American idol vs Brooke White

I thought she was a great singer myself. I was upset when she got voted off last week. I voted for her from the start. I hope she still makes it big.

Yes she is a very pretty girl, and also really sweet and talented! I was really mad when she got kicked from the show! I think it defeniatly should have been Jason! I am really sick of him. He's boring and sounds the same every week! Brooke was a really entertaining performer!! I think her leaving, and Michael Johns leaving, were both wrong!

needless to say at this point in the competition...everyone is good, but someone HAS to go and thats the contest rule. She had a bad night and since 2 songs were performed it did have an effect on her. The first song was TOO well known and it wasn't that powerful of a performance. I think she's good. Very fresh and clean. But the competition is harsh. I was more upset that Carly went home since that was a big shocker. I have a feeling anyone within the top 5 will easily get a recording contract hands down. Here's my opinion on the remaining contestants: Jason- nice sound to his voice...but it lacks versatility. He'll only probably be good in one style. I was slightly disappointed when he did the somewhere over the rainbow song because I grew up with the version he did and the original will make you cry...and it didn't happen for me. He doesn't have much power in his voice but the sound is nice. More of a recording studio artist I would say then live. I'd say he's still in the competition now because of his female fanbase. Shaisha (dunno if I spelled that right..sorry)- Good power, nice presence and very fun. I really liked her on the Andrew Lloyd Webber week. She was very entertaining. and I don't think she'll win, but she will make it big. She'll probably end up on Broadway like Clay David C- My personal favorite because he's different from what you normally here. Like Blake from last year he does try to bring his own 'flava' into the mix which is why he's getting good votes. But I don't have high hopes on him winning, just like Blake. Last yeah the song was more tailored to a pop/r&b sound. I don't know how this years song will go but I'm sure it'll be more for David A then it would be David C since you're not allowed to change the arrangement. David A- he makes me laugh since every time he speaks the girls in the crowd go crazy. I'm beyond those crazy obsessive years but I know the frantic teens and grandmas are helping him along. No doubt though he's good, but he still needs to mature just a little.

yes she is pretty but i like the beauty of kristy lee cook. my wife also finds kristy lee cook some kind of like a beauty pagent contestant. but brook looks like a very sweet person. she looks like she really is a good nanny. but to bad she was booted already.