Carrots, what kind should I plant?
By Nykkee
@Nykkee (2522)
Canada
May 30, 2008 6:28am CST
I have been starting a vegetable garden this Spring and I was thinking about planting some carrots. However, when I went to the store to get some seeds, I was shocked to discover that there are actually several different kind of carrots, and I don't know one from the other. Does anyone here at Mylot know anything about carrots? What is the difference between the types? Is one better tasteing or easier to grow than the others? Does it make a difference or are they all pretty much the same? Can someone tell me what type of carrot seeds I should get. My grandmother used to have babay carrots and they were really good but I always thought that was just about how early you harvested them, not the type of carrot, but maybe I'm wrong. The picture that hoepfully will attach with this discussion shows the type of carrots I would like. Please help.
2 people like this
3 responses
@royal52gens (5488)
• United States
1 Jun 08
I like both the long and the short kinds. Our soil is very hard and we have lots of clay. Normally, the carrots would grow crooked and knarly. So I mix my carrot seeds with my radish seeds. The roots of the radishes keep the soil broke open enough for the carrots to grow straight. When the radishes are ready to be picked, they also help to space the carrots out from each other. This process is called Companion Planting.
2 people like this
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
2 Jun 08
I like you plant radishes, but with everything I grow. They are the first to propogate, so they mark every row, early! And when you harvest them, they both aerate & loosen the soil!
I am actually thinking with the kind of soil that you have, until you have the time to amend the soil with compost & sand...and remove some trees (for more sunshine)you may NOT want to grow root crops. Carrots are inexpensive to buy (I know it's not like growing your own..or nor do they taste as good)BUT, at present your growing conditions are not optimum!
After my carrots have been thinned to about 4" apart...I plant onion sets in between them..the onions help to break up the soil...and totally deters Carrot Fly..that can dessimate a crop.
Happy Gardening!
1 person likes this
@peavey (16936)
• United States
30 May 08
The type of carrot you should grow depends on your soil and growing season. Most carrots like sandy, loose soil, but there are kinds that grow in heavy clay. Here's a page that explains the difference: http://www.carrotgardeningtips.com/typesofcarrots.html
Maybe that will help make up your mind which one you need to grow.
2 people like this
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
30 May 08
I would love to answer all your questions...and might be able to, but first I have to ask a few questions;
a) What is your soil type? Sandy? Loam? Rocky?
b) what is your growing season?
c) Sweet or standard?
d) Early or late harvest
Carrots usually range from 72 to 125 days to harvest. Most grow best in somewhat sandy loam, because as they are growing they need to be able to move the soil. It helps to cultivate them! They range from "Healthmaster F1 Hybrid"-which is a deep reddish orange, which has 30-35% more beta-carotene (because of color) to "Yellowstone F1 Hybrids" which are canary-yellow colored and have the sweetest flavor when eaten raw.......And then there's the old standby "Nantes" which our grandmothers grew...and hundreds in between! Haven't helped you much but if you like, you can sign me up as a friend and then you can PM me, and would love to help! ( owned a Nursery for 13 years)
Happy Gardening! Cheers!
2 people like this
@Nykkee (2522)
• Canada
30 May 08
I don't know what loam is, but out soil is reddish, so and it has alot of rocks and stuff in it. I would prefer sweet carrots if they will grow here. My garden doesn't get alot of sun, it only has partial sun to shade at times. I need to cut some trees down from behind it.
1 person likes this