What Would You Substitute for the Bible as a Moral Guide?

@taurus54 (317)
Philippines
September 28, 2008 1:07am CST
You ask me what I would "substitute for the Bible as a moral guide." I know that many people regard the Bible as the only moral guide and believe that in that book only can be found the true and perfect standard of morality. There are many good precepts, many wise sayings and many good regulations and laws in the Bible, and these are mingled with bad precepts, with foolish sayings, with absurd rules and cruel laws. But we must remember that the Bible is a collection of many books written centuries apart, and that it in part represents the growth and tells in part the history of a people.. We must also remember. that the writers treat of many subjects. Many of these writers have nothing to say about right or wrong,about vice or virtue.
2 responses
• India
28 Sep 08
as you had asked for a substitute for bible as a moral guide,there are a number of holy books like bible in other religions like geetha of hindu religion and quran of islam.even these holy books serve as a moral guide.i am a hindu and belive and try to follow some of the saying from "Bagavath Geetha".if you apperitiate reading other religion holy books then do read Geetha, it will really serve you as a best moral guide
@taurus54 (317)
• Philippines
28 Sep 08
You have points manjalvaanam,but I would like,for the benefit of our christian brothers,to check the entire contents of the bible if it really justify their claim. Let's start with the old testament: The book of Genesis has nothing about morality. There is not a line in it calculated to shed light on the path of conduct.No one can call that book a moral guide. It is made up of myth and miracle,of tradition and legend. In Exodus we have an account of the manner in which Jehovah delivered the Jews from Egyptian bondage. We now know that the Jews were never enslaved by the Egyptians; that the entire story is a fiction. We know this, because there is not found in Hebrew a word of Egyptian origin, and there is not found in the language of the Egyptians a word of Hebrew origin. This being so, we know that the the Hebrews and Egyptians could not have lived together for hundreds of years. Certainly Exodus was not written to teach morality. In that book you cannot find one word against human slavery. As a matter of fact,Jehovah was a believer in that institution. The killing of cattle with disease and hail,the murder of the first-born, so that in every the murder of the first-born, so that in every let the Hebrews go, certainly was not moral;it was fiendish. The writer of that book regarded all the people of Egypt, their children, all the people of Egypt, their children, of Pharaoh, and these people and these cattle were killed, not because they had done anything wrong, but simply for the purpose of punishing the king. Is it possible to get any morality out of this history?
1 person likes this
• India
30 Sep 08
i am inteligent enough to decide for myself and do not require any scriptures to know what is moral and what is immoral. i trust my intelligence. i trust myself. i can differentiate from a good deed and bad deed. i know what is beneficial for humanity. i am inteligent enough to decide for myself. i know how to correct myself and move towards truth and knowledge. proof is - my own actions. i did not waste myself in preaching any utopian faith to anyone. i have guided many people to good ways where in they benefited. i did not ask them what their faith and whom they worship. Now who is moral? Me or the scripture?