Have you been accused of Acting too white or Not asian enough, etc?

NAIMA, accused of trying to be too black - Picture of model Naima on tyra banks top model show
United States
August 16, 2008 12:40pm CST
This has been an issue that has come up in my life from time to time especially as a child. I am adopted and grew up in a white family and predominantly white small rurul town and then when I grew up went to live with my father who live in a predominantly upscale white neighborhood. I have been accused of acting too white and never really cliched with the african american groups until after high school. I am actually alaskan american and something else but I just classify myself as native american and do not think of myself as white but somewhere in between the two. I personally think I am very well-rounded because I grew up in a small rural town, lived in upscale white areas, lived in the projects, and now live just live in the suburbs as a mother so I feel like I've experienced a lot of different backgrounds and now with my boyfriend being Turkish, have been immersed in his culture. I met a real nice girl who is Chinese at the beach this summer and she tells me her friends think she doesn't act Asian enough so I guess this issue of not being enough of your race crosses all boundaries. I even see this with Obama, others accusing him he doesnt act black enough. What about you, do you get this from people? Does others acting outside of their race, bother you? why?
1 person likes this
3 responses
@SHUGA81 (220)
• United States
17 Aug 08
In Junior High and High School I used to get that I am not black enough. And that I act white. I am African American, my grandmother who used to be an English Teacher raised me. My Grandfather was a doctor. I come from a family that speak well and had a different way of carrying themselves. When I moved to an urban neighborhood, kids didn't like the fact that I wasn't "ghetto". I always used to ask myself, what does that mean? I moved from there to a neighborhood which is predominantly hispanic and a few black families there too and went to a high school that was 85% hispanic and still I wasn't black enough. I was too white because I spoke well, dressed differently, and listened to all kinds of music. It was ridiculous. In college, this black guy was talking to me and I enjoyed the conversation, and I overheard him tell one of his friends that i wasnt black enough. Luckily I had friends who liked me for who I am. And I started acting differently to fit in, they will think something was wrong. Be who you are and dont let some people tell you any different. The way I am today is because I was raised differenly.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Aug 08
Im some so glad girlfriend that you stayed true to being Y-O-U and you encourage me and maybe others who read this that its not the end of the word to stick out of the crowd if it means staying true to yourself. In my mind your Spirit knows whats right for you and even if you are not true to yourself and try to change for the needs of others that you will never be ultimately satisfied until you listen to what you want and answer the call.
@gabbana (1815)
• China
18 Aug 08
hi, that's not so good for you. i've never experienced that. but i do notice when people go to another city, the locals sometimes repell new comer or strangers. that's true in every city in my country.
• United States
18 Aug 08
Yea, I see that with the upper classes being able to do that but not being obvious in their discriminations, but people do discriminate but in a way that is passive otherwise they will most likely get in trouble or harsh words at least.
@gabbana (1815)
• China
18 Aug 08
hi, i don't feel i can do anything but ensure myself treat people kindly as possible. have a nice day.
@jerzgirl (9327)
• United States
16 Aug 08
Well, I'm white, but my kids are half-Mexican American. My ex is of Mexican descent, but his family has ALWAYS been in what are the current boundaries of the US since before it was the US. Yet, even within his family and with him, the us/them push was heavy. And, I'll admit - I just don't completely understand it. Oh, don't get me wrong...I do understand the reason for much of the feeling behind it (oppression, discrimination, victimization, etc) and I witnessed fair shares of ignorance and prejudice against my son when he began acting out and drawing attention to himself as well as the strange questions of others about him (I don't understand why he has such dark hair and skin - your his mother and you have red hair and freckles! Apparently, in some minds, I should be capable of asexual reproduction.) But, I watched as my then-husband repeatedly told our son how he would never succeed in this world because of his ethnicity while our daughter would because her physical characteristics were more white. Yet, when my son had his baseball cap on backwards during a little league game once, he hollered at him for trying to "look like a stinkin' Mexican"! This from the same man!! The poor kid didn't know who to identify with!! It's no wonder our son has so many problems with his self-esteem and employment. After we divorced, my son moved back with his dad and Dad never made him go to school, so my son only has an 8th grade education. He's not stupid, but neither is he educated by society's standards - yet, somehow, his failures are due to the oppressive nature of the dominant society, not his father's failures to encourage learning or to even encourage success. So, while I admit a definite lack of complete understanding because of my not having grown up as a minority, I do have a bit of experience in seeing some of it first hand. However, I still can't understand why, if people want their children to be on a level playing field, they don't teach their children inclusive behaviors instead of insisting they either act or talk different or that they should assume their differences guarantee failure (and then blame others when that teaching takes fruition). And, I mean white parents as much as I mean parents of color. It takes all members of a society to achieve equality. I commend your parents in giving you a strong sense of self, in teaching you about your ancestral background and giving you good reason to feel pride in it. I also commend you in knowing that genetic background should not determine personal behavior. I think we should all just be people....who just happen to have different genealogies we can EACH be proud of.
• United States
17 Aug 08
Sounds like your sons father is feeling some strong frustrations of his own and its unfortunate it had to turn that way but never stop stressing the importance of education to your son because maybe if he is able to just get a GED then that could open up more opportunities further in his life then if he was just with the 8th grade completion, I do not even think you can serve the army without a GED. My youngest sister (also adopted and Mexican descent) actually became pregnant at age 14 which blew us all away but thankfully she had the support of the family (I was living with my dad at that time) and she did finish high school and I push her to go back to school because she does talk about wanting to and thats all I can do is support in that. I understand your frustrations though. I am a little nervous about my own daughters since they are Turkish American. I know that other Turkish kids can be rather harsh with other Turkish kids who don't know the latest Turkish music or don't speak fluent Turkish and so on, and personally I think it comes from their own insecurities with growing up in America and trying to still hold on to their culture because their is a lot of pressure there but I just want my two daughters to be proud of all of it. My boyfriend is sometimes like a fish out of water because he grew up in America and I can tell he has trouble relating to some Turkish people who came staight from Turkey because they bring customs that my bf doesn't have to conform to here in America, see what I mean? Good thing is that he has a HUGE family that knows plenty other families and they band together and he has a lot of people he keeps in touch with and he does speak fluent Turkish. I will admit at times I do feel a little confused sometimes because society sets these categories of race but I do not feel like I fit perfectly into one just because of my background even though I am biologically native american but the way you were brought up molds your character too.