best american idol for you

DAVID COOK is the best American Idol for me but I also count on my top three are: CARRIE UNDERWOOD and KELLY CLARKSON... They have great voice and talent! Brilliant in the music industry... =)

I must agree with the last person, Ruben Studdard would have to be the best winner of American Idol, a close 2nd would be Fantasia. I just love to watch the show each year and although I live in New Zealand and can see it each week here, it is hard to see the results show earlier on the computer or on the Ellen show.

I liked Carrie Underwood from the moment I first heard her sing during auditions. Simon Cowell had said she would make it to the end and she did. She is my favourite of the winners and as far as I can tell, the most successful in her career.

Ruben Studdard. I loved Ruben on American Idol, and of course, still do. His voice is amazing and his smile radiates and is infectious. You can't help but smile when you see him. I literally got chills when he sang "A whole New World" during season 2.