt that he just want to be friends with you. if there's something on his mind other than friendship, let him say that directly to you first, do not assume because in assuming that he's after another round of relationship, you're ruining the possibility of you being friends again and to some extent, you might hurt yourself in the event that he is not into that. Just stay cool and let him show his true intentions.
• United States
15 Apr 08
Yeah, I agree I think it's better just to wait it and find out what his motives are.
@leeapollo (611)
• China
13 Apr 08
I think women and men can be friends.it is possible if you keep the distance.so don't do the thing that let him misunderstand.I think you know what i mean.just keep going on ang good luck.
• United States
15 Apr 08
Thanks. I will keep that in mind.
@pillusch (1147)
• Mexico
13 Apr 08
I suggest you give him the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he just likes to see you, for old times sake, maybe (probably) he still likes you, whether as a friend or what doesn't matter. We tend to complicate things, he might just want to have a chat, collect those $ 5.00 you owe him LOL, get your opinion on his new hair-do, might be in love with somebody else and wants your feedback...... There are thousands of things, and yes, he might just want to be your friend. I'd go and find out, there is little you can lose (unless, of course, YOU still love him, and then I don't know.)
@youless (112591)
• Guangzhou, China
13 Apr 08
I think men and women can be true friends. The most important point is men and women are quite different, they seldom have to be jealous to each other. And therefore they can give truly opinions and offer sincere help. But if both of you had a love relationship before. It depends on whether you can be friends again as both of you may still feel hurtful and sad to it.
@jason_co (407)
• Philippines
13 Apr 08
Yah they could be a better friends. Because they are opposite and they have a lot to teach with each other and a lot to experience.
@khateya (263)
• Australia
13 Apr 08
Nothing is impossible in this world as long as you learn to accept it. To me it can be. Good discussion.
• India
13 Apr 08
I think friendship is a prelude for having a relationship with someone you love .It doesn't work other way around .You can be person who knows each other very well but not best of friends there after . with regards www.chocolatesavy.com
@sisco100 (2338)
• United States
13 Apr 08
ya i dont know why they couldnt its not like were two different species, all my friends are women and i wouldnt change it. so i dont think tht there would a problem with it, not even if they dated once in there lifes if they get along thn why not be friends
• Romania
13 Apr 08
Yes I think that women and men can truly be friends even without dating before. Just friends. I think you can be friend with your ex but at one moment it will come up the discussion......... about how did things go when you were together and stuff like that. But I think you can be friends!!
@rombi001 (941)
13 Apr 08
I think its very much possible to be just friends as long as both of you already have partners, or you are not physically attracted to them... I would probably find it very difficult to be just friends with someone I really get along with and find extremely attractive... If you know what I mean :)
@thuynhu (661)
• United States
13 Apr 08
I think you guys can be friends. I have many friends that were an ex at one point in time. I just have a close bond with my friends. I was usually always a friend before ever becoming a girlfriend. Honestly, I think you should still give him a shot to be your friend. Sometimes people lose contact with one another and all of a sudden find them. I know about this very well. I lose touch but I still remain in contact after years. Don't deny him a chance to be a good friend, if you don't honestly know if he's after something else. You maybe wrong about him and if you were how would you feel then??
@learn25 (114)
• Philippines
13 Apr 08
Yes. That is possible. If both parties agree to be friends then it can be done.