American Idol 2008, David A or David C?

I like both of them also, I think they are both very talented. Its going to be a very close race, but I can't help but think that David C. will probably get it, he just seems more like the star type. But whoever doesn't win, doesn't lose out entirely, I think that they are already getting a record deal out of it, everybody's a winner actually...but we'll see who gets to claim the American Idol winner for 2008.

Yes, they are both very talented... and they have their own strengths and weaknesses... but i prefer David Cook... since he has proven how versatile he is in all his performances... it is like he can sing anything and make it his own... i have nothing against David Archuleta... and i think he will have a successful career after American Idol...

I like both of them. My favorite is David Archuleta. He is really cute and has a great voice. David Cook is a great singer also. So it is really tough this year. Whoever wins I think they will both have a great singing career ahead of them.

no doubt that the american idol winner this season is COOK. you can let cook, cook it up. he makes a cool version of any song he sings. archuleta is a good singer but he can only sing ballads. well this is only my opinion. but i think this year is cooks year.

At the start of the season, I was really routing for Archuleta. I saw him auditioning for the show and fell in love with his voice and smile instantly. But through the course of the season, I admire the performance of Cook. He's also hot! hahaha... So now, I'm not really sure who I want to win. Both of them are not ony talented but also charming and hot! I'll be routing for them both since I really can't make up my mind right now. lol

Cook. He's very versatile in his performances. But i have to admit, they're both talented and this is gonna be a tough competition.

The both have great voices, but I am hoping for David Cook. I think he is more versatile, and I also think that he is ready for will come his way as The Idol. David A. is still very young and has plenty of time for all of that.