Ever had to deal with "Selective Response Syndrome" on myLot?
By James72
@James72 (26790)
Australia
October 13, 2008 1:51am CST
I am sure we have all suffered the effects of this on mylot every once in a while. You know, the instances when you respond to someone's discussion and when you check back to the post you see that the owner of the discussion has replied to most of the responses but not yours! Or EVERY response except yours! lol.
So what does this mean then? An oversight maybe; or something far more sinister? Mwah-ha-ha-ha-hah! How do you feel in such a situation?
33 people like this
84 responses
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
13 Oct 08
Suspicious Mind is it James !. Jumping to a lot of conclusions.
Actually i've noticed a sort of a trend.
There are those like you who go in serial order of the responses received.
Then there are those who respond to their friends first.
Then the third category are those who respond to the interesting responses and some to the simpler responses first.
And of course there is the category of those who do not repond at all.
So instead of checking on the discussions, i tend to see my mail notifications to see them. Unless of course there is something i've said and eagerly await a reaction and a response. Still No response here. A bit of disappointment, but would leave it at that.
6 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Suspicious? It's a personal vendetta alok I just KNOW it! lol. I never went as far as determining the trends so thanks for doing the hard yards in this regard! I have just always found it intriguing, especially when there are discussions where very single response except for mine has been replied to! I don;t have notifications on either by the way. This got the boot a week after I joined as it was driving me insane! I get enough emails per day as it is without having to deal with that also. Thanks for the comments and you have your response now so breathe easy my friend!
3 people like this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
13 Oct 08
May be my response did not amuse him, may be I have negated him outright, may be he chose not to comment for he didn't get me right. But the most convincing to me would be that he forgot, his careless eyes missed or even my avatar did not amuse him. hahaha.
Having said this, its difficult to catch up on the comment thing when you have to do justice to more that hundred. You do have to be selective. Unintentional selectiveness - i would say.
Seriously, however, 'selective response syndrome' would make me little annoyed. I mean , how can he ignore me!! The response that took me time, soul and serious thinking! That's offputting.
4 people like this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
13 Oct 08
Hang on there. Will catch you in a bit..
Please..
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
That's a lot of maybe's mimpi! And any reason why it is always a "he"? lol. I agree that in many cases where most have been replied to but not your own then it is probably an oversight; and it is clear to see patterns with some members where they either don't answer anyone at all or just a select few friends. I have to admit that in the cases where it is clear that I am the only one or one of a handful of responses NOT replied to then I tend to get a little annoyed too.
And yes, it can be a tremendous challenge replying to each and every response when you get a good number of them but I do it and I will continue to do it as long as I am able. As per your statement, it took time, soul and serious thinking so if an effort is made then I shall always make one in return! Thanks for the comments mimpi.
2 people like this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
13 Oct 08
I do it sometimes in my discussions. If I have nothing to comment, I usually don't....and move on to the next response in my discussions. I also tend to try and comment to all my friends (people I interact with often) and not always to new people who respond to my discussion (when there's nothing to add or comment).
So, when I see this same trend in a discussion that I have responded to....I really don't mind. But it's a different matter if this happened in a friend's discussion and I realize I'm the only one without a comment. If it's a really good friend, I might message or write a comment asking if my response was not worth a comment. But if it's an acquaintance, I would forget about it after I logged out.
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
I do understand this mindset, sure. I too can struggle sometimes in finding ways to reply but I do end up doing so regardless. But I am also on mylot considerably more than you are able to so time factors need to be considered as well. I would like to think though that I have never left a response that closes the dorr on that front! lol. I agree also that an oversight with known friends carries more concern than with an acquintance or new user but I have never PM'd somebody if they overlooked me yet. Thanks for your comments SViswan.
2 people like this
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
13 Oct 08
I don't bother getting all 'figure-figure' on it, I just stop responding to their discussions because I am pretty fond of communication, and while talking to myself can be very fun and even rewarding, it is not the same thing when I am talking (well, typing) to somebody else and feel just like I'm talking to myself, without the rewarding aspect.
