What if your child comes home late?
By cmathias12
@cmathias12 (1025)
Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
September 28, 2008 1:38am CST
I have a teenage daughter age 13 and sometimes she comes home late. The most time she is ever late is 30 minutes. When I was younger, if I was late home even 2 minutes I would get in severe trouble by my mother. I do not get after my daughter this way. Instead I tell her that it makes me upset because I worry about someone taking here and the time to check in is a safe communication we use to make sure everything is ok. She is still late on occassion but I still do not want to become that upset at her. I can remember when I was a child loosing track of time but my mother treating me like a criminal for being late. What are your thoughts on this subject. Would you punish your child if he or she was late?
1 person likes this
8 responses
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
20 Nov 08
I think that 30 minutes late is forgiveable. As long as she understands that you worry when she is late but that you will genuinely listen to and understand her excuses, you will build a position of trust and caring between you. What is important (especially at her age) is to allow her to make her own decisions ... with your agreement, of course. She's not your slave or property and she is (in her own mind - and you should understand it, too) no longer a child.
Being on time for appointments is a very good habit to get into, whether it's being home on time, getting to school or work on time or not being late for interviews or meetings. If you punish automatically for being late, her mind will go into rebel mode and it will reflect on her promptness for anything, maybe for the rest of her life, because there will always be that 'little parent' inside her wagging its finger at her!
If she has a cell phone, let her get into the habit of always texting or calling if she's expecting to be late. It's much better if there's an unavoidable delay or even a change of plan. Communication with caring is what it's all about.
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
20 Nov 08
It's sad that a tragic event has to be the means of making her understand but that is often the way - it sometimes takes something like that to 'bring home the home truths'. Sometimes positive and good things can be the result of something evil (which in no way excuses or condones the evil, of course).
I'm glad, anyway, that you and your daughter see eye to eye on this now!
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
20 Nov 08
Thank you, I am happy also. I just am relieved that it wasn't her. I can not even begin to imagine what that other child is going through but like you said, sometimes it takes an extreme act like that to bring young ones to their senses. I don't worry about being to over protective now. Someone has to be for your children. No one else is going to be that protector for you.
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
20 Nov 08
I am not realy looking at the situation as do I need to forgive her for ever being late. Of course there is no question of forgiveness because she is my child, there is nothing to forgive. The situation is kind of like the little boy who cried wolf. If you are always late whether it be 30 minutes or 2 hours, there may come a time when something happens and unfortunately I will not think that she is late because of a bad situation but because it is her habit to come wandering in late. All of this has been settled because of a tragic rape that happened this week a block away from our home to another child who lives near us. I am now walking her and her friends to and from the places they would like to hang out. As far as not being a child in her mind, I remember being 13 and thinking that I was no longer a child but I also remember that I was no were close to being able to make an adult type of decision. Because of this unfortunate thing that has happened my daughter understands my worry now and has done a 360.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
29 Sep 08
My oldest son is only 11, but he definately knows that when he is told to be home at a certain time, he is to be home. I let it go the first couple of times, but the third time, I had told him to come home and check in at a certain time and he was late, I made him stay home the rest of the day. I don't feel that it is treating him like a criminal to punish him for being late. I am teaching him to be responsible and punctual. I have not had any further incidences with him since I took away his priviledge that one time. Now, he is sure to be home a couple of minutes early.
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
2 Oct 08
When I state being treated like a criminal, I do not use all punishment in this statement. My outlook comes from an abusive mother and sometimes it is hard to know when I am being too lenient because I refuse to be that harsh. I think that the way things worked for your son and you is great but considering the different person my daughter is, this would not work. She would not stop doing it after one time of being punished.
