which better?

Indonesia
April 16, 2008 5:29am CST
which better? anime from japan or western? give me the reason why you like it?
1 person likes this
12 responses
@jeseravi (337)
19 Apr 08
japaneese anime, because western 'anime' is not 'anime' It's called graphic novels... so ya, if you like 'anime' you're liking japaneese animation novels
21 Apr 08
Er, slight correction here; anime = cartoon manga = graphic novel
• Philippines
6 Sep 08
Animes from Japan are the original while animes from the west are just 'imitation' of the animes from Japan. Don't get me wrong, what I mean is that anime started in Japan, so technically, the people from the west just 'copied' the style (which is anime) and made a one of their own. I think Avatar: The Last Airbender is an example of an anime from the west. So, this means that animes that came from Japan are better because the producers are more experienced in that area.
• Philippines
21 Apr 08
definitely japan anime, because the illustrations are more detailed that gives the unique looks and impressions with every characters, and the story plots are great too.
21 Apr 08
Anime... or cartoons... anime... or cartoons. So long as it is GOOD, I don't care where it came from. I'm not going to shun an excellent piece of story telling (or comedy or horror or whatever) just because it's not from Japan. That would be childish. Along the same lines, I'm not going to declare every single piece of entertainment that comes out of Japan as being amazing. They can produce rubbish too. Currently Japanese entertainment is outstripping American, in my fields of taste anyway. However, 15 years ago the Americans were doing much better. They fell behind the Japanese though, putting profit before style (Cartoon Network and Disney are, in my opinion, the worst companies for doing this). However, American companies are seeing their profit margins die off as people turn down their tired, old garbage for the fresh and interesting stuff from the east. This is why they are 'copying' the artistic and animation styles... but they are not seeing that people don't watch anime just for the style (which they copy very poorly). However, those of us who grew up on good animation, both western and eastern, are coming of age and moving into the employment of these companies, or starting our own. People are now bringing the things they want to see, the things they miss from their childhood favourites, into the world of western animation. A great conglomerate of the best of the old, the western and the eastern will soon be being produced. We are already seeing western money being used to produce eastern shows and films... the transition has begun. Way to go prophetic and bizarre, Shard. Silence, you!
@chooseus (172)
• Indonesia
21 Apr 08
Anime from Japan It will be better....
@helsin (57)
• United States
16 May 08
the anime from japan is the best becuase they pay alot more attention to detail and they have been doing it longer
@diansinta (7544)
• Indonesia
19 Apr 08
I love both of them. I like Dragon balls, Sailormoon, Card captor Sakura, Candy- candy, Detective conan. I also likes Powerpuff Girls, Dexter, his lab and Didi his sister, I can't choose. each of them have speciality.
@jep_toyo (1606)
• Philippines
17 Apr 08
i love japanese anime!...
@megumiart (3771)
• United States
18 Apr 08
Japanese anime is the only anime. Any others are just imitations or "comic book" cartoons.
• Philippines
17 Apr 08
Hmm, in my opinion, I think anime is better than western cartoon. Well, for one thing, the drawing/graphics of an anime is really good, and also I like the story plot of anime than the cartoons. More entertaining and fascinating.
• Indonesia
16 Apr 08
i like japanesse anime
• Barbados
17 Apr 08
Of course anime from Japan is the best. They made it of course. Western "fraud" anime doesn't even come close to the quality of japanese anime. Better characters, stories, action, animation and music - the Japanese are kings of it. To them its more than a business, its culture. The only Western anime ripoff I've seen that was good was Teen Titans but its still doesn't do a good job of imitating anime. Bottom line, the predecessor is always the better.