American Idol: Was Carly's husband to blame for her getting voted off?

Well even Carly has a rocker kinda look to her. Even though she sings more Diva. Shes got a half sleeve on one of her arms. I was looking at it the other day and it looks like a tat of Amy Winehouse's Face ?!?! Anyone? Anyways. I have had many piercings and funky hair and been discrimnated against many times. I wouldn't doubt that America would do that to her. Her husband is so hot though!

Thats quite the conspiracy theory, one which I wholly doubt. If that were really the case, she would have been gone week one as they showed him just about every week. I always find it a little odd that people are afraid of those of us who are heavily tattooed. I'm glad to see you don't subscribe to that theory

I don't think her husband had anything to do with it. They are suppose to be voted on talent, but I think there are some tiny boopers who are voting for the cutest instead of the one who can sing the best. It is really ashame that it is a popularity contest, I really thought it would be Brooke or Jason to go home this time. Again I was wrong. I don't like Syeshia too much, and I missed her performance, so I can't say if she was good or not, but based on what I did see, it should have been 1 of the 2 I mentioned above that went home, and certainly not Carly.

I can not think of one reason that she was voted off. I think that she is one of the best singers there, and that her last performance was wonderful. i really do not think that it is because of her husband's looks, it seems too idiotic. i really can not think of one reason why she was voted off.

I would hope that wasn't the reason. Her husband has been shown many times. I always thought she was going to be voted off for already having a record deal. she is talented; however, she wasn't one of my favorites. I couldn't believe that syesha was in the bottom two. i thought jason would have been. it will be interesting to see how the remaining contestants are going to do Neal Diamonds songs.

I doubt that people think that way! I think that people find the ones that they like and vote for them, but it just might have been that her fans weren't voting that night. AI says it all the time, you have to vote to keep your star in the competition!

If people votes against her because of her hubby's tats, then they are IDIOTS!

if that is why she got kicked off that would be so crazy to me. the level of peoples awareness in what they do and think is amazing to me. judgment of others by looking at them, is sad.

I was wondering if maybe the reason she didn't get many votes is because the show is taking place in conservative Christian America, and for anyone who isn't familiar with the Jesus Christ Superstar production, the song is probably going to come off sounding blasphemous. I can see a lot of people freaking out about such a song. I don't think the tattoos have much to do with anything. If that were the case, she wouldn't have made it so far into the competition because both of them have been seen multiple times with tattoos. People would be used to it by now. I am also wondering why American Idol is having themes based on singers that were famous YEARS ago, instead of people who are more current. Even 80's music would be okay. But c'mon, next week the mentor is Neil Diamond. Neil freakin' Diamond? Who under the age of 30 is even going to know who that is? Most of the voting demographic are teeny-boppers with too much time on their hands. Why are they not catering to them? Speaking of teeny-boppers voting, why is Jason Castro still there? He's awful.

I think thats just grasping at straws, I don't think so, I would hope the american people would be above not voting for someone because of her husbands appearance.

I think Carly was the lowest votes for many reasons, but not because of her husband's tattoos. If that was the case I don't think she would have made it to the top twelve! I think she never really found her musical identity during the show. She also pandered more to Simon than to the general public who held her fate in her hands. As well as the fact that a lot of people never really got over her failed record when they think Idol is for people who never had a shot before. Also I don't think she picked up many of Kristy Lee's voters. I did like Carly, but I think it was her time to go.