Bananas (as we know them) may go extinct

@irdsm1 (288)
United States
April 24, 2008 5:42am CST
Hello. We all love bananas (why else would you have this in your sortie?). But the banana as we know it may not be able to last much longer. The cause? Not global warming or industrialization, but a disease. Panama disease attacks banana roots, and is a highly contagious fungus. It can ruin entire crops of bananas. Not fun at all. We no longer have the Gros Michel banana because of this disease. Up until the 1950s we had a type of banana called the Gros Michel or "big Mike" which was popular and better suited for exportation because of its thicker skin. It also, according to many people, tasted better. Unfortunately many Gros Michel producers were infected with Panama disease and we now have the Cavendish banana. The problem is that although the Cavendish is more resistant to Panama disease than the Gros Michel, the disease continues to mutate while the banana does not! Bananas are little more than clones, which propagate mainly by root. Because of this bananas all have very similar DNA and all are, and will probably continue to be, susceptible to this fungus. While our banana supplies are now stable, it may not last forever. An article about it (I've read a few and they mostly have the same info) www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2005-06/can-fruit-be-saved So what do you think? Maybe genetic modification is needed? It has been used successfully on many foods. Or maybe we should just be very careful? Discuss! Dan
2 people like this
4 responses
@liquorice (3887)
24 Apr 08
Well that's really sad, everyone I know likes bananas! However, I don't really like the idea of genetic modification as it's a bit of an unknown factor and you never quite know what the effects are going to be long term. I prefer to leave things to nature where possible even though this can sometimes have bad consequences (like potentially no more bananas..) I say we just have to be very careful ( - not sure what this would involve exactly, but sounds better to me :)
2 people like this
@irdsm1 (288)
• United States
24 Apr 08
Sadly the fungus can travel on loose soil from shoes or whatever. Very hard to contain. It hasn't gotten all the bananas yet but it is definitely a possibility :( Thanks for the post Dan
@paid2write (5201)
24 Apr 08
It may be possible for genetic modification to produce a resistant type of banana, but I would not buy it. I always buy fair trade bananas, grown and sold by independent producers. I had not heard about the disease but it does seem to be a threat to some varieties of banana. I think more research needs to be done to find how to stop the spread of the fungus, preferably by a natural solution.
@irdsm1 (288)
• United States
24 Apr 08
I agree that we shouldn't go all willy-nilly on GM-ing stuff, but it has proved a reliable and safe method thus far. Alot of corn, for example, is GM-ed to kill corn burrowing parasites. Natural preventatives are the first thing we should consider of course! GM should be last resort. Dan
@Nardz13 (5055)
• New Zealand
24 Apr 08
Hi there. Well Im not really a banana eater, those things give me the sore tummy, so I stay away from them. However my children and husband love them though. Personally I dont have a problem with the banana disppearing, but for others it would be a big loss. Have a great day, thats all I have to say...
1 person likes this
@irdsm1 (288)
• United States
24 Apr 08
Lol okay maybe not everyone loves bananas ;p Dan
@LouieWpHs04 (4555)
• United States
25 Apr 08
Well hopefully they figure out some sort of solution! I love bananas, 'specially ones with whipcream on'em. =D