Muhammed rafi vs. kishoe kumar
By mkarthik91
@mkarthik91 (6)
India
November 5, 2006 10:27am CST
Hey guys,
I am a singer and a follower of Muhammad Rafi Saheb. But a some of people disagree with me as they think tht Kishore kumar is better. Write down ur opinion on who is better?
Muhammad Rafi or Kishore kumar?
5 responses
@Goodfellow (1)
•
20 Jun 10
Rafi is great! no comparison. Comparing kishore to Rafi is like comparing coal with Diamond! Rafi had the greatest voice and greatest singer of all times
@jbakshi (63)
• India
22 Nov 06
It's very surprising that you, who claims to be a singer himself, can come up with such a question!! How on earth can you compare them? Both of them were legends in their own rights. Some prefer Rafi-saab while others prefer Kishoreda - just like some prefer Chinese cuisine while others prefer Italian cuisine. Can you tell me which cuisine is "better"? You can't. Nobody can.
So please my friend, for heaven's sake, try not to come up with such ridiculous questions/debates. If you're genuinely into singing - be it as a profession or as a hobby - give the art some respect.
@Mohan070983 (764)
• India
5 Nov 06
am a fan of kishoreda...
Voice..
Quality
Pitch
Variation
Taan
Laye
Sur
Uthan
Then Who sang more songs
who sang difficult songs
who sang variety of songs
who experimented with his voice
who sang classical
who sang for variety of actors
who sang with variety of musicians
who was better when singing live
if we compare all aspects kishoreda comes... as de winner