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
You don't go putting hexes or anything on any of us do you? It's definitely not the same when it's all one sided. Some of the most entertaining echanges come from the sub-discussions! I stop responding to some people too for the very same reasons and it can be a shame sometimes because some of the topics can be very interesting and are worth far more conversation; but if they never come back with anything then it's just not worth the effort.
3 people like this
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Well, I do think "a$$hole", but the only person that affects is myself, so I try to think it really fast and then let it go, hehehe.
I absolutely agree with what you have said on the topic... I have stopped responding to a few users who post some very interesting discussions, but then never 'discuss'. What a waste, but I don't like the disappointment of getting no reply so I just stay away.
3 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Well it has been said that a discussion forum without responses is just like a novel, and without input from others or a differing storyline it gets boring after awhile, who is going to read the same book over and over and over?
I agree that some of the liveliest discussions ensue from all the off-topic chatter comments that pool under the original responses. As far as getting back to respond in your own posted discussions, I think we all need to cut people a LITTLE slack, I'm sure I have a few that I haven't gotten back to lol. You never know which ones will get 4 responses total and which ones will take off and have 85 responses within the 5 hours you're gone.
1 person likes this
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Hey james, I take it personal if it happens to the point
where I do see a pattern and it has and I have and I did
so I turned off my notifications on those people! And I'm
quite sure that they have no idea that I no longer respond
to them because they obviously didn't care in the first
place! So yes it is something sinister~an evil plot on
mylot! And I shall take care of those evil doers~so beware~
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Another member for the club then Opal! lol. (See the above reply for club details!). I have turned off notifications for ALL people so tend to go back to the responded section throughout the day to check what's what. I too would stop interacting with anyone that consistently fobbed me and I am sure many others would do the same. Thanks for responding and keep those eyes sharp Opal. If there's an evil plot it must never prevail!
2 people like this
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
13 Oct 08
I responded to 2 or 3 of your discussions Opal, and you never acknowledged me once. That is why I removed you from my friends list, I figure friends are interested in what you have to say, if they are not then what kind of a friend is that??
2 people like this
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Zigzagbuddha, I had no idea that you responded to my
discussions. I hardly ever even start any. I think I
may have started 6 or 7 in the 4 months that I have been
here. I am not the type of person to ignore people in
my discussions. If you commented late I might not have
seen it. I also don't get all my friends notifys, I never
did. I would never do that to anyone on purpose. You
read my comment. It came from the heart. It has been done
to me so why would I do that to you. I am truly sorry
if I did. I am sure I didn't see your comments. I don't
even skip over peoples comments. I would like us to be
friends. I am very upset about this. I am going to give
you a friend request and I hope you will accept so that
I can fix this. I hated when this was done to me and even
then I didn't delete anyone, although I should have. Please
give me a proper chance. I asked you to be my friend, so why
would I intentionally want to hurt you. There are alot of
glitches here on mylot. My pm's don't send. I can't even answer
someone when they pm me because if I try to send it disappears.
I am asking you for a chance to make it up to you, the choice
is yours. I truly apologize for any misunderstanding. I would
never set out to hurt anyone. Especially some I asked to be
a friend!
3 people like this
@SaintAnne (5453)
• United States
13 Oct 08
I feel cheated and lied to! I feel left out and doubt NOT my response but my being as a whole. I get annoyed at the user who is clearly ungrateful for my response. I pout and I swear I will NEVER reply to any of his/her discussions anymore.
Lol. I would be lying if I say it doesn't bother me at all. Of course, I wonder why I didn't get a comment back. But then I move on to another discussion where I may get left out again.
I did this myself. It was an oversight. I replied back to every response or so I thought. A few hours later, I saw a post in the middle of my page that I didn't see before. I felt soooo bad...
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
You too SaintAnne? Maybe we could start a club! "The Unreplied To's" (Or TUT for short!) I have to admit that it gets me wondering as well. I have missed the odd one myself too actually, like when someone replies to your own reply so I then don't realize that in between this someone else has added a new response..... But I do end up seeing this eventually and go back and reply. So once again you are not alone! Thanks for the response.
