Abortion: How mad would you be if your parents forced you to have one

@tjades (3591)
Jamaica
April 28, 2008 10:58am CST
I am watching this show on TV where the parents forced their teenaged daughter to have an abortion. The girl is now an adult and her son has tracked her down and wants to see her. She was elated as she had always tried to contact her son but the adoption board had restrictions against birth mothers making contact with the adopted child. Even now her mother thinks she is a fool for agreeing to see her son. How would you react to your parents if they did this to you? Would you be eternally mad at them? I know they would have a lot of heat to put up with from me especially if they were still so negative toward my child even after so many years. How about you? Would you be able to be forgiving and understanding toward your parents?
2 people like this
10 responses
• United States
28 Apr 08
As a father, I feel that there should be some say from the father of the child. The mother obviously has her rights to either choose to have the child, or terminate, or offer the child up for adoption. But where are the father's rights?Parents forcing their children to have either an abortion or give the child up for adotion is outside of their scope of rights. No parent can force their child to do either action. Parents have inherent rights over their children, and making a decision such as that is not one of them. How would I react if a parent forced that on me? Well, being that I am not a woman, I can not respond to that exactly as you are hoping for. I can answer it from the father's perspective. I would fight for that child until I was blue in the face. A potential grand-parent should not interfere with this issue. The only time that a potential grand-parent should have any input on a matter such as this would be if a) the father is not in the picture, b) the mother came to them and asked for their opinion, or c) the mother is a rape victim. Still, the overall choice is LEGALLY the mother's (and maybe someday soon, the father's too). Would I be able to forgive my parents for forcing either an abortion or an adoption? An abortion, I would not be able to forgive them for. That is stepping over the bounds of parenthood. The courts could even deem that as a form of abuse. As for the adoption part of the senario, I would harbor negative feelings towards my parents for a great deal of time, but I wouldn't feel the distain and discust for their interference as I would with the abortion issue. With the adoption, I would probably be able to forgive. Abortion, definitely not!
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
28 Apr 08
Welcome to mylot and let me hasten to say that your scope on the issue from a male's perspective is very much embraced. These topics really usually focus on the female and leave out the male. I agree with your views but I'd like to hear your views on the same issues from a different perspective. That as a teenage boy who is still in school and got his teenage girlfriend pregnant. I ask this because many times this is how the father gets left behind in such matters. He is too young to put up a successful fight against the girls parents and maybe cant go to his parents for assistance. If you were this teenager how would you react?
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
28 Apr 08
Well said. I totally believe that children should be allowed to face up to the consequences of their actions. Parents are there to guide and protect not to take over their lives. If the child was educated as to what that aspect of life entails but still choose to act in a manner that will put them at risk then they should be allowed to bear the responsibilities. Other than that the resentment they may feel for causing them to give up their child may never abate even with the passage of time. It is a difficult situation for all involved. I dont think I would bail out my child boy or girl out of the situation though. I'll offer my support the best way I can but it would have now become reality that had to be dealt with. They would now have to plan their lives accordingly and would need to realise that they gave up a part of their teenage years through their own actions. The parents may be very hurt but two wrongs do not make a right and asking their child to abort or give up their own grandchild for adoption is just wrong. One point you made in your first comment is where rape is involved. I draw the line there. I most certainly would carry no such child myself. Would I ask that my child do abortion too......????? God knows that is one tough bridge to cross as i cant see myself asking her do it. I would have to let her choose.
• United States
28 Apr 08
From the perspective of a teenage father, I would still feel the same. Just because these parents are still children themselves, they do have rights and responsibilities to their unborn child. Although, the father may not have the means or support necessary to take care of the child himself, he has the responsibility to do what he can. If it means that he has to put his future on hold so he can go out and get a job so he can support his child, so be it. I would still have to say that both of these young parents knew what the consequnces of their actions were. They would have had to have known that there would be the potential of pregnancy with what they were doing. Therefore, they would assumed the risk, and thus must take the responsibility. Most teenage parents are afraid to step up and take the responsibility. That may be because their parents have taken all of the responsibility away from them. Our society has shifted towards the trend of children not moving out of their parent's home until their mid-late 20's! I would still want to be a part of that child's life. I would also want a say in what the course of action would be with the child before it was born. It is a responsibility that men (and boys who decide to make decisions like men) must take.
@qtfrog99 (279)
• United States
28 Apr 08
I am a little confused as to if her parents made her have an abortion how did her son survive to be looking for her?
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
28 Apr 08
Oh my goodness thank you for that. It should be adoption. Give up the child for adoption. That was ahuge oversight on my part. Initially when the parents took the child away I thought it would have been an abortion so that word just got syuck in my head. Good Lord. Thank you very much. I wish we could delete and make corrections. I didnt even notice that until I read your comment. I was still distracted watching and posting at the same time.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
28 Apr 08
Took the daughter away that is, saying she was going to travel around singing for the military. I thought they were going to let her have an abortion and stay away for a while. I try to guess what the writers plot will be when I watch movies sometimes.
