Free-will or predestination--is their a continuum?
By DavidReedy
@DavidReedy (2378)
United States
April 14, 2008 1:06am CST
Anymore, I rarely know what I want to rant about, and frankly, I never really get satisfactory answers from my questions that I ask here--if anyone even bothers to answer... I did see an interesting discussion about whether or not one thinks they are doing what they are meant to be doing in this life...
Which leads to an age-old question--do you believe in determinism or free-will? Is their predestination? Is the truth somewhere on a continuum--is it possible that there is both predestination and free will existing in simultaneous synchronicity--somehow contributing to an additional facet of reality that we have yet to name?
Thoughts?
1 person likes this
5 responses
@miamilady (4910)
• United States
6 May 08
My thoughts...I have no clue!
I used to ponder this stuff.I guess sometimes I still do, but I haven't come up with an answer.
It seems that the older I get and the more I experience, the less I know!
I appreciate your discussion. It's a shame you haven't received more relies. I guess people don't like to think too hard on certain topics.
I did come across a quote recently.
I can't remember who said it, but it was probably someone famous...
I'd rather rather live like there is a God and find out that there isn't, than to live like there isn't and find out that there is.
I probably got off topic a bit, but thats just how my brain works. It kind of wanders a little bit.
Take care,
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
6 May 08
You have a great response. I'm not sure if it's to the original poster or to me, though--mylot's always been a bit vague that way.
Frankly, I want to forget about this discussion, I allowed my passions to overwhelm me, and did become both offensive and defensive. It just got my goat, that others weren't recognizing the exact same behaviour... But again, my pride speaks.
God, let us all assume that "He" is real, is a perfect being by that age old definition, thus, no one, regardless of what book they want to quote, can possible know "Him" or "His" ways--except to do their best to live by Love and truth, and the highest of ethics and faith.
DR...
1 person likes this
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
6 May 08
LOL... Silly me, I confused this post (my own) with that of another one I participated in. You can completely disregard my last response--with exception to the "thank you"--I'll stand by that.
LOL...
dr...
1 person likes this
@miamilady (4910)
• United States
16 Apr 09
LOL and I just realized that I posted a second reply to this discussion one year later! I guess the second reply will get deleted eventually. now I have to go back up and finish reading how I felt about this a year ago.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
14 Apr 08
I think it's a combination of the two actually. I think that our lives are predetermined when we're born but we're given free will to choose what paths we will follow.
Meaning that a person may be born destined to have many children but they then decide as they become adults that they don't want children. They've changed their destiny by making a choice.
We all make choices in our lives and I know many ppl, including myself, have prayed to have things work out the way we want them to but they tend to work out differently b/c that is the way they are supposed to end up.
**AT PEACE WITHIN**
~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~
2 people like this
@TheGreatWhiteBuffalo (4822)
• United States
10 Sep 09
We have determined that our will is not free and we will do as we please just for spite of that fact, at least some people think that they are invisible to the rest of us and that their actions are not witnessed.
In the end, all will be known...
1 person likes this
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
10 Sep 09
"In the end, all will be known" you said... I like that. It's the basis of hope for a lot of belief systems is it not? Great response.
1 person likes this
@TheGreatWhiteBuffalo (4822)
• United States
11 Sep 09
Yes, thank you all I can add is that in my world I have found some humans that are bad humans...
Some people are in need of being told the truth! If they want me to smile and treat them with warmth and unconditional love then they are going to have to figure out a way to stop violating the laws of the land. You know the law of the Land,is written on the heart of the universe...
@miamilady (4910)
• United States
16 Apr 09
You questions just gave me a headache. lol
I've actually thought about this at times.
And I think my opinion changes.
I guess I do believe that it's possible that it's both at the same time.
I think I'm just resigned to the fact that most of these lifes questions we really will never "know" for sure, so why bother trying to figure it out?
I just do what we all do. Make the best decision I can at any given time and hope for the best.
It's a shame you don't get more replies to your discussions. You ask some really good questions.
1 person likes this
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
22 Aug 09
On a personal note, I want to apologize for taking like 5 years to get back to you, my inbox--obviously somewhere, somehow, I gave someone or some entity my email address that I shouldn't have--and I'm spammed with dozens of letters a day--they collected hardcore (as they continue to do) as I was without a computer/internet for a few weeks. You've probably noticed the trend of me replying to a lot of old postings on your part--I'm just now getting that far along in getting this inbox cleaned out. (There's over 4,000 still--was close to six...)
Anyway, thanks for that. Yes, I live for those never easily answerable questions, because they make things interesting--as opposed to worrying about new trends, videogames, "going out" or "partying", football, "so you think you can dance" what have you--the many upon many trivialities my peers engage in... Don't, by the way, take any offense by that statement, nothings wrong with any ONE of those things, I'm just frustrated by our culture of TVism.
Thanks again for another awesome post. You've gone a long way in helping me come a long way, been forgiving when I've been a chump and have helped me to consider a lot of perspectives on things. Gratefully yours,
Rev. David A. Reedy...
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
26 Sep 09
We have free will. Just because God knows what the outcome is...doesn't mean we didn't freely choose it. It's not really that complicated.
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
27 Sep 09
I wish I could so quickly, and easily see it that way. Perhaps years of researching script theory, various social dynamics, quantum physics, and the touching upon Jungian theory... complicates things a bit.
Choices or not, I find that when I make a decision that the external world changes, producing both elements that coincide with my new thought, and those that resist, this is the aspect I think that boggles me, well it's one of a couple at least.
Thanks very much for your input, I look forward to learning some more from you--let's always be civil (but I suspect that goes without saying), but be sure to always feel free to question--to get me to question... Thanks again...
dr...
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
27 Sep 09
It is humans who make it complicated, just by trying to understand. It is what it is...but we cannot leave it alone and let it be what it is.
Of course we will be civil...