2 people like this
@Trace86 (5030)
• United States
9 Jan 09
I tend to try to respond to everyone who's response is even remotely on topic, if I can think of something to say to them. If a response is noncontributory, I can't really respond to it, unless it is to clarify what I was trying to ask.
How is your New Year going so far James?
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
9 Jan 09
Heya Trace. I reply to each and every response myself and will continue to do so as long as I am able. I do understand though that it can be a challenge because sometimes people don't come up with anything too detailed at all. But I guess i am one of those people that always has something to say, so even if they reply with a few words, I always seem to find something! lol. My New Year so far is shaping up nicely too thanks. I have high hopes for 2009 and am optimistic and positive as ever!
Sharra, I just don't bother interacting anymore with people that never bother to reply to anyone. Each to their own and I understand that not all members will reply to everybody and this is of course fine; but never replying to any at all? This is totally counterproductive and in my opinion, goes against the whole purpose of this site. I agree with you 100% that it is in our best interests to reply to all or as many as we can too. This gives our discussion more exposure, helps generate new friendships and creates opportunities to open up further discussion. Some of the most fun exchanges I have had came from subsequent chats within a discussion!
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
9 Jan 09
I try to do this as well but there are some people who never respond to anyone. I cannot understand why they even bother to set up discussions if they are not interested in what people have to say.
I agree that some responses are hard to reply back to but if you get lots then it can also be hard to keep replying to the same sort of responses with original replies. I also do not like it when people paste the same response to every response in the discussion. I try to do an original answer to everyone and it may take me a long time but it is worth it in the end.
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
I have had this happen to me also from time to time subha. As far as I am concerned, this provides us with a pretty clear indication that it is purely a one-way street so we may as well no longer make the effort with that particular user anymore. I do try to respond to the people that make the effort with me as much as I can but of course it isn't always easy. I hope I'm not one of these people you are referring to! Thnaks for your response.
2 people like this
@austere (2812)
• Philippines
13 Oct 08
whahaha.. i have experienced that and it feels really painful.. "OUCH" hahaha really, it's like they dont want to respond back to your response.. or they dont even acknowledge it.. well, for those who respond to mys discussions, i always see to it that i respond to them all.. i always log in to my mail, see the and check with my alerts if anyone has responded to a discussion that i have started..and make sure to respond back to them to make them feel that i am grateful that they respond to my discussion and that i really read their response too!
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
14 Oct 08
Oh the pain, the PAIN of it all! I don't use alerts myself actually so rely on monitoring the discussions as best I can from the site itself. It really IS all about gratitude so I appreciate your own mindset here. They make the effort and so shall I! I just hope I can continue to do so when things start to get really busy again for me soon. Thanks for the response austere.
@austere (2812)
• Philippines
14 Oct 08
hehe well, i would understand if you get busy.. what i hate is that they really skip when they respond back to the responses.. like they give back a comment on number 1, number 3 and number 4, skipping number 2 without any response!huhuhu but i dont really take it seriously though, i just feel a little not so happy.. but then again, i dont make it ruin my day!
1 person likes this
@vijigopi (991)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Yes, I've seen this happen and felt so hurt. Apart from the other reasons people have given, I feel that sometimes, people don't respond to responses if different from their point of view. I guess they just don't want to argue with disagreeing with a different person. And the fact that the person who has responded is also responsible for some earnings in their account, and they don't want to hurt their feelings. They might be feeling guilty about not responding to them alone, but don't know what to say either.
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Now this is where I LOVE to reply! If someone has a differing point of view then I have the opportunity to engage them further and have a really good conversation about it! It's a shame when they won't allow this to happen. It is pretty obvious too which users just post discussions for earnings only and I try to steer clear of these ones. Single sided activity is just no fun at all. Thanks for the comments vijigopi.
3 people like this
@vijigopi (991)
• United States
13 Oct 08
I agree too James and mommyboo... disagreeing makes the discussion a lot more interesting because the pros and cons are debated to and fro. But not all people love to argue, I suppose. Besides, they might just think we are nuts and keep moving on... hope nobody thinks I'm nuts now..
