Salt is good for you?

Lubbock, Texas
July 20, 2008 2:11pm CST
For years we've been told that a low sodium or no sodium diet is necessary to control high blood pressure. For years I've said "Bull! Use sea salt in moderation". Recently the Journal of General Internal Medicine reported that people on a low sodium diet may have an 80 percent higher risk of dying of heart disease than salt users, and that you should "stick to a moderate salt intake of six grams a day". I wonder what they'll tell us in a few years? Have you noticed that about every 10 or so years the medical community contradicts itself and tells us all these things they said were good for us aren't?
5 people like this
18 responses
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
20 Jul 08
I read that there is enough salt in everything to meet out needs without adding any extra. I don't add much as I prefer less. Howver you have brought to mind a situation I came across a few years back when I was working in the fruit and vegetable department of a chain of supermarkets for several years and one year there were more yellow peppers available than red ones because, for some reason beyond my knowledge, the harvest of the yellow ones was higher than the red ones. Sure enough that whole summer ALL the media from television to magazines told people that YELLOW peppers were better for this or that ailment and reduced this or that level of goodness what. What a load of...beep-beep!
3 people like this
• Lubbock, Texas
20 Jul 08
Isn't it amazing how the media is allowed to spin everything to suit special interests? (whoever pays them the most)
• United States
21 Jul 08
then why do people die if they have too much like from salt water?
@vera5d (4005)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I believe that moderation is key for everything. I lost a lot of weight in the past few months just by balancing the main food groups at every meal & exercising regularly. It just seems your darned if you do, darned if you don't, especially since there's so much conflicting information. I guess it depends who funds the research and who's pockets they are trying to line. (I know that's a bit of a cynical look on it, but I really think all these studies are just a "conspiracy" half the time anyways in trying to get the pharmaceutical companies & others more $$$ by proving this or proving that.)
2 people like this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
I'm with you in the cynical department. I try to keep the cynicism down, but It's always there. I even have trouble taking a Dr.'s advice because I just don't know if he's been brainwashed by the FDA, or lining his pockets with kick-backs from big pharma.
1 person likes this
@buenavida (9984)
• Sweden
21 Jul 08
Well, what are we going to hear next?? I have been using sea salt for many years when I make the food at home, which is most days.. I remember the time when fats were supposed to make us fat. Now we are learning to avoid sugar instead. Anyway, it is interesting to follow the latest news when they come from real scientists and not sensation newspapers....
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
I couldn't begin to predict what will be the next big taboo, but I can predict my response to it! Moderation and common sense!
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I rarely use any salt. Most foods that you eat have salt already in them. Hubby on the other hand uses tons of salt which is why I either cook seperate meals or make it without and then let him add his own. As for bad for you, I am reminded of a time growing up when doctors decided that eggs were terrible for you. Ppl quit eating them and started using egg alternatives. After a year or two, the doctors said that actually eggs are good for you as long as you have them in moderation, like anything else. I kind of go by what I see my older relatives eat. My Grandma rarely eats red meat...she's always been healthy. My Grandparents on my Dad's side were really big on fresh fruits and veggies right out of the garden. My Grandma on my Dad's side also made just about everything from scratch rather than convenience foods. I try to follow the same things...I goof sometimes but I still try. **AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~
2 people like this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
Yes, sometimes I think it would be wonderful if we were all able to grow our own food. I think part of the stuff they say is bad for us stems from all the unnatural things they do to the animals and land in order to grow "super crops".
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Jul 08
good day.. Medicine is an ever changing science and is not always absolute because people aren't absolute there are always exception. The main thing is research continues and discoveries for diagnostics and treatment methods never ceases. People's health evolves and so would the science that studies it.
2 people like this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
I'm aware of that, but my objection is they publish the findings of one study without any long term testing and have people harming their health by following it. Of course we should all take our health in our own hands and take care of ourselves. Moderation in all things is a good motto, but here in America many people have turned their health over to their Dr.'s and have let common sense fly out the window.
@CharRay7 (1549)
• United States
21 Jul 08
salt shaker - photo of salt in shaker
Hi my friend These days, you don't know who to believe or when. I have noticed that the medical community contradicts itself every 10 or 20 years. I think they need to find out the definate proof before they going on record saying something is fact. I personally love salt and probably use it more than I should. I use Morton's Lite salt so I hope that helps a little. lol Have a nice night, Char
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I love salty things, I see so many people talking about too much sodium in this, too much sodium in that. I think there is too much worry brought on by all these studies and what doctors say. The studies are not absolute and doctors do not know everything. Neither do I of course but a lot of things are common sense. If it makes you feel icky, you are probably eating too much or too little. If your bp is going up, maybe it's too much. Cause and effect, not absolutes.
1 person likes this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
What the studies of food don't take into consideration is the medications the person is on. Many times it's the medication that causes a problem and food will make it worse! Personally I think that is the case with the hbp. I know medications cause some problems. Salt by itself doesn't cause high blood pressure, but if it's there it makes it worse, so it needs something to balance it.
• United States
21 Jul 08
We are damned if we do and damned if we don't. You never quite know what is best anymore. I believe moderation is always key.
