One to think about...

Hi my friend, recently I went into the store and was looking at the different Tylenol products and I noticed the exact thing your are saying, all the ingredients were the same so this has me believing that if I was to buy "Tylenol Extra Strength" it does not matter if the box says it's for Migraines, Tension, Arthritis Pain, your only getting "Tylenol Extra Strength". Must be the same with the "Excedrin Strength".

Hi JTerrasi, I really can't tell because I suffer from asthma so I have to get one with codine and I have to get extra strenght as the others don't work on me. Tamara

Hi Jterrasi they all have the same ingredients but extra strength has more medication in it, and works a lot better'too than the others for a bad headache. other than that I think they are all pretty much the same.

If they have the same ingredients it is probably about the same.

I can't remember for sure. It's been a long time since I bought any. The last time I bought Excedrin it was for a co-worker who has asthma. She was also studying to be a respiratory therapist and she told me a specific Excedrin she had to use because of her asthma. If I remember correctly (and I may not) the ingredients will be listed in different order. I think different formulas may have the same ingredients, but the amounts of each will be different.

I always though it was funny when they say "new and improved".What do they do with all the other crap,because its no good now in my eyes.