Blame the animal or the human?

@TessWhite (3146)
United States
July 9, 2008 11:27am CST
How do you feel when an animal injures a human because the animal was being used for entertainment purposes? The other day I was watching a show about dramatic videos and they showed a bull fight in mexico. The bull had attacked several people and had jumped into the stands. The people were so enraged that the animal had done this. Well what about the animals rights to protect itself during this extremely cruel "sport?" Another day on the news I saw where a horse had severely injured a man in a rodeo. Everyone was so upset over the man's injuries, did they bother to express concern over the animal laying there in pain? Another news story awhile back was about a bear killing its trainer. Maybe the bear had just had enough? What gives us the right as humans to use and often injure animals for entertainment purposes. And when we fall victim during the process we blame the animal. Sorry, I say blame the human. If we had left them well enough alone there wouldn't have been a problem. What do you think?
3 people like this
24 responses
@guybrush (4658)
• Australia
10 Jul 08
To be honest, I cheer for the bulls ALL THE WAY when they do the run in Pamplona and some moron gets gored - serves them right! It disgusts me that animals are taunted and teased for human entertainment. I agree - the bear had had enough! Trouble is, the poor bear was probably put down. Human beings are the most disgusting animals of all.
1 person likes this
@Bugsey (775)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Me too. I mean why call ourselves civilized when we "make" sport outta these innocent animals. They are not made simply for our amusement! I am glad when someone gets "hurt" by a bull ; I am happy that a dog gets rabid and bites someone during some dogfight; and I blame humans not animals for NOT RESPECTING the rights of these animals to live a cruelty-free life!
1 person likes this
@guybrush (4658)
• Australia
11 Jul 08
Hurray for Bugsey and Tess!
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
LOL you sound like me. Whenever I see this happen I say - serves you right. And have no sympathy for the person.
1 person likes this
@newtondak (3946)
• United States
9 Jul 08
The animal can't be blamed when it is only responding to its instincts to protect itself from a predator.
@newtondak (3946)
• United States
9 Jul 08
To an animal, humans are a predator. Humans are making them do things that aren't their natural behaviors. Different animals have different ways of dealing with predators - some fight back - others, such as cattle and horses, run away.
• United States
9 Jul 08
is the predator the human? cuz im confused
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for responding. :)
• Netherlands
17 Jul 08
This is one topic that always gets under my skin. An animal is an animal and it has it's own built in instincts, tolerances, defense, and ways of dealing with things. It can not possibly understand that the human wants it to do certain things and perform for our amusement. It is unfair to expect that an animal with all these instincts can drop them at our whim. If you poke at it, if you hit it, tease it, starve it, harm it.... IT IS GOING TO REACT! Full stop. They make me very angry that they turn their rage on the animal if it injures a person. What do really think it is going to do? Why is the animal at fault for doing what nature has programmed it to? It doesn't know right or wrong and who is to say that their reaction is wrong? It attacked because it didn't like what was happening to it, it may have been scared, it may have felt its life was in danger.... The other thing that really really gets under my skin about this: When a person goes into the animals natural habitat and fumbles around and gets attacked. People go after the animal as though it was a criminal. If you go into the forest where there are bears, large cats or whatever.... YOU must be aware that they are there and they are dangerous. So if you are hurt that is YOUR fault and not the animal. It is just protecting itself from an assumed threat. Maybe protecting its children. MY I just want to strangle people when they go after the animal to put it down. How about people just be more careful!
• Netherlands
20 Jul 08
Thank you for best response. :)
@sylvia13 (1850)
• Nelson Bay, Australia
9 Jul 08
I would tend to blame the human too, especially in the case of the bullfights! I wish they would abolish them, they are so cruel and pointless!
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Agree - thanks for replying :)
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
9 Jul 08
The animals are animals, they can not explain to us how they feel. We are torturing them (the bull fighter) or just don't understand what is happening to them or how they feel. Yes, they will lash out. I am sure the animals get the same aches and pains that we do, yet they can't tell us. It is time we gave the animals a little space.
1 person likes this
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Agreed. Thanks for the reply.
• United States
9 Jul 08
i think that one of these days animals are just going to turn on all humans that use them for entertainment. and i hopes they get my friends brother cuz he has dog fights over her, they have this one pitbull taht they put to fight and i told him that its not coolz but he didnt care so i was just like ok just watch u guys will get in so much trouble and he was like w/e.
@newtondak (3946)
• United States
9 Jul 08
If you are aware of people that are having dogfights, it is your responsibility to turn them in to the law enforcement authorities. It is illegal to hold dog fights, it is illegal in most states to watch or participate in a dog fight in any way. Thousands of family pets are stolen every year by people who sell them to those who have dog fights. They are used as "bait" to train the dogs to fight.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
phenon - if you are aware of someone having dog fights you need to report them! I don't care if they are related to you or not. This is so so wrong. And in my opinion if you DON'T report them then you are just as guilty of animal abuse.
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
10 Jul 08
very well said and yes i agree with you on that..we must leave animals the way they are and not trying to control them according to our whims or wishes and its us to be blame if something happen to us in the process..
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for the reply. :)
@Samanthavv (1380)
• United States
10 Jul 08
I don't really know. I kind of have the attitude that if you're going to play with fire, you're going to get burned. I certainly wouldn't be messing with animals I knew were dangerous!
