why are americans sterotyped as sensationalists?
@Hatley (163776)
Garden Grove, California
July 5, 2008 2:47pm CST
I got this idea for a disussion from another I had just answered
'and one of the responders accused Americans of being sensationalists, now that tees me off a bit as to begin'
with judging all americans because of our hyped up Media
is so wrong. I don't think we are all that different as individuals from Canadians or any other country. What is
'your view on this, mylotters?
3 people like this
9 responses
@friendship (2084)
• Canada
6 Jul 08
I don't assume that Americans are sensationalists . Will you still be mad if someone calls Americans as melancholic?
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
7 Jul 08
hi friendship no of course not I am not mad now,just irritated that we are judged that way, and maybe some are melancholic'
but thats just some, just calling us names does not make it so you know.
@Ivan_Ivan (13)
•
6 Jul 08
People who say that are far from the fact; others are not sensationalists because they are not free to speak.
We have freedom even to criticize our own chiefs, parents, churches, or the president, without fear of reprisals.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
7 Jul 08
ivan ivan yes we do have freedom, and mostof us use
it and maybe sometimes we are misunderstood but hurray
for our freedom.
@Angelwhispers (8978)
• United States
5 Jul 08
I agree with you Hatley. What amazes me that the very people who say such things are indeed sensationalists themselves for believing everything they read or hear about "Americans" in general. Generalizing any group of people bothers me, when we do this it shows our own ignorance. As sure as a stereotypical comment comes out of our mouth or we make a post there are going to be 10 people to show how wrong we are.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
hi angelwhispers you are so right and I debated for awhile
'before doing this as I did not really want to hurt anybodys'feelings just give vent to the fact that all americans are not like the media. I just feel we should not judge other people as we do not ever have all the facts.
@AmbiePam (93740)
• United States
5 Jul 08
From reading discsusions from many different people on mylot from varying countries, I have realized everyone on mylot. including Americans, stereotype badly. It surprises me how ready people are to make judgments about Americans when they have never been here, or maybe have visited once and paint everyone with the same brush. I'm constantly astounded by the solutions foreigners come up with for America's problems. I'm not belittling other people's opinions, but we all have to be careful about making snap judgments. I mean if people are to go by what only the media reports, then they are only getting a one sided view Or even if they go by a few disgruntled American citizens of mylot. Basically unless you live in a country all the time and breathe your country's cultures, you are going to be able to formulate an accurate opinion. And the same goes for Americans voicing things about other countries. Now I'll just wait for someone to say something rude about my post. lol
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
ambiepam they had not better say anything rude about your post'or I will say something too. lol. yes we get painted with'
a black brush at times when they do not know the real common'ordinary american person at all. and the same goes for us taking slanted viewsof other countries. I have some dear friends at the library where I used to work who came from China and Japan and they are both quick to point out our sterotypes of their countries. they are both now american citizens but did grow up in their native countries.
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
•
5 Jul 08
Hi Hatley, we in the UK get it because we are British we are deemed reserved. Well like you in America so are and some aren't but it is a generalisation. I drink tea but I can't stand cucumber and I am sure there are many Americans who don't eat burgers. I wouldn't class Americans as sensationalists, maybe more outgoing than others but that is because you have always been encouraged to live the dream, which I think is great. I am living my dream living by the sea surrounded by glorious countryside. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
hi ellie I have a lot of British friends ans some are reserved and some are far from it,just like us americans,some of us are outgoing like my husband was, and some are shy Like I am.
Living by he sea oh that sounds so good, I am about six miles'from the Pacific,when we first came to ca we lived on the beach while we waited for our house to clear escrow and it was such fun.
@DonnaLawson (4032)
• United States
5 Jul 08
This person didn't know what they were talking about.. It really takes an unlearned person to lump a group of people together in this way.. Too many people do this and don't seem to realize how idiotic it makes them appear.. You can't judge many by a few and this is what so many people are guilty of.. I could care less about any type of sensationalism.. People stereotype others and make assumptions with only a few facts and this is what that person appears to have done.. Our media is not the be all, end all of our thought, wants or needs.. I would like to hear the truth from the media but we get what we get.. But, personally, I believe only a little bit of what I hear and only a small portion of what I see.. I do like to make sure that I know what I am talking about before I make any types of statements and I would not make this statement unless I was prepared to take the consequences of what I said.. So, this person, unless they have studied each and every individual American, doesn't know anything about Americans or what we are like..
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
I agree, it takes time to know all the people in a country and realize they arenothing like what the media portrays. I hate
being sterotyped at all, and avoid doing this to people of other countries.
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
5 Jul 08
IMO the only people who really deserve to be called senationlists are the members of the media and not just in America but any country. The more outrageous they are the more money they make. As we all know money is the bottom line for the media worldwide.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
whiteheather as usual you make such good sense. thats it, the media willdo anything to make money. My son parodies some of these where someone sticks a microphone in a womans face and asks her how she feels since her husband was shot in a drive by shooting, only he goes how the hell do you think I would feel, moron, then he pretends to smack the microphone away from the media person.The sad thing is that the tv people do ask just such stupid inhumane questions of someone who is grieving.
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
5 Jul 08
Poppycock. Americans are just as nice as other people and in certain ways they are nicer. Your media does seem to be full of itself, and does not show the real people who live in your nice country. I hate judging people by what the media portrays them. I really hated those old movies of settling America and the people were portrayed as ignorant hicks compared to the smooth and educated French and English. I mean there were some really educated Americans then.
After all, the different between Americans and Canadians is just that you have a better climate, and have a president while we have a prime minister, and it takes all day to cross one of our provinces unless you go from south to north and it takes forever.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
6 Jul 08
suspenseful you are so right, we to me anyway seem to be a lot'like you canadians when we toured British Columbia, just
a nice bunch of really friendly people and the Mounties, I was young then, and drooled over some of them in their uniforms, a silly kid yet. but we really enjoyed our trip to BC.