Why are my mashed potatoes always bland?

United States
October 7, 2008 6:01pm CST
I can cook lots of things, but not mashed potatoes. When I cook mashed potatoes, they always end up tasting bland or gross. I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong. Is there some way to spice up mashed potatoes to make them taste more gourmet? What's your best gourmet mashed potato recipe?
11 people like this
38 responses
• Canada
8 Oct 08
The only way to know what you are doing to make them bland is to know how you cook them. My mother uses lots and lots and lots of butter, and hers are not bland at all. danes use lots of butter in things, and maybe even a pinch of salt. Then they are served with meat and lots of gravy. Yummy! Now all of a sudden I want some mashed potatoes. You made me hungry.
3 people like this
• United States
8 Oct 08
There must be a lot of Danes in the South, cause we use butter like crazy!
• Canada
8 Oct 08
You know from experience, that there is NO margarine in this house. There will always only be real butter. I also recommended further down in this thread, to add a little Danish Esrom while mashing. The taste is unsurpassible.
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I normally add milk, butter, salt and pepper to mine. Sometimes I will make them like a loaded baked potato and add sour cream, chives, bacon, and shredded cheese. This one sounds really good to me. I might try it tomorrow night with dinner. CHEESY BBQ GARLIC MASHED POTATOES 1 lb potatoes, peeled 3 tablespoons butter or spread 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder 1/4 cup bbq sauce 2 tablespoon vinegar 1/2 cup sharp cheese, shredded Cut potatoes and cook in boiling water until tender. Mix BBQ sauce with Vinegar. Drain potatoes, and place in large bowl with butter or spread and BBQ sauce mixture. Mix to desired consistancy, then fold in garlic powder and cheese.
2 people like this
• United States
8 Oct 08
That sounds phenomenal! I'm going to bookmark this page and try out the recipe as soon as I can get the ingredients. Thanks!
1 person likes this
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I have everything I need to make them, so it is on the menu for tomorrow night. It sounds like it might be a keeper.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
8 Oct 08
yummy... i'm drooling :P~ i'm gonna give this recipe to my sis and ask her to make it and if it taste really good then i'm gonna ask her to make it when i'm at home. yeah!!! then again i think maybe i'll do it myself and make her go 'she can cook?' haha
1 person likes this
@egdcltd (12059)
8 Oct 08
Try adding things like cheese, herbs, pepper, garlic to them.
2 people like this
• United States
8 Oct 08
If you like ranch dressing, (Hidden Valley is the best), after you make your potatoes, add some of that in the potatoes. It gives it a great flavor, I also add a little lemon pepper and garlic salt as well. It is really good!
@GardenGerty (160665)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I like lemon pepper seasoning on fresh tomatoes. It is just so zippy.
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I'm a huge fan of Idahoan instant mashed potatoes. You only need water and they are great! My favorite homemade mashed potato recipe was passed down from my dad. He used 4 different kinds of cheeses and even added shrimp to his, but mine is a bit simpler. Just 8 oz of cheddar cheese, a pint of sour cream, and a couple handfuls of bacon pieces.
2 people like this
@samijo719 (1052)
• United States
8 Oct 08
When I make mased potatoes from scratch I always add lots of butter. Then I add Garlic salt and Seasoning salt. This gives them a nice flavor and they aren't bland. They always seem to turn out super yummy!
2 people like this
@GardenGerty (160665)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I do whatever strikes my fancy. #1 I like little red potatoes, and mash them skin on. #2 Ranch dressing, either the powder, or some bottled dressing. #3 Blue cheese crumbles. #4 White cheddar #5 Parmesan #6 Garlic powder #7 Use chicken broth to cook them in. #8 Use horseradish sauce, and bacon bits.#9 Powdered onion soup mix instead of salt. #10 The original, butter, salt, black pepper, milk.
• United States
8 Oct 08
Sounds really good. I like the chicken broth idea. I think our water is making the potatoes taste bad during boiling.
