Why are many religions exclusive?
By shlooper
@shlooper (309)
United States
July 8, 2008 3:27pm CST
Many different types of religion believe that they are the ones who are correct and everyone else is wrong. We see this in Christianity, as those who do not accept Jesus wont be saved, in Mormonism when they baptize the dead to save them, and in Islam as well, which is eventually what lead to the Crusades ect. Why do so many religions feel as if they have an exclusive right to god and that all other ones are incorrect? Is this just human nature? and if so how can we overcome this as a species?
3 people like this
8 responses
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
8 Jul 08
Hi shlooper, Thank you for starting this discussion. Many religions are exclusive, and it usually dates back to the beginning of that particular religion. There are many small groups within Christianity itself, that believe that you have to be baptised in their particular church. There may also be similar factions in other world religions. These people are absolutely convinced that they alone are right, whether it's the born-again fundamentalist Christian, the Mormon, the followers of Islam or of some smaller group. Those at the head of those churches have no intention of losing the power that they have over their followers, and that's why it will be difficult to change. It will happen eventually of course, even now you see some of them losing followers. The younger people growing up today may not be so easy to fool, but they have these teachings inbred into them when they are young and so far only a comparative few have been able to break the yoke. The belief that Israel is God's chosen people is a good example of the concept of being exclusive. We all know that a good parent does not have favourites, yet many think it perfectly acceptable that God would. I do see some hope in that there are people out there who are saying that we are all one, and that we have to accept the fact that God loves all, and there is no one true religion. I don't know how long it will take for us to see the truth, and tell those in authority that we've had enough of this nonsense, but I do believe the day will come. I believe too that it will bring the long hoped for peace. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
9 Jul 08
Hi again shlooper, You could be right, I can see where exclusiveness might make some people think that all religion is foolishness. At the same time, there is bound to be an increase in those who don't believe in anything but what they can experience for themselves. I don't have a big problem with those people if they are willing to live and let live. I might add here that I have discovered in my lifetime that not all who call themselves Atheists, really are. Blessings.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Thank you for your response. You make some very good points. It all makes me wonder who the corruption really lies with, we seem to be pointing toward the leaders of the various churches because they don't want to lose followers, but could we not also consider that some of them believe that what they are teaching is the only truth? You mentioned that some of these religious institutions are losing followers, however at the same time, at least in America, I believe there has been an increase in the number of atheists and agnostics, I wonder could this corruption in the religion be driving people away from it all together?
1 person likes this
@mynameismine (771)
• United States
9 Jul 08
There are quite a few and unfortunately many of them can be linked directly to violence and murder to prove their point. It is really sad that they choose to believe in such hypocrisy but it is their life and that is what they choose. I just wish they would leave me alone in the process of their own choices.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Yes, thank you for your insight about Judaism, I really don't know that much about it, and I enjoy learning more about things that I don't understand. I wonder where the idea of exclusiveness came from though. Perhaps the power that the Catholic church had when it was tied to the governments?
@shlooper (309)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Thank you for your comment, you are correct there are religions that do not evangelize. However, I am wondering about the ones that do because many do. At the same time, I do not know that much about Judaism, don't they also believe that they are god's chosen people and everyone else is gentile? I am confused about what exactly they teach now since I don't believe its the same as what is in the old testament.
1 person likes this
@astw56 (12)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Indeed, Bugsey is right. Judaism does not go out and spread itself as the Jehova's Witnesses do, nor does it preach against any other religion and believes in coexisting with others. The Noachide Laws (which he mentioned) are the laws applied to all of mankind, and if you obey those, then you are a "good person". One Jewish comedian once joked, "If we are the Chosen People, then couldn't He choose someone else for once?" We're bound by stricter laws and are expected to behave even better by G-d, meaning we have less leeway.
I believe that Judaism and Buddhism are two of the main religions that believe in the acceptance of others.
The Church has always wanted control and power, and therefore made such claims as "anyone not accepting Christ will be damned to Hell" and others of the sort. It hopes that because of those claims, others will join them to avoid being placed in this supposed Hell of theirs. The entire issue grows even more complicated when various sects of Christianity start claiming that you must be part of THEIR sect, or else you go to Hell. Meaning, believing in Jesus isn't enough anymore. You have to believe our claims. Even though pretty much all of them have the same overall concepts.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
9 Jul 08
Let me first say that I respect all religious beliefs while believing that religion is basically a brainwashing method, a complete hogwash to keep ordinary people under the leadership and spell of some very extraordinarily clever men. Its like eternally dangling the carrot of heaven in front of our eyes, taking advantage of the inherent greed in human nature. And the worst part is that we inculcate the same blind faith in our children too and so in a way humanity is doomed due to religion. You will find how true this is when even under the major religions, you will find numerous sub-sects with their own leaders and band of followers who are always trying to prove each other wrong.
