In love with two people.....
By fafinette79
@fafinette79 (943)
United States
July 12, 2008 9:16pm CST
This is just a question and I really need some honest, detail responses. Has anyone been in love with two people at the same time? Was it a girl and guy?Here's my situation. I'm happily married and love my hubby very much. My hubby and I have been discussing bringing another girl into the relationship. If you read my discussions, then you'll know that this is totally my idea. During a conversation we were having, my hubby joked that he was worried that I would fall in love with the girl and will want to get rid of him altogether. But, is this possible? I'm thinking that I might fall in love with both of them if I had the chance. Is this bad? Be honest, don't hold back.
3 people like this
14 responses
@walkthetalk (1307)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I think you are take the risk of your Husband falling in love with this other woman. It is very risky. What if they get rid of you.? It is something to think about.
2 people like this
@walkthetalk (1307)
• United States
15 Jul 08
Your apsolutly right, you can't stop him from loving someone else. But if he if your husband fell deeply in love with this girl, how would you fill if you were the one that put them in the same bed. I just think if you thought this girl is so special that you may fall in love with her, that you husband may also. You said she may not even want him to particapate. will you back?
@cherylsousa (81)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I have been in love with 2 men at the same time. But they couldn't stand each other, so the thought of having a relationship with both of them would have been a nightmare.
I don't believe that anything is impossible when it comes to emotions. You could end up falling in love with this new woman, you could end up hating her. Same with your husband. I think it's very risky.
Personally, there is just no way I could ever share my husband. I'm way too insecure for that! I'd be too afraid of being compared!
Either way, I wish you the best of luck and hope whatever you decide it works out for you!
2 people like this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
I think that I would feel the same way if my hubby wasn't so different from anyone that I've ever dated. He thinks of me as someone truly different and incomparable to anyone else. Thank you for your wishes.
@therd27 (31)
• Philippines
13 Jul 08
i haven't experience anything of this kind.. but i think that it is very inappropriate.. you can't love two persons both at the same time.. you maybe attracted but that does not mean that you are really in love.. although it will be alright at first.. time will come that you have to choose from the two and there will be someone that might get hurt.. i do believe that you don't want that to happen..
maybe as of know you are just confused or not contented because as you said you were the one initiating to have another girl in your relationship..
i really think that having another girl will evetually lead to a problem..
1 person likes this
@cherylsousa (81)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I think everyone has their opinion as to whether or not it's appropriate or not, but how can you determine that its' not possible for someone to "really be in love" with multiple people.
I do agree that it's very risky and bad could come from it, but there are plenty of people out there who have been in love with more than one person. Not that I condone polygamy, but as an example, it does exist and multiple partners are in love with each other.
Being in love is an emotion, just as being happy, being sad, being angry, etc. You can be angry with several people, you can be sad about many things, a lot of different things can make you happy. So who's to say that you can't be in love with multiple people?
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
Thak you both for your opinions. It's great to see both sides of the same coin. If I had to choose between my hubby and the other woman, then it would not be a hard choice. My vows and my undying love is to him. I do agree with chery though. I think it is possible to love two people at once time. It may not be the same exact love, but love no doubt. I pray that I will never be in this situation. As for inappropriate. There are many stories in the bible where men of God have a wife and a mistress. I know people don't want to hear that, but it's very true. Mistresses were widely used to bare children or help in housework and even satisfying the man when the wife could not.
@turtle_ring27 (199)
• Philippines
20 Jul 08
well. sometimes it is possible. You know I admire you and your hubby for having an open communication and trust to each other. It happens to me loving two guys who are closely related - they were cousins. thats the sad part. I lose the two of them so that nobody will be hurt. I miss the two of them
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
20 Jul 08
Boy, that's a hard situation! I would've done the same thing if I was in your situation. I've never loved two people who were in the same family and don't ever see it happening. Have you ever tried to be just friends with them?