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
21 Jul 08
Yes, I have noticed this and I have been noticing it for years. I do not take a lot of stock in studies that do not make sense, or anything that is not moderate, ie I don't really believe in things that are restrictive or completely without structure. I kind of trust my own instinct as far as what constitutes moderation for ME. I am a moderate salt user, I like salty things and in general, more spicy vs less spicy. More power to you if you want to omit salt. Go ahead. Same if you want to brine yourself in it. I think the world has room for a wide variety and that every study or expert opinon should be taken with... a grain of salt.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Jul 08
People crave different things too. I think that I am more of a salt-o-holic, I do add salt when cooking. I like sweet things but only when I am in the mood. I could eat salty things daily.
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
Yes, as I told another poster, each person's physiological make-up is different and each needs different amounts of various nutrients.
1 person likes this
@cjgrooms (4456)
• United States
20 Jul 08
Nothing and i do mean NOTHING in medicine is absolute. If one study finds one thing the next can find something else. I don't pay much attention to most of it i use common sense and go on about my business.
1 person likes this
@cjgrooms (4456)
• United States
2 Aug 08
Thanks for the best response. It made my day.
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
All things in moderation. Cut the prepackaged food and cook from scratch. It's hard to do when you have a family and a job, but I think we're just batting our head against a wall trying to keep up with all the studies on how to be healthy. Eggs? As one person mentioned they were supposed to be bad for you. We lived on a farm. We had eggs every morning for breakfast. My Dad may have had some problems, but he lived to 92, so I just have decided common sense is the best way to go.
1 person likes this
• India
21 Jul 08
Ya i am agree with you.But i do not like more salt in my food and even i don't take extra salt. I know these people will always contradict after some times later its not their fault becuase research and technology keeps on changing and later at any point of time they found that some thing is true but it was false before. i mean to say that change is the game of life so these people also keep on getting more and more details and finally they conclude something but that can be changed ny them also after some time when they have some other result for the same. So please do not worry about that and try to understand what those people are saying and concentrate on the facts and figure.good luck!
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
I think the best thing we can do is live and eat as naturally as possible and use good common sense regardless of what scientific studies find. For one reason, one study can't possibly cover all the variations that can occur in the human body and life style.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Jul 08
The problem (and why I cannot believe study after study) has nothing to do with research and technology. A study is done, oh 50 years ago. It reports one thing. Ten years later, they say the opposite based on another study. Ten years after that, they go back to the results of the original study based on ANOTHER study. Things are definitely different within a span of 20 years. This isn't technology talking, this is just people who want to spend money on a study.
@lixiaos (17)
• China
21 Jul 08
salt can make dishes delicious. it is magic that differet amout of salt can make different flavours. By now i haven't known well the art of using salt. even someone believe salt may do harm to the health, but i don't mind because i pay more attention the if i live a happy life, other than if i live how long. we abide by some rules will make us heathy, but too many rule will make life colorless.
1 person likes this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
Everyone has different dietary needs. I believe if we use moderation in all things, and eat the foods we know are healthy, we will be much healthier and happier than if we let every scientific study scare us out of eating good food.
@MaeTsuen (257)
• Philippines
21 Jul 08
true true... well too much salt is bad or anything too much is bad. just enough salt on food for tasting but not to the point it becomes so salty already... i believe in natural way of life natural food intake... and won't go beyond that. like too much canned goods and etc where there's to much preservatives
1 person likes this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
And who is to say it's not the chemical preservatives that cause the trouble, not the salt. The FDA refuses to admit that these preservatives have some health risks, but I believe that if only salt were used in canned foods for preservative, there wouldn't be so many health issues.
• China
21 Jul 08
Low solt is good for your health,but high solt may be harm and could cause the high blood pressure.
1 person likes this
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
Thank you for commenting. I agree with you about moderation, but I have one correction to make. High salt in your diet doesn't cause high blood pressure, but it has been thought in the past that it will make it worse.
• India
21 Jul 08
ya salt is very good ingredient to the food and also body,it increases brain power and it is good to health to some extend
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
Thank you. I hadn't thought about salt being good for the brain, but it aids in exchanging the cellular fluids and keeping them fresh, it does indeed, aid the brain.
• United States
20 Jul 08
For healthy people, some salt is OK. But, it seems like salt is added to just about everything nowadays and people are getting way more salt than they need. I have a health problem that makes me sensitive to sodium. It's gotten better, but I still can't have a who lot of it. The thing is, when you have a problem like that, you really notice all the sodium in foods, especially when you dine out. I've only come across one or two restaurants where most of the items are low-sodium or no salt added. Just about all of them overdo it to the max and most meals have more than half the daily recommended amount of sodium in them. That's what bugs me, too. Most foods don't need added salt as they have plenty of sodium already in them.
• Lubbock, Texas
21 Jul 08
This is true, and there's another thing that studies don't ever take into consideration. Every individual has level of need for any specific nutrient. You can't just say everyone needs XX amount of this and Z amount of that. If our pallets weren't so distorted by processed foods from a very early age, we could tell what our body needed.
@snowy22315 (182196)
• United States
21 Jul 08
I think salt particulary iodized salt is essential for living. I think what you said a moderate salt intake is good. I have high BP (though it's pretty much under control at this point) so I need to watch my intake. I read labels and I try to pick foods lower is sodium, I alos will tend to salt with lite salt or sea salt that's about the extent of my watching. I love salty foods unfortunately.
1 person likes this
@valeria1 (2721)
• United States
21 Jul 08
LOL. I agree with you totally. I eat more salt than a cow and my health is perfect! They go in accordance with what they can make more money with. What is next cigs? hahahaha!
1 person likes this
21 Jul 08
salt give strength--we are all born with a salt deficit. but it does give high blood pressure if not used in moderation--that parts bad
1 person likes this