@steph07 (38)
• Canada
29 Apr 08
i think even with the best intention to their daughters, parents are wrong to force them to abort, and it is not only for the fact that they are killing an innocent baby(if 2 months or more, under 2 months if i am right the baby is still not considered to be formed enough to be considered as a person). The real problem is someone who is forced to do something traumatic against her will, will never forget it and will always recent the ones who forced them to commit that act. so the parents are making enemies of their children. i have seen some cases and mostly it finishes by daughters leaving home earlier or hating their parents so much that won't even call them by phone.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
That is true Steph. it does make enimies of mothers and daughters whose relationships are sometimes never repaired. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
• Australia
29 Apr 08
I wouldn't allow my parents to force me to have one. I would move out and go live with someone who understands and supports me or I would go to one of those houses for pregnant women. I would never allow my parents to do that to me because that's something that could affect me for my entire life, even scar me.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
I agree with you SassyKittyKat. My option would be to rebel and leave home. Its to have to face up to the ghost in the closet and surely having had an abortion must be on of the hardest ghost to face. Thanks for sharing(lol)
1 person likes this
@jesbellaine (4139)
• Philippines
29 Apr 08
If I am very young and can't take care of the child, neither do my parents then I would agree for an adoption so that the kid would have a better life but if my parents can support me until I reach the right age to work on my own and for the child then I would never ever like to have my baby adopted. Supposed they forced me to have the child adopted, yes, I would be hurt but sooner or later, it will be gone as long as I know that my child is in good hands then maybe.. someday, I get to know my own angel and nothing can ever stop me from doing that as long as my kid wants to know me. :)
@mikeysmom (2088)
• United States
29 Apr 08
i think abortion is a terrible thing period. i am a bit confused by your post though because you say they forced their teenage daughter to have an abortion and then you say her son is trying to track her down. that makes no sense.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
Hi Mikeysmom. I understand your confusion. I explained the reason for the mix up in the first comment I made. Sorry about that. Thanks for participating though. (lol)
@MsCYPRAH (394)
29 Apr 08
This is a very tricky subject - adoption, because we cannot judge it in black and white terms. There are always so many factors involved which are known to only the people they concern. Most people would be deeply unhappy at being forced to give away their child. But we must put this in context. Depending on how old the mother is now, the times she grew up in, when she was a teenager, were very different to our modern day. Back then it was a stigma and acute family shame to have a child without being married, especially if the mother is barely a child herself. So the obvious action at the time was to give up such children for adoption. It caused a lot of pain and hurt to many mothers who were at the mercy of their own parents and the authorities, but very few pregnant youngsters could escape that fate. The aim was to pretend there was no pregnancy and life was supposed to carry on as normal. But for that young girl who had to give away her child, life would have been anything but normal. Contacting the child is another matter. It should be entirely up to the mother and child in this case. They are now adults and free to do what they wish relating to one another so that's a good thing. I suppose the older parents are probably worried on two fronts: what to do with the guilt that will come out of seeing such a reconciliation, and perhaps worry that the meeting might not go well and hurt the mother even more. So there are lots of emotions riding on this contact and it is natural that some people involved, especially the older parent who instigated the adoption, would feel very anxious about the whole thing. As to the mother, it is her life and it is her birth son. If he wants to see her, she should welcome the opportunity and see how it goes, without too many expectations. Just for her own peace of mind for the rest of her life, and the possibility that she could still be a kind of mother in his life, they should meet, and good luck to them.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
Hi MsCYPRAH. They did meet and it was a happy reunion. The son turned out to be a pastor and they were a very religious family in the first place. Very valuable points there. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
@tinkerick (1257)
• United States
28 Apr 08
I'm a grown woman with my own children now, but if I were still that age and my parents forced me to have an abortion I think I'd be very sad. If you wanted to keep your child but your parents forced you to get rid of it in that manner, that would be very heartbreaking. Adoption on the other hand, is a bit more hopeful. The child is at least still alive and living a good life (hopefully). Plus there is the possiblity that you would one day see them again. I think her mother is wrong in thinking it a bad thing for the girl to meet her son. If both parties are wanting to meet (for right reasons) then it can be a very joyous and life building thing.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
28 Apr 08
I agree with you. I dont know if you noticed the mix up of terms and meanings in the post but I will point it out as it is a mistake the first commenter made me aware of. I thought of posting on abortion as I thought the parents were going to let her have an abortion. They actually sent her away and made her give up the child for adoption. So with the thought of abortion in my head I posted the discussion with the story of the adoption. Not wise to watch and post I guess. Its good to have you comment on both though. I agree with your view on both acts.
@chas1808 (20)
• United States
29 Apr 08
i would have tried to run away to b able to keep the baby if that didnt work i dont know what else i would have done. i would have def been really pissed you should be able to make your own choices, and being a mother is not a choice your parents should be able to make 4 u.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
Strong point there Chas. I dont think getting rid my baby is an option that should be forced on me either. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
• United States
29 Apr 08
tjades, I think that the lady took a strong stand for having the baby and not getting an abortion. To many women that I know have had abortions. They live with the sound of those abortions everyday. Those women blame their parents for having to get the abortions. This grandmother and grandfather needs to leave this woman alone. She did the hardest thing in life,when she gave her baby up for adoption. Every child wants to know who their biological parents are, at some time in life.It sounds like this mother and son need each other and love being around each other. The grandparents need to grow up. There daughter has grown up and she needs to be able to see her son now.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 May 08
I agree with you Shartsell. I was so surprised when she objected to her daughter meeting her own son. It just never serves any purpose to try to sweep things under th carpet. One day that carpet will get worn and need changing. All the secrets will be exposed then. Thanks for sharing. (lol)