The only way to overcome this is to forget about religion and look inward towards the spirit. Awakening the spirit is the only way of connecting to God and for that, the first step would be to accept and recognize that all humans are same and equal and each soul is but a part of the greater universe.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
10 Jul 08
Oh! Trying to prove each other wrong or to prove myself the best is basic human (or animal) nature. Its after all, survival of the fittest and in humans, it takes a more cerebral form than muscular form in animals. It has nothing to do with religion per se.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
9 Jul 08
This could be true, but why do people as a whole feel the need to always try to prove each other wrong? What is it that makes religion a competition instead of intended to bring people closer to god? I agree with you about the acceptance of each other as equals, but what I don't understand is why we can't do this with religions in place.
@munkysam07 (31)
• United States
8 Jul 08
I think that a lot of religions try to put all those kinds of labels on them because they all think that they are right. Religion is all about making you feel like a bad person so that you will feel like the preacher, priest, etc is higher. This leaves you feeling dependent on them, and you are in need the whole time.
@srpkinja (375)
• Canada
9 Jul 08
Think about it this way: if one person was raised to think believe that the sky is purple that person will go on to belive the sky is purple. If another person was raised to believe that the sky is blue they will also go on to believe that the sky is blue. When people are raised a certain way, they believe in that and its hard for those people to believe or think of something in another way. Especially religion. When a child is baptized and is sat down by the parents and is taught that Jesus is our Lord and Saviour that child will only know of Jesus and will only believe in him. It goes that way with all religions. People go on to think that whatever they were raised up believe is right and everything else is wrong. Its how people are. They do not want to hear or educate themselves about other religions because then when they hear the truth that other religions may be right and theirs is "wrong" then they will start to panic. Again, its how people are. And btw. Islamic people do not get baptized, thats more of a Christian thing.
@srpkinja (375)
• Canada
10 Jul 08
Well, imagine someone comes up to you and tell you that everything you have believed in all your life is wrong. Would you not feel paniced? For some people, religion is all they have and when someone tells them its not real or true then they feel threatened because there is something that is "right" when all along they thought what they believe in is right.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
10 Jul 08
When I was growing up people came up to me all the time and informed me that what I believed was wrong. I know I am the exception, but it didn't bother me. I asked them what they believed and as a result, I eventually decided that they were right, I was wrong, but that didn't mean they were right. I know that I was more open minded than some others, but I wonder why we are so close minded in general.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Yeah, sorry about the Islamic thing that was me being grammatically awkward, I did not mean to imply/say that they believed in baptism. My question is more of they why are the people just like that? Because many people are perfectly fine with saying "I believe the sky is purple, but it is ok if you think it is blue", what makes the people who panic feel like they are being threatened?
@vijigopi (991)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Good question! I would say it is human nature to make a religion exclusive. Take for example, a ritual based on a belief in a religion. The first question that arises is that 'why should we do this ritual?' to which the answer is 'this is for such and such a reason'. Then the next question automatically arises - 'What about people that don't do this?' which is not fairly answered because people don't know what the answer is. So to make a person do something, people tend to claim that others are sinners. Human brain works in such a way that it thinks that if one religion is true then all others are false. This is because people can't understand what happens to those that don't follow their practices. If it does not matter whether they follow or not follow their rituals or spiritual practices, then automatically nobody would follow any rituals and this would mean a lot of economically difficult situations for the priests and such others whole primary job is doing rituals for others. I guess this is done to avoid a lot of unemployment .. just kidding.
@LordTimber (287)
• United States
8 Jul 08
It's the ignorance of people, and their ego's wanting to be recognized.
@shlooper (309)
• United States
8 Jul 08
Basically yes, but the real question I have is what is it about certain things, in this case religion, where the ignorance and egomania take normal decent people to a point of violence or intolerance. These people don't believe they are ignorant, and they would certainly not consider themselves to be violent or intolerant. In certain situations they still are though.