2 people like this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Well I for one am not afraid to discuss something, especially if it differs from my point of view. I have read some responses and had entirely NO understanding why the poster is so adamant that they feel the opposite of me. I usually respond because I want to know WHY - whether it's cultural, family/friends related, religious, political, whatever. Sometimes it's purely because of their surroundings and environment - they never even considered MY point of view at all because it's nonexistant or a rarity where they live, ie my discussion is the first time anybody ever questioned how they think or feel.
I have been on that side of the fence as well in discussions I have responded to. It tends to actually be more interesting than the discussions in which everybody says 'I agree...'.
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Better late than never right? I am not aware of any complaints about you mayka and I do not recall you never replying to my own responses to your discussions before either. Most of the people I know of on here are not like this at all and it is usually new people I come across that occasionally seem to exhibit these types of behaviours. Anyways, I will always make the effort to reply to all responses myself and if I ever come across people that repeatedly ignore my responses then I just won't make the effort with them anymore! Thanks for your comments.
2 people like this
@DaddyOfTheRose (2934)
• United States
14 Oct 08
I don't worry too much about that. Some people are very diligent about replying to people who post to their threads. Others, less so. If I happen to be skipped, I don't generally assume it was something intentional.
3 people like this
@DaddyOfTheRose (2934)
• United States
14 Oct 08
I can understand skepticism if you were the only one in 50 that was missed and it keeps happening. :(
2 people like this
@magda191919 (391)
• Romania
14 Oct 08
Happened to me and I can't explain that. Probably error, I still cannot believe this is a way of discriminating me. Or fear. Many people are now afraid to answer some discussions posted by the fresh MyLotters. A newbie has little chances to get answers to a discussion. They are afraid of newbies on MyLot, a newbie is a potential scam, his discussion may be deleted and he is loosing money ... This is what they think. Most of the people here answer your discussion if you are older and trusted. This makes me feel...well, not frustrated, but disgusted. Is anybody so afraid to loose 0.01c ? Cannot he judge if your discussion is or not a good one? I think YES.
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
15 Oct 08
My pleasure magda. Mylot is a complex ecosystem of online persona's and there will always be varying degrees of conflict an joys just like any other cimmunity. All we can ever be is ourselves and we can't ever make every single person happy either! In time, you will find yourself starting to understand the intricacies of this site more and more and your experiences will improve as a result. Just be patient, be always respectful; and be true to who you are!
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
14 Oct 08
This is an interesting aspect magda! I certainly am not afraid of any newbie? I do try to respond to newbie discussions whenever I can and have even made suggestions from time to time. The deleted discussion aspect is something I can relate to though, yes. I have to admit that there are certain discussions that I see posted that I will immediately avoid because I can see they are not within the rules. But then again this is not only newbie discussions, it's ANY discussion! Knowledge comes with time so we should all be patient with new people and help wherever we can. Thanks for responding and I hope that you are finding your way just fine! It certainly seems so.
1 person likes this
@magda191919 (391)
• Romania
15 Oct 08
Thank you so much for encouraging me. Is true, takes time to gain some experience in anything you start, even here, on MyLot, some people gain something, some not. And we all have something in common. Thank you again for the nice words. This place is a good opportunity to learn, no idea who is behind this system, but is an intelligent and complete one, I appreciate it.
1 person likes this
@thebohemianheart (8827)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Sometimes I just don't know how to respond to a response, so I let it go.
It doesn't bother me if one of my responses just sits there. I figure the person doesn't have anything to say about it, doesn't know exactly what to say, or they think it is just too dumb to deserve a response.
I have even gotten best responses for things that the originator didn't even respond to. So see, it doesn't really mean anything.
So, are you paranoid, or what?
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Paranoid? Who's paranoid??? Me?? Where? I don' understand? Well I am happy to say though Bo that in spite of all the whacked out afflictions you may actually have, this syndrome is thankfully NOT one of them! I too have received a BR for a response that was never replied to but whatever..... At least they acknowledged SOMETHING! lol. It is when I see all but mine get replied to once in a while that the old brain starts wondering is all. Thanks for the response and seriously, is there paranoia? I didn't realize I was paranoid?? Surely I'm not paranoid? I can't be..... Shhhhhhhh, they can HEAR us.