I wish you luck with this. I'm hoping that you find love someone else and that you are very happy.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
14 Jul 08
I think so much depends on how the others involved all feel about the situation. Your hubby sounds a bit worried and that makes me think that this may not be a good thing. I have never been in that situation. What I have heard from others that have is that more often than not someone will get jealous and it can all backfire. I do know of one lady that did this with another guy and amazingly her relationship has worked and they are soon getting married. She did not however, fall in love with the other guy. Not saying that it can't or won't work out for you as I know it happens...tread carefully.
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
15 Jul 08
I understand where you are coming from and your reasons. But if I continue to hold it in, then what will I do? Won't I be unhappy?
1 person likes this
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
15 Jul 08
i really don't know. i think you have to follow your heart. No one can really tell you what to do here, Clearly you already have your mind made up. like I said..never been in your situation so i can't say that it is wrong. I hope it all works out for you,. good luck...let us know how it all turns out.
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
15 Jul 08
Thank you for being supportive of me and my decision. I'm still looking for the right girl to start a relationship with. I appreciate the members here all the time.
@relundad (2310)
• United States
14 Jul 08
What a discussion! Well I think obviously love has no definite quantity limits. As humans we are definitely capable of loving more than one person. I guess what I am having some difficulty understanding is that if you are happily married why is it that you are searching outside of your marriage for something else on an emotional level? It seems that your husband is pretty accomodating and open minded and is willing to do whatever it takes to make you happy and sustain your marriage. It would seem that you wouldn't have to go outside of your marriage for whatever your search is for.
I definitely think there is way more at stake than a pre-discussion between your husband and you can predict. Even if the two of you decide that from an emotional standpoint that you can handle this, it could be quite different once the wheels start rolling. And emotions just aren't that predictable. Neither of you can be sure where your feelings will end up. And definitely you can't be sure where it end up for the third persons feelings will go. If your marriage is as happy as you say and you love your husband as you say, are you willing to risk this for a fantasy?
I'm also wondering if you have even remotely thought of the possiblity that though this is your idea, it could end up that you are on the losing end? Have you considered that the new girl and your husband could end up being the two in love?
Or what happens if shortly after you realize that the thrill is gone for you desire for this undertaking and your husband then somehow feels that he now has your permission for another person in the relationship? Wow, I could go on and on about the what if's. I think at the end of the day I just would not be willing to subject a good relationship and marriage to the possibilities. Of course this is just my opinion.
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
I have thought of what you said and more. The girl would end of spending more time with me than with him. Though I would love for him and her to be close, the thought of losing him makes me worry. I value everyone's opinion. This is more than a fantasy to me, it's more like a wanting....a need. I believe that people love who they love, but if I desire to be with a woman shouldn't I try? I have dreams of another girl and being intimate with her. My therapist says that this can be emotionally distructive if I just set it aside and try to forget it.
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
17 Jul 08
I think it is entirely possible to be in love with two people at once. In college, for about a year I was involved with both a guy and a girl who were not involved with each other, but would gang up on me if I wasn't doing what I was supposed to be doing as far as my health or something like that. I think the most important thing in polyamorous relationships is honesty and rule setting. Once you make the rules, don't break them. No matter how tempted you might be. I also think it's important to ask yourself, as I did, could I possibly love this person anymore if they were my only person? I can to the conclusion that I couldn't and so it was ok with me to be with two people. I don't know how I would have felt if I would have realized I could have been a better girlfriend to only one person. I'm glad this wasn't the case.
1 person likes this
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I do know if that is possible but I guess it's happening...I have not known anyone in real life who experienced that but I heard from people....
Classifying it as bad or not depends on one's personality,culture and belief and for me, that is the thing that I can't and will not do!
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I know that most of my family won't approve. This is something that I will probably keep to myself. She'll just be known as a really good friend and hopefully no one will ask her about her love life. I haven't met anyone who has been in this situation, but I'm hoping that someone will respond soon.
@wisedragon (2325)
• Philippines
14 Jul 08
What your husband said was a joke. He's still the luckiest man in the world for having a wife like you, wanting to give him a threesome! Believe me, divorce is the least of his worries right now! Man, some guys have all the luck!
