Lohan vs Lavigne

most definitely Avril! she has the looks as well as the ability to move millions of album units.

does avril's music really qualify her as a pop starlet? i guess i would say avril because she has put out a lot more hit songs. i think lindsay can sing though. i really liked when she sang in her movie freaky friday. i think it went to her head though and her songs got a little too personal. she just went out of control and i think it is going to take time for her to get back to where she was.

Well I guess that really depends on what grounds that you are looking for. If you're looking for the controversies and the scandals and whatnot I guess Lindsay Lohan will be the winner hands down. For who is the better person by how she is portrayed on tv Im going for Avril Lavigne. Even if she is a rocker chick and might be on the not so goody-goody side but over all she is pretty good. Might have an edgy personality but she keeps her private life private and if it needs to be shown in public only the proper ones are shown. As for who is the better singer/celebrity Avril wins this round hands down. She has her own style, and she's famous for being a musician and not for all her escapades and scandals. So for me the winner of the contest is Avril Lavigne over all. I just didnt like her sudden change from rocker chick to bubbly and pop kinda rocker chick.