Men:- Silent, strong and unexpressive ?

@alokn99 (5717)
India
September 7, 2008 3:12am CST
As boys we are taught not to cry, to control fear and ignore pain. Trained to believe that man should be strong and silent, to have control over the softer emotions and be unexpressive. In the American society this has been aptly called the cowboy syndrome. The term probably got from the behaviour of men in the old cowboy movies. This is changing in many societies and there is a definite increase in those who oppose this inability of man to deal with emotions ,and strongly suggest that men should communicate and express their enotions more openly. Would you evaluate men who express emotions more openly and often as insecure or unmanly ?
2 people like this
7 responses
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
10 Sep 08
I think the fact that men are more strong than their female counterparts has largely been instilled in us this thing. And if you allow me to modify, I would say, men can show their emotions but he should be wise enough to understand when and where to do so. They,( and women as well) just cannot get away with their emotions in any and every place. Can they? Our society is still largely patriarchal and we have been brought up watching our fathers and forefathers taking up the rein in their hands and controlling the proceedings of the house. In most cases then and in some cases even now, women were not disclosed about the men's occupation and remuneration and stuff like that. The point is we are made to believe in that way even before we could perceive anything. Men are strong, men are the masters and this is still so pertinent in our society. Now, however, things are changing. With more and more women running the edge with men, i think the disparity is narrowing down rapidly. Now as we can question our male counterpart we are also learning to accept them with their emotions. So, if a man cries it would mean that he is a hurt human and not only a hurt man! Generally speaking, I would rather not want to see any normal man or woman for that matter to go exuberant with his/her extreme emotions. Even though it's perfectly OK but we must have ensure proper civic decorum when and if in public places. Even if he wants to cry he can cry, rant or do whatever but in a more apt ambiance. And ofcourse men can express their emotions as much as women can do. Personally, I do not have any problem with that and that doesn't or does make a man insecure or unmanly. I would rather want my man to shred off his inhibition and express his emotions (to me alone though) more often. That would make both of us more strong and secure. Hope that made sense. smiles...
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
10 Sep 08
The ease and quantum of emotion men express does vary from one culture and society to another and as you have rightly put it, ours being a patriarchal society ,men are looked upto and expected to have constraint on expressing themselves, especially publicy with relation to the softer emotions. Men are human too and do have the urge and should be more expressive in this regard, but with the right amount of control and timing. When it comes down to our personal relationships and when we view it from our perspective to that of our partner, then the expections in terms of expressivness also increase be a it man or woman. Thanks for the great response. It certainly made a lot of sense.
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
19 Sep 08
I feel the discussion becomes good and special by the quality of the responses. Thanks a ton.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Sep 08
And what about the discussion thread itself?
• Philippines
13 Sep 08
Well given the facts that you provided, yes I think it can be considered unmanly in the cowboy sense, but it shouldn't be unacceptable to society and neither should it be called being insecure. Having the inability to express your emotions is a bad illness to have and it also inhibits other persons to know if you need them in your life. I'm glad I'm not raised in the cowboy way when it comes to my emotion because if I was I wouldn't be able to have a long and beneficial relationship with my dimsum. Though some may view me as weak for being able to express my feelings openly, I look at it as they only envy what I have in my life.
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
14 Sep 08
Thanks for sharing your views. Really appreciate it. It's a wrong perception that people can get so easily when you do not express your self openly.
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
19 Sep 08
Thanks again and have a great day.
• Philippines
19 Sep 08
I'm always happy to post my thoughts. Well Indeed its very hard to understand and help people who just won't open up and give a chance for others to help them.
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
7 Sep 08
Funnily enough there was a show on last night on cable here called "Extreme Makeover" where a new house was built for a family living on the plains somewhere in the US. The Father of the family was a cowboy through and through and he was crying openly on camera when he saw what had built for him and his family. He said "a real cowboy can cry if he so chooses to!" (Seriously! It is bizarre that your topic is so relevant to a show I watched last night in EGYPT of all places! lol) It is not a sign of insecurity or weakness for a man to show emotions but there is of course a time and a place. Anyone that would look at a man crying as weakness has issues themselves as far as I am concerned. It takes a bigger man to freely express themselves in this way than to always put on a brave face.
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
8 Sep 08
"A real cowboy can cry if he chooses to "- That really makes a lot of sense. The time and the place is also relevant, as there are instances that the man is expected to be in control and looked upon for solace from the family. James, on the bizarrness of the relevancy of the topic to the show that you watched , there might be something in it after. You can read the last part of the article i had recently written on AC. Might make some sense after all. http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/966076/projected_thoughts_and_emotions.html?cat=34 Thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
19 Sep 08
I only just noticed your reply and the link alokn! I must be on time delay or something? Thanks for sharing it and I will certainly read it!
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
8 Sep 08
I think there is no harm, if a man expresses his emotions, for example if he cries when some mishap takes place, I do not think anything is wrong in it, afterall he is also a human being. Crying does help brining out pent up emotions and gives a kind of satisfaction. But you are right, men are taught since childhood in such a manner that they feel scared to come out with their emotions in public.
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
9 Sep 08
Letting go of the emotions at times of grief is certainly acceptable. Further it does release the bottled up emotions. Thanks Dpk for responding and have a great day.
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
9 Sep 08
I entirely agree with you.
@cambiste (1244)
• India
9 Sep 08
Well, when one says "man" this is usually the image that one gets in mind. Men who act like girls, freely expressing themselves, usually have a lot of problems with the society - esp if their behaviour resemble girls too much. Personally, i like to be the unexpressive type, and i search for likewise in other men. Men of fewer words are wiser, and i find it all too true. However, "unexpressive" isnt what i really have in mind. More like "controlling your experessions" suit it better. The former may end up making you a silent and errie type, and make it seem like you have built a wall around yourself - and that's not good. However, being able to control your expressions, may create a fake mask, but the present society does demand it.
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
9 Sep 08
Controlling the expressions seems to be best way to put it. The influences of society does have a lot indeed to do with level of expression. Thanks for responding.
@valeria1 (2721)
• United States
8 Sep 08
I think men should express whatever they are feeling the same as woman should control a bit more! I think is not a problem at all a man that show his feelings!
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
8 Sep 08
"Women should control expressing their emotions a bit more"- That is an interesting point. I wonder what influence it will have on men expressing their emotions ? Thanks Valeria and have a great day.
@eagle_f15 (1827)
• Malaysia
7 Sep 08
Nope - I will not evaluate or rate men who express their emotions more openly as insecure or unmanly. My husband is very good at expressing his emotions and so are the some of the men in my church including my pastor. They are secure, manly and takes the role as head of their house who loves and proved for the family.
1 person likes this
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
8 Sep 08
Thanks for sharing your views and have a great day.