Palin got it wrong on community organizing!
By sumpter
@sumpter (214)
United States
September 4, 2008 1:25am CST
I was so excited to hear her speak tonight and she was pretty good until she started feeding into the partisan crap. Her poking fun at community organizing was sad. What does she think the PTA represents? That is a form of community organizing, and I am sure soccer moms do some organizing themseleves. It was a poor attempt at attacking Obama and in effect mock one of our fundalmental rights as Americans, and that is the right to assemble as a community.
1 person likes this
2 responses
@soccermom (3198)
• United States
4 Sep 08
I totally agree with you sumpter! I am an Obama supporter, but being the open minded person I am, I watched last night thinking maybe, just maybe, there would be some glimmer that would make me understand all the support behind her and McCain. And I also wanted to learn more about Palin. Which didn't happen. To me she came across as very smug and elitist. I could never picture myself sitting down and having a cup of coffee with her.
I don't think she really dug into any of the issues. She made snide remarks, but didn't back anything up with what her or McCain would do to solve the problems. Her remarks about community service totally offended me. Community service is the backbone of what makes this country great. Where would Katrina victims have been without community service minded people? My FIL went with his church group to NOLA right after Katrina and busted his butt to do what he could to help. Should that be laughed at? My aunt in Texas took in total strangers when Gustav was coming so they would have a safe haven, should that be mocked?
I don't mean to get off subject, but her remarks about the "bridge to nowhere" about made me scream. The fact of the matter is she fully supported that project until she found out Alaska would have to pitch in to pay for it. Then she opposed it, but guess what? Alasks still kept all the federal money that was to go for that project!
I didn't hear anything I was looking for in the terms of solving the energy crisis. It's almost as though she mentioned alternative energy sources as an afterthought. Like they weren't anything to be taken seriously. But coming from Alaska I would assume her state would reap great benefit from drilling for more oil there. Her environmental record is a joke, and just shows that she is more concerned with the revenue oil drilling would bring than she is about the environment.
I for one am very dissappointed. Last nights spectacle just proved to me that she's more of the same. And shame on McCain for thinking that as a woman I'd fall for his transparent effort to get more votes.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I heard today that the person who wrote her speech is a former speech writer for George Bush so she had no choice but to come across as Washingtonized since that's where her words came from. I was also disappointed in the half truths about how Obama wanted to raise taxes. Didn't I read somewhere that the tax hikes were only for those folks who earn waaaaay more than any of us...or did I just dream that?
1 person likes this
@ZephyrSun (7381)
• United States
4 Sep 08
I watched the speech last night too, thinking that we would see the reformer side, the side that isn't Washingtonized, but to me she didn't come off that way. She had no problem with slinging mud and not only making snide remarks about Obama's community service, which I find completely offensive, but also his education. I hear all the time from many different sources, that our education on today children is the pits and we need to educated children better so they can compete with China and various other countries, but to then mock someone's education from one of the best colleges in our nation, it really left a sour taste in my mouth.
1 person likes this
@sumpter (214)
• United States
5 Sep 08
We were both in the same boat. I really expected this "maverick" to take my breath away and get excited about the proposed change the republican party had in store for this country. After the RNC has not concluded, I am convinced the party has no ideas for change and that the convention was nothing more than a smear the otherside convention. How embarassing? I mean, some of it can be that, but when not one issue is talking about seriously, how can I take the party seriously? Everyone seemed to be edging on each presenter, never questionning anything. I have no faith, no I know I am voting for Obama. I scared that not many republicans saw through the what wen down at the RNC. Its time to open their eyes.
@piasabird (1737)
• United States
4 Sep 08
Oh please give me a break!
Did you watch the Democratic National Convention? They talked smack on McCain and the whole Republican party. That's politics. Last night was the Republicans turn.
Obama went from being a community organizer to grabbing a senate seat. He has very little experience in anything else. She has more experience than being in the PTA.
Mocking our rights? I don't think so. She was mocking Obama's running for president when he credentials are so thin. I think she did an excellent job of showing where Obama is weak.
@sumpter (214)
• United States
4 Sep 08
I did watch the DNC. However, a big difference does exist right now. At the DNC, I heard a lot of discussion about the issues. There was so red meat, but it wasn't the only the thing the convention was about. So far the RNC has been nothing but stump speeches about nothing. Nothing on how to fix the economy and nothing on American innovation, jobs or education. Nothing of substance. He went from community organzing to teaching. Then he was elected in the state senate in his state before becoming a U.S. Senator. I know she has more experience than being on the PTA, my point was that being on the PTA is a form of community organizing. A collective body of parents who want to have a hand in the fate of the children in the community. Some do bake sales, church gathering and all the sort to make that point. I think that a good quality to have and all they did was make fun of it. I was surprised that Palin would stoop that low and if she was in Alaska now would not be so against the community organizing. Fine, if Obama is weak than I want to hear how the McCain Palin ticket will fair on the important issues. I am sorry sir, but there was none of that.
@sumpter (214)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I know exactly what community organizing is and the type he was involved in. The land deal was something completely different. When the steel plant closed down, a lot of people lost their jobs. He was able to get the community united in getting more jobs and training in the community so that other plant closing did not decimate communities. This happens all over the country and people do not know how to respond to it.