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
They're in my HEAD now??? Oh my God..... I knew they had become more advanced. I just KNEW it.
And Bo, I have always felt your insincerity so no harm no foul. Let's just keep playing the mylot game like good citizens and think no more of it.....
2 people like this
@thebohemianheart (8827)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Ummm, I just make stuff up to answer your responses. I know how you are, and I just don't want you to feel left out.
1 person likes this
@Tetchie (2932)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Fairly miffed actually James. I don't like it at all. Makes my mind go a bit ape, wondering whether they don't like me, or had a reaction to my comment in some way. As you know my responses bare little venom so that shouldn't be the case. So I'm stumped. Actually I think it may have something to do with not being in their 'in-crowd' Fine I say, I just won't respond in future.
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
13 Oct 08
Hi Tetchie! I too tend to get a little riled up when this happens and of course I then start wondering why this may be the case etc so thankfully it is not something that happens a lot otherwise I might go batty! LOL. Yes, you are definitely one of the more congenial members here and I was actually looking through my history here and you are one of those that I have been interacting with for the longest here on mylot so I would consider myself to be a good judge of character for you! Thanks for responding and be asured that you will always get a reply from me!
2 people like this
@Rosekitty (19368)
• San Marcos, Texas
9 Jan 09
3 months ago is this and i'm still waiting for you to respond to me..
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
13 Oct 08
Sinister? Well, you never know, halloween IS around the corner . I guess in answer to your question, yes I have had to deal with this. I don't think there's any clear reason why. Everybody has different ideas about things, maybe the answer you gave seems great to YOU but to the discussion starter maybe it just doesn't strike them as something to comment on. I admit to sometimes asking QUESTIONS in my response in order to encourage a response from the discussion starter, but it doesn't work every time.
I know that for me sometimes I won't answer if the response is one line, if it seems disconnected - for instance if it doesn't really answer the question, or if it seems to be nearly the same word for word as another response I got from a different person earlier in the thread.
I guess I also have to admit that I do tend towards ALWAYS answering responses from some friends - because I see they ALWAYS take the time to post in my discussions or comment to my comments wherever they see me. It's kind of a give what you get scenario as far as that goes.
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
14 Oct 08
I never even considered the Halloween factor mommyboo! I sometimes ask questions too but it doesn;t always work as you have stated yourself. Oh well. What does get me riled up though is when somebody posts a discussion regarding a topic that is new to me and I am eager to understand more; but when I ask more they just don't bother coming back. Now THAT can be frustrating! Personally I try very hard to make sure I do not get caught up in this stock standard answer cycle and I do try to be completely in context with my reply but it can definitely be a challenge at times! I have a core group of friends thankfully that make every effort and I in return so I am always grateful for this. I come to mylot as an escape from my daily work and to be able to lose myself in these exchanges is of great benefit to me. I do realize that time is a factor for many but my belief is simple really; ENGAGE people. If a person only wants to make a statement and then walk away then go publish an article or something! lol. Thanks for the response mommyboo.
1 person likes this
@richiem (3644)
• Philippines
15 Oct 08
Before, it was my routine to check discussions I have responded to to see if there have been comments to the response I made.
And it is really quite tiring doing so especially not all of them are commented.
That is why I just rely on email notifications for comments on my responses. It's easier that way.
Have a nice day!
@tismesara (113)
• United States
15 Oct 08
of course, i think its everyone.. sometimes maybe its just being tired of commenting or maybe even being tired of being on the computer and there ya go.. my take on it anyway!
2 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
15 Oct 08
I can assure you that it certainly isn't EVERYONE tismesara! I can honestly say that I have replied to every single response I have received over the last 6 months or so and as long as I am able to I will continue this way. I do appreciate that not everyone feels the same way though. And I agree with the middle response that spam can be an issues also. Thanks for your comments.