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Agreed. Thanks for the reply. :)
@wrangel15 (1443)
• Philippines
10 Jul 08
Animals, like human have their own brain. Animals usually act by the things they experience and reactions are based from their situation and instinct. As human beings we should be the one to take care of the things around us. We are assigned to protect and be good to our surroundings. I can say that we cannot blame animals when they become wild. This includes our pets. Animals are naturally wild. I would say that we should do good to animals in a way that when they become wild, there's no reason for others to be blame us.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Agreed. Thanks for responding. :)
• United States
11 Jul 08
i would say humans are to blame because we are the ones who demanded those entertainment shows. and many humans love blood sport like me. and if we were attacked by animals its most likely that we did something bad to deserve it. i believe in karma. we humans also think that we are superior thinking only about ourselves andnot so much about with the so called "lower lifeforms"
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
11 Jul 08
Thanks for your response. :) Yes, maybe karma is whats working when animals finally get the upper hand.
@phoenix25 (1541)
• United States
10 Jul 08
I also say blame the human. Humans are the only animal capable of complex thought. They are able to weigh risks and make complicated decisions. If a person is going to participate in activities with dangerous animals, they should understand that they are dealing with an animal that could possibly dangerous and may injure them. Even when animals are trained, they can still be dangerous. People want to get all upset, but the animal is responding in the only way that it knows how in those situations. The animal doesn't "decide" to hurt people and it doesn't understand that doing that is wrong. The person needs to be responsible for preventing injury.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for your input and response. :)
@amrith (291)
• India
10 Jul 08
Yes I blame the humans because as we want freedom it is the right of the animals also .We all know the most cruel animals also won't attck others simply. When they are killing and eating to fill their stomach it is natural, because they have been made for that by nature.But man in their thirst to please their inhumane interest making use of animals and hurting them by using in entertainement purposes is disgusting .Man who supposed to be the the most evolutioned creature is degrading to be the lowest by this type of cruel acts
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for your input. :)
• India
10 Jul 08
Only humans are to blame. They use the animals for there sport, though animal likes to engage in such activities on its own. Cruelty to animals in any form is unfortunate.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for the reply. :)
@muxicka (215)
• Philippines
10 Jul 08
Lack of safety precautions?? (can that be blamed?) I can't blame the people since they went there only for entertainment purposes. Can't also blame the animal since it's part of their nature to be violent when provoke. Sorry I can't decide.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Well I blame the people, because the support that type of entertainment. To me that makes them just as guilty.
• United States
9 Jul 08
I am always amazed when an animal acts like an animal and humans are surprised by this. Well.. DUH! To those ignorant and unenlightened humans who think a wild animal makes a good plaything.. get real!
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Thanks for the reply. :)
• Philippines
9 Jul 08
good day... In scientific point of view, we are the highest form of animal because of our brain which is perfectly developed and that is the source of our intelligence compared to other form of animals but then, Indeed we are higher in form of intelligence compared to them but we are lower in terms of kindness. Animals attack or kill either they have to (for food) or they need to (for defense) but I never heard they do it for fun or entertainment. Well, I wouldn't want to wander any further, just answer this who invented gladiator fighting? and you know what I'm talking about.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
9 Jul 08
We may be the top of the food chain, but that should make us more caring too. Thanks for the reply.
@excellence7 (3655)
• Mauritius
9 Jul 08
You are so right. We are living in the cruel world where animals are no more valued as before. Human makes the difference clear between animal and mankind which is pure discrimination. It is to be noted that we are also animal, the only difference is that we are 'civilized'. I think in todays world, animal are exploited. We can see so many horses suffering and dying in the horse racing industries. Do you know that a horse is whipped nearly 30 times during a single race- just imagine ! Horse no more reliable for racing are sent to the butchery to be cut off and eaten. Is it not an injustice? If ever a horse fell off during a race, the poor animal can even die!!! And we people, we go to bet on this cruelty..we keep supporting the racing industry ! STOP BETTING ON CRUELTY..if every human start this action, and make others do this same action, then there will be a change in the world..a minor change- but at least a change..So many animals are exploited in circus, in zoos, on the roads..so many animals are ill-treated and die out of hunger and sufferings. Who is to be blame for this? The human or the animal !!! It's HUMAN because we are "civilized" not them..If so, we don't have the right to blame the animals if ever they try to defend their rights! It's simply that we don't have any reason to pursue them because they are not civilized...but they have their rights of life which have been guided by cruelty nowadays. Let us all think about this friends, we have to make the change as from now. Every animal we see, just remember that they also have their words to see but they need us to express themselves because we can understand their speechless message if we try to care for them...start this good action as from now..and let's fight for the animal kingdom...!!!!
@CharRay7 (1549)
• United States
9 Jul 08
Hello my friend, I totally agree with you. When human beings put animals into unpredictable situations and the animal acts out, it is the human who is wrong, not the animal. Animals have animal instincts that you can stiffle but you can't stop them from coming out. Besides, did anyone make the human go in front of the bull? Did anyone make the rodeo guy go in there? No, they did it themselves....so it's their fault! I feel there should be stricter rules that don't allow animals to be used for entertainment purposes. They didn't ask to be in human exposure. People put them there. Too many animals are hurt or die because of these entertainment shows and it just isn't right! Have a great day! Char :-)
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Thanks for the reply Char. :) Agree with ya.
• Colombia
9 Jul 08
I really hate bullfighting activities.. some people think it's art , but it's just a torture, you know, that bulls are not agressive so the owners put them in a dark room and hit them, hurt them, make them to drunk some laxative in order to make the bulls feel weak and sick,so the bullfighter has advantages... that people is just crazy.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
Awful treatment. Thanks for responding. :)
• United States
9 Jul 08
I have to agree with you. It's messed up to use animals as entertainment purposes. A lot of people say that "Wild animals will always be wild." But I don't believe that many people really live up to that knowledge. Once you see tiger in captivity and doing tricks, some people automatically think that they're civilized, train, etc etc. I mean really? That's just wishful thinking in my opinion.
@TessWhite (3146)
• United States
10 Jul 08
agree - thanks for responding :)