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
3 Oct 08
There are no worries to the consistency. That I am adamant about. The parenting tool that I hold firm to is talk first. When my daughter and I sit down and discuss why she is late, she gives me a reasonable answer but who can say there is always something holding her up, legit situation anyways, LOL!I hope that she is being as honest as I think she is butif not then I will have to change my way of handling the situation.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
2 Oct 08
only you know what will make you daughter listen the best. I know it may sound like a harsh punishment, but maybe if you made her miss out on something she really enjoys enough times, she would begin to respect your time limits. Unfortunately, right now she sees that if she is late, it won't really matter. The punishment needs to be fitting and yet make a statement so she will understand that you are not joking, more importantly, you need to be consistant.
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
28 Sep 08
Hey cmathias, That's entirely up to you as you are her
mother. I'm not really sure how you should treat this
but, if it is something that she keeps doing after
you keep telling her not to then I think that you
should maybe start showing her that you are more
serious about her coming home late. You don't have
to treat her like a criminal, but you do need to
impress upon her that she needs to follow your
instructions and be home when you tell her. If she
is already taking advantage at the age of 13 what are
you going to do when she is 16? If she isn't listening
now you are going to really have your hands full in a
few more years if you don't set some ground rules now
while she is still young enough to deal with.
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
28 Sep 08
Yes I was that naughty teenager, LOL! But I am fortunate with my daughter because she is a good kid. She listen almost always but has her trouble of time getting away from her. I do agree that I may need to implement a more serious discussion if this continues.
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
28 Sep 08
If it only happens once or twice I think it is not a big deal. But if it happens a lot, I would tell her not to promise something that she would break anyway. It is not about coming home late, but it is about breaking the rule and the promise that she made. If she had something come up in the way, I think she can still keep contacting me and confirm when she would be back
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
2 Oct 08
I never thought of it that way. I do have to say that she did purchase her own cell phone so we could have contact at all times. That was very responsible on her part but I think with her age she still gets caught up and that is the part that worries me.
@lunelden88 (90)
• Philippines
29 Sep 08
hello cmathias, i suggest that you give your daughter a condition if she came late at home. like for example you wont give her an allowance if she get late. ?
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
2 Oct 08
Nice suggeston but as far as money goes she is very involved in babysitting and could care less about the allowance she may loose over it. She also has purchased her own cell phone so limiting her use is off limits, for me anyways. I respect her for being responsible enough topurchase and pay for her own cell phone at the age of 13 and I do not feel that it is my right to take away what she works hard for. But I will think about other options to use with your suggestion.
@mohdabzel (1)
• Malaysia
29 Sep 08
I will give him a first warning and a second one,and on the third time if he still come home late ,i will ground him for going out for a week
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
2 Oct 08
LoL, I guess that woul be a way of getting your point across
@guybrush (4658)
• Australia
28 Sep 08
I hate it when family members are home late, cmathias. We still have our 21yo son living at home, and even though he's that age, I still like to know whether to expect him home for the night or not. It's common courtesy for him to tell us, I feel, while he's living under our roof. Teenagers are an extra worry, and I know just how you feel when your daughter is late. Maybe you could punish her by making her miss the next outing - she won't be happy, but you can explain what it's like from a parent's point of view to be sitting waiting, with horrible things going through your mind. Missing one outing will give her time to think about how her lateness impacts on her family. Does she have a mobile phone? If so, she could send you a text message or phone you if she was running late, to let you know she was safe and on her way.
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
28 Sep 08
She does have a cell phone and she actually bought it herself for this very reason. I know she is a good kid and is not doing this on purpose but of course as you said, us parents do worry.
@amlegend (945)
• Pakistan
28 Sep 08
no way dear..punshing your child is not the solution of this problem.as far as my thinking goes in this regard,you must talk to your daughter with love and try to convience her to be careful.she is little now and will only understand the language of love not of stick.if u would be harsh t her,may be she grts out of your hand forever.so be careful and do not punish her
@cmathias12 (1025)
• Armed Forces Canada, Europe, Middle East
28 Sep 08
Yes I agree with you. The point I am trying to make is that my mother made me fearful of her. I never respected her authority. I do not want my children to be fearful of me so I am easier on them or I guess you could say I do it differently.