@Calais (10893)
• Australia
8 Oct 08
I always boil mine with salt, that adds flavour, or flabours I like is, finly chopped raw onions, or fresh parley chopped fine mashed through it...
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Oct 08
When I'm boiling them I add a few beef bullion cubes to the water. After they are cooked, I add enough butter to make mash them, I think most people will add milk first. I add the butter till they are creamy, then add some salt and pepper, maybe a little bit of garlic powder, and then put in enough milk to whip them up so they are whipped and creamy. I usually leave about half of the peel on them too.
1 person likes this
@CatsandDogs (13963)
• United States
8 Oct 08
Idaho Spuds - Taste pretty good!
My dad always made mashed potatos with canned milk instead of regular milk. They always taste much better that way. He's more of an experimenter than mom is and that's how he learned this. The kind we all buy is the boxed kind called Idaho Spuds and they taste great! Try that, I bet you'll like it too!
1 person likes this
@Ldyjarhead (10233)
• United States
8 Oct 08
You said you're not sure what you're doing wrong, but you haven't mentioned what it is you're doing. I usually just use butter and salt, and maybe a dab of milk. I often use garlic powder too. If I have sour cream on hand, a little sour cream can sometimes find it's way in there. I taste as I go and add more of whatever I think it needs. So, what are you doing?
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Oct 08
I don't have a set recipe. It varies each time. That's part of the problem.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
8 Oct 08
Garlic Powder and a bit of salt with butter will spice the flavor up. I usually buy the seasoned mashed potatoes.. These are very delicious! You should try these, that way you won't have to seasoned it by hand..
1 person likes this
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
8 Oct 08
all i put in mine are alot of butter, salt,pepper & milk. tates good to me.
1 person likes this
@mienkoos (95)
• Netherlands
8 Oct 08
I always cook my potatoes together with a cube of bouillon. When I mash the potatoes I put the bouillon into a cup and add it slowly while mashing. I like the flavour although its not as creamy as mashed potatoes with butter.
• United States
8 Oct 08
Super tip! Welcome to Mylot!
• United States
23 Oct 08
I always put butter and salt and pepper in mine. I like real creamy mashed potatoes. I've also added sour cream and shredded cheese to mine before and that was good too.
• United States
9 Oct 08
add either sour cream instead of butter or maybe just a bit of powdered garlic. either makes it a bit fancier without much effort.and it tastes good :)
@CanadaGal (4304)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
I no longer bother with real mashed potatoes for meals. Instead I buy the "Betty Crocker" instant mashed potatoes. They come in plain, butter and herb, or garlic. They're all fantastic too! And oh so easy! (which is my favourite part lol). I'm sure you could add a package of them to real mashed spuds, as long as you added enough extra water and milk of course. One thing I know about potatoes, is that the best flavour is nearest the skin. Perhaps you should try mashing them with the skins still on? They taste phenomenal that way! I've heard of people adding chicken broth (such as from a can of Campbell's soup), and that intensifies the flavour as well. You could also add sour cream to give them a thicker and richer taste.
@bmorehouse1 (1028)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I find that sometimes its the kind of potatoes you use. I think red potatoes are more mushy and don't have as much flavor as white potatoes. I always use white potatoes. I mash all the potatoes before adding anything, because if they aren't completely mashed and you add milk and butter, they will turn out lumpy. I actually prefer to use the instant mashed potatoes. They are easy to make and have a good flavor. You can't go wrong. Sometimes I have added a few instant potatoe flakes while mashing the real ones. It seems to make the real ones better - (Maybe thats all in my head)! Good luck!
• United States
8 Oct 08
Try this : add real butter ( Food Lion has a inexpensive sweet cream butter) and a dash of garlic powder to them. Or, if you prefer a bit of zest to them- use malabar pepper in them. This works for baked potatoes and most types of noodles too!
@PrarieStyle (2486)
• United States
8 Oct 08
I put sour cream in mine instead of milk. Don't forget a little salt and pepper. Sometimes I even use chip dip if I don't have sour cream.