From the book to the movies

Considering the amount of detail & story he had to squeeze into that few hrs he had I think he did a great jog. Did you notice that Toms role in the barrows was deleted but his song which put the willow to sleep was sung by Treebeard instead. I thought that was great how even though a few scenes which didn't directly relate to the flow of the movie were deleted he still made a reference to them. I sooo wish they'd get a move on in making The Hobbit.

i think he did a pretty good job with the movie. the only thing that i didn't like was that arwen (liv tyler) had too much exposure in the movie. the arwen in the book did not really have that much role. if i remember correctly, in the 1st book, it was elrond who saved aragorn from those guys riding horses. in the movie, they made arwen do it. i don't like arwen in the book and in the movie.

the book had no fighting describtion so in the movie it had to be invented how the fight was

I thought he did well. I enjoyed both the movies and book(s)