Is it ok to get engaged without an engagement ring?

Philippines
August 13, 2008 10:27am CST
How important is an engagement ring? I would like to throw this question as I remember someone who was booted out from a relationship because he could not give an engagement ring. Is an engagement ring really necessary? For not giving an engagement ring, would that be enough reason to kick somebody out of a relationship? What's your opinion?
1 person likes this
4 responses
• United States
13 Aug 08
My husband proposed to me without a ring thats why i didn't think that he was serious... till this day i still don't have my own ring i am wear my mother rings and my husband and i have been married for 4 months now.. I think that it is okay but you need to get her a ring soon after or she might not think that you are serious... For a week i didn't know my husand was serious about getting married i had to ask him if he was serioud about that... I don't mind wearing my mothers ring at all but it is time for me to get my own ring i think... I wouldn't kick someone out of a relationship if they couldn't present an engagement ring.. that is stupid i knew my husband couldn't afford one cause he is in the military so there for i knew that he could afford one.. So i am stil being patient to get my ring and i know that he will let me get whatever i want since he made me wait this long for one... I don't think that it it right that someone kick someone out of a relationship because he couldn't present a ring...
• Philippines
14 Aug 08
The ring may be truly an appropriate symbol for someone's love but, I think, what it symbolizes is more important. What if love is lost and all that is left is the ring, would you still appreciate it's symbolism? You might as well like to dispose the ring!
• United States
20 Aug 08
Yes I would appreciate the symbolism.
• United States
14 Aug 08
For the short term he could go to Sears or some other dept. store and get a $25 cubic zirconia for you. My mom never got a diamond other than a tiny one in a necklace. She has been married for about 44 years. I gave her a Sears card for Mother's day and she bought a cubic zirconia and it looks perfect with her wedding band! She only wears it on special occasions as that will make it last longer and keep shiny:) Anyways, a diamond sticking out of your finger just gets in the way of things you need to use your hands for... Don't get me wrong, I think they are pretty, too, but not necessary if you are truly in love.
• United States
13 Aug 08
A relationship moving forward is a wonderful thing, leads to engagement then to marriage. I personally do not feel that the engagement ring is a requirement compared to a ring for the marriage ceremony. After all, the relationship/engagement/marriage is based on love, love is not based on a shiny ring, a big stone, or a heavy price tag. The ring is a material symbol of how much someone paid for the other to show off, it isnt a measure of love. Think of the american flag, I do not need to have it flying in my backyard or wear it as a sash, to believe in patriotism and liberty in my heart. So, for anyone that requires a ring to make it official, get rid of that high-maintenance princess/queen-attitude materialistic thinking (I am aiming it towards women because most of the time it is usually a female) and take heart on what really matters: love, trust and happiness.
• United States
14 Aug 08
I agree with majestic12. And if that person who requires an engagement ring doesn't want to compromise and see reality that maybe you can't afford it or something, then you will have a hard time being married to someone who can't compromise. Love, trust, happiness, compromise, understanding, honesty and lots of other things go into a marriage...not material possessions.
• Philippines
14 Aug 08
If giving an engagement ring would forever and totally guarantee love, trust, happiness, honesty, compromise, and everything nice in a relationship then that would justify it.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
13 Aug 08
An engagement ring is a symbol and is only as important as the person wearing, or not wearing, it thinks it should be. I don't think the inability to produce a ring is a good reason to end a relationship and, really, if the guy meant that little to the woman, he's better off without her. I personally believe, though, that is a man is going to propose marriage to a woman he should have some kind of ring in his pocket.
• Philippines
13 Aug 08
I'd like to ask your reaction to #4 and #5 commentors of this discussion.
• United States
13 Aug 08
WEll its pretty much important. i mean those things those when we older. Will you marry me, and the guy pulls out the ring. I can't imagine myseld doing that years from now. good thing im still a senior in high school. too nervous
• Philippines
14 Aug 08
You'll be doing that in due time...you may have a ring when that time comes but more important than a ring is the LOVE that you're going to give your girl