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
I will be sure to let him know how you feel. I don't think he feels exactly the same. He loves me and wants me to be happy, but at the same time he feels he's setting me up for pain. He also told me that divorce would never happen for us because I'm exactly what he wants and needs.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
14 Jul 08
When you bring a third party into your most intimate relationship you are forming a bond with that person and, yes, you could fall in love with her and decided that you want to be with her more than you want to be with your husband. Or your husband could fall in love with her. I understand wanting variety in your life but why include a third party into the emotional part of your relationship? That can ultimately lead to pain for at least one of the parties involved so is it worth it?
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
Thank you for your advice. I don't want any pain. But, I think holding it in would cause me lots of pain. And would cause my hubby lots of pain from my unhappiness and constant not knowing.
@TheCarter (369)
• United States
13 Jul 08
Yeah that would be pretty bad. People aren't built to love that way. Confusion will eventually set in, and the problem with confusion is that you can't be sure of what side she will take.
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
Confusion is only when we don't search ourselves for what we really want. I'm going through therapy for a lot of things that have happened in the past and to also learn more about myself since my father passed away. I'm also taking psychology classes to improve this. I do know that I love my hubby and if he didn't approve then I would leave it alone. But, I probably would always wonder.
@prncesfrmheaven (452)
• United States
13 Jul 08
Hey fafinette,
I don't think it's possible to be "IN LOVE" with 2 people. You may have love for them both, but if you were really and truly "in love" you wouldn't do anything to hurt either one of them. When you are in love with someone you would never say or do anything that would cause that person pain. Being "in love" with 2 people would definitely be painful for these people. So I think you might think you are "in love" with them, but I don't personally think that it's possible.
@Kierstal (142)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I disagree. It's true that when you truly love someone, you don't want to hurt them. But not everyone is hurt by the idea (or reality) of their loved ones being in love with other people. But it takes a big heart and an open mind to truly accept such things. There is no wrong way to really love someone. All unconditional love is right. Whether it's for one person, or ten. The key is openness and honesty. Love doesn't lie, love doesn't keep secrets.
1 person likes this
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
Yes, I agree with the way you put it. I haven't been forcing the idea on my hubby because I want him to be completely comfortable with this idea. He knows that I love easily and I love hard if the love is returned. He knows that there is the chance that this woman might become a part of our lives for a long time. But, he also knows that I get hurt by women easily because of my past experiences. The more we discuss this idea, the more I come to believe that my hubby is more concerned with me getting hurt by her.
@cherylsousa (81)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I completely agree with Kierstal. Not everyone is hurt by the idea. It does seem that fafinette's husband may have some insecurities, which may cause problems in the relationship if a third person is brought in. However, it still doesn't mean that it's impossible to be in love with multiple people.
1 person likes this
@lilibetha49 (15)
• United States
13 Jul 08
I thought that I was in love with 2 men at the same time. I was very young, just married, and I found out, in time, that my marriage had some problems that I just didn't want to face. It took me a long time to figure this out, after a painful divorce from my husband. By the time that I got divorced, I knew that loving this other guy was just my chicken-s--- way of ignoring a problem. It's my personal belief that we should all be free to choose whom to love, but sometimes family and friends have other ideas. Good luck to you.
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
14 Jul 08
The only problem that my hubby and I have is financial. This is only because I couldn't substitute during the summer and we went down to one income. This was a learning experience for us because this was the first time that we had this problem. I go to personal therapy and we have gone to marriage therapy. We talk everything through and understand each other. He understands me and why I want to try this and I love him more for that.
@goddessofbeauty (713)
• Philippines
20 Jul 08
I guess that's possible and is a normal thing, but still you have the control over that. You have to choose only one. Think of who makes you happy and who would be there for you for the rest of your life through thick and thin. Maybe you are just confused right now and would love adventure. Think a million times cos if you have lost your husband, that would be a total pain...
@fafinette79 (943)
• United States
20 Jul 08
I understand how you feel, but I disagree. Why do I have to choose only one to love. Everyone seems to think that every person in this would is meant to be with only one other person. I don't believe this is the truth. I believe I have the capability to be in love with more than one person, and I'm glad that my hubby understands.
So far, it's just him and I. We are very happy this way. But, I'm still attracted to women and want to see where it would take me.