Mariah or David cooks version of always be my baby

no one beats mariah carey's own version! coz she's always the original! she is such a legendary artist in the world!

david cook sure did give justice to the song but it is a classic mariah hit. and mariah made it famous. so i give it to mariah.

I've heard david cook's version of that song, and I must say that he gave justice on it. I mean, he sang it well. I do love his version. and his voice really soothes my soul....and I like david cook.

Although Mariah Carey's version was ok, I love David Cook's version. It made me appreciate the song more.

i havent heard his version of it, but david cooks billy jean was awesome i think its better than the original

My 16 year old daughter thinks David Cooks was better.She downloaded it onto her Ipod.I thought he did an awesome job,however I still prefer Mariah Carey. Who did you want to win? I wanted the younger David to win.He seemed so passionate about his music,you could tell he really loved it.I have no doubt that we are going to see several of the top Idols this year even though they didn't win.Most of them were star material. Jas

Mariah for sure. I don't think David Cook should have won American Idol, i think David Archuetta should have won.