Do you think teachers has the right to hurt the students?

South Korea
June 3, 2008 4:27pm CST
my husband nephew come home with blood in his shirt..i ask him why? he said my teacher bit me ..i was so shocked and was very angry how come the teacher have the right to hurt students..i know students are very hard to handle with but hurting them is not the best way..my husband said it a korean way.. what do you think?
5 people like this
13 responses
@Jemina (5770)
4 Jun 08
Well, what I can say is that if it is allowed by the culture there is nothing we can do about it. In Thailand, teachers have also the right to hurt problematic students. But if you are a parent and you don't want to kids to get hurt no matter how naughty they are then send them to international schools where hurting is not allowed.
@Jemina (5770)
4 Jun 08
So, tell me what you do in Korea. I was constantly asked by a friend to move to Korea from Thailand but I didn't really think I would like it there. I have worked with some of them in the Philippines and I like their foods.
• South Korea
4 Jun 08
thats right..jemina..thanks
1 person likes this
• South Korea
7 Jun 08
hi jemina..teaching korea is a good job for those who wanted to teach..the salary is really good...some korean students are interested some are not..they find it boring but korean students are smart too.
1 person likes this
@abroji (3247)
• India
3 Jun 08
Hello marketing07, here in India education is a state (provincial) matter, and hence policies on student - teacher relations deffer from state to state. I am in the state of Kerala in south India and here we have strict rules against physical abuse of students by teachers. A teacher beating up a student to shed blood is unthinkable. It is barbarian, horrible. Gone are the days here that a teacher carries a cane with him/her to beat students. I am very sorry to hear about your son.
@abroji (3247)
• India
3 Jun 08
Yes marketing, I erroneously put it as your son, sorry for that.
• South Korea
3 Jun 08
oh yes,physical abuse on the students is normal here ..teachers has their own stick when they entered in the class room..thanks..he is my nephew
1 person likes this
@abroji (3247)
• India
4 Jun 08
Thank you marketing for choosing my response as the best one. I feel honored. All the best.
@lkbooi (16070)
• Malaysia
4 Jun 08
I totally disagree a teacher should have the right to hurt his student both mentally and physically. Teacher is supposed to be a professional worker so he must know how handle kids’ problems instead of using violence to stop the problem. As a parent definitely I don’t like to see my kid to be hurt by his teacher in school.
• South Korea
7 Jun 08
that right my friend thank you..
@DarkDancer (1011)
• Dayton, Ohio
3 Jun 08
Wow, I am in the U.S. and here that would be bizarre, and actionable (lawsuits would happen).
• South Korea
3 Jun 08
yes, thats what im thinkin..thanks
@phoenix25 (1541)
• United States
4 Jun 08
I agree with you. Lawsuit! That is pretty weird for a teacher to draw blood, though. I definitely wouldn't want to go to school in Korea.
@nicholejade (2430)
• Canada
3 Jun 08
In this day and age it is a sad truth kids do not give respect anymore. In this case I don't understand why the teacher bite him as you never mentioned what he did to cause the biting. There had to have been something that your husbands nephew did to cause the teacher to do this. The big thing right now on youtube is a teacher and a student fighting. Is the teacher justified in doing so. I beleive she/he is as they need to hold their own ground. Kids these days are not like when I was growing up. They are quite rude and will and do anything. Did you ask your nephew what he did?
• South Korea
3 Jun 08
oh yes, he said that one of his classmates told the teacher that he bully some students,,and he said i never do that..thanks
• Canada
4 Jun 08
There had to be something more than a student just saying that he bullied another student? That doesn't seem right at all. I do not agree with the drawing blood nor the biting. I think you should be making a meeting not only with the teacher and the child and yourselves but the principal as well. There is something that is not being said here.
• Philippines
5 Jun 08
What do you mean Korean way? Is he studying in Korea or what? Or he has a Korean professor? Here in the Philippines hurting physically is prohibited especially when it comes to Professors. Giving direct assault by saying foul languages are not allowed also. The students can complain to the administrators or school authority if they violated the rules of the school. That is considered already as abuse if they are going to do that.
• South Korea
7 Jun 08
yes, here in korea some teacher will hurt students as discipline that is aloud for some parents..oe some schools..yes,i do believe that in the philippines you can complin,,and the tescher will be punish that was great and i like that..thanks
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
5 Jun 08
They don't have any right to hurt any of their students. And if that will be reported for sure, he might end up losing his license for doing that. They are there to educate and discipline in a right way. They have to be that huge patient since it is essential in their fields. No one would ever trust him nor want him to be the teacher of their kids if that is his way in disciplining the students!
@youless (112561)
• Guangzhou, China
4 Jun 08
That's so terrible. No matter what, a teacher can never have physical and mental hurt for the students. This teacher is so wrong and he/she is not even qualified to be a teacher. Such kind of teacher shall be fired. I love China
• South Korea
4 Jun 08
thanks for sharing my friend
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
7 Jun 08
teacher-student relationship  - it is very important to have a very happy teacher-student relationship as it helps a lot.
Hello dear marketing friend. I am so sorry to hear that your son was beaten by his teacher as some punishment, which is not the way a teacher is supposed to use to teach his student. I have been a teacher for years, but I have never beaten any students. I always try my best to be their friends to have them behave better in my class and I am very happy that my students love me as their teacher.
@ellie333 (21016)
3 Jun 08
Hi Marketing, we used to have the slipper and the cane as punishment here in the UK and in fact it did work as a deterent, there is none now so the kids think they can get away with anything but to draw blood is a step too far and I would personally be VERY ANGRY at the teacher for having done that. Ellie :D
• South Korea
3 Jun 08
yes thats right..thats why he wanted to transfer to another school.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
3 Jun 08
Not in the US. I was slapped by a teacher in 6th grade (we're talking the late 1960's here) and she was fired. I didn't even say anything but another kid must have. Schools here are concerned with lawsuits, among other things.
• South Korea
3 Jun 08
that was great..hope it happens here too
1 person likes this
• South Korea
8 Jun 08
Absolutely not. Teachers should be the second parents of the students. They can correct the students and teach them the right way of doing bad things correctly but they don't have the right to hurt the students. Here in korea, if you hit the students you can be imprison. From the time you choose teaching as your profession, it comes in package the obligation of being the second parents of your students.
• China
5 Jun 08
I think it is a very bad way to educate the student! I also hate this way,because the bit is not just break the body,but also the so little heart of the student!