Pacify
By Humbug25
@Humbug25 (12540)
October 22, 2008 8:32am CST
When my kids were babies I had numerous arguements with my husband about giving our babies a pacifier/dummy. He would say that all the women in his country would give them to their babies when they cried. I always beleive that a baby cries for a reason and once you have sorted that out there would be no reason to stick a pacifier/dummy in their mouths. I wouldn't want to miss all the gurgling noises and cooing that they did either. It wasn't until his neice, a fully qualified pharmacist, told him that the constant sucking on a pacifier/dummy alters the shape of a baby's jaw line. He then thought that maybe they weren't such a good idea but wouldn't dream of telling me that maybe I was right not to give them one. Also I didn't want to get my kids addicted to having something that would break my heart to have to take away from them once they were older and in turn break their heart. I have seen how hard it is to take these things away from kids and I would have hated to go through the same thing. I think if one of my kids had started to suck their thumb then I wouldn't have had a choice but to give them a pacifier/dummy as a thumb you can't really take away.
So, did you/do you give your baby a pacifier/dummy?
3 people like this
17 responses
@wolfie34 (26771)
• United Kingdom
22 Oct 08
Why do you think Wolfie has stubbly thumbs? I was always sucking my thumb as a child! I didn't have a comfort blanket but my thumb was forever in my mouth, but on asking mum I didn't have a dummy as mum loved to hear my gurgling sounds, not so much now though LOL! Aren't men funny they won't admit they are wrong and even when they are wrong still won't back down and put their hands up and say 'ok I'm wrong' Call it male pride? I call it obstinancy. Still you can chalk that one up to a victory against your ex ha ha ha! Thumbs up my friend (once I take it out of my mouth that is!)
2 people like this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
22 Oct 08
lol...I had the same issue with my husband. And he wouldn't understand even after his aunt (who raised him) said that he was on a pacifier till he was more than 2 years of age and it was VERY hard to get him to stop.
I've used a pacifier with both my kids. With the first one, it started when we were travelling and he would need it just to fall asleep. But once he was 10 months old, I just took it off one day and he was fine.
The second one too...I started when I was travelling. But he NEEDED it everytime he wanted to sleep. That was worrying for me. And when I tried to stop him cold turkey...it was really hard...especially since my husband would stuff it into his mouth when it was his turn to put him to bed. It took me lots of arguing and really strong nerves (to bear with the screaming) to get my younger one to get off the pacifier when he was around 14 months old. But once he stopped, he wouldn't ask for it even when he saw it. He's 23 months old now...and just the other day he was crying in the night....and my husband said that we wouldn't have had to listen to it (and could have got some sleep) if we had continued with the pacifier. But I'd rather have one sleepless night without a pacifier than many days of sleep with a pacifier in my son's mouth!
My husband just wants the easy way out in everything.
2 people like this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
22 Oct 08
Hey there SViswan
I used to work as a nanny in the US and I babysat one little boy once as a favour to my boss and this little boys was about 3 but he wouldn't go to sleep unless there were 3 pacifiers under his pillow, one in each hand and of course one in his mouth! A bit excesive I think but it was what his parents did for an easy life I guess!
Thanks for your response
1 person likes this
@sunshine4 (8703)
• United States
22 Oct 08
I think up to a certain age the pacifier is good for the baby. It satisfies their desire to suck. And it give mom and dad a break when they can't figure out why the child is screaming. If a baby is crying because he is hungry, wet or hurt, he won't take a pacifier. If he is crying due to tiredness them they do. I see no harm in using them when the baby is a baby.
When a child is talking with a paci in their mouth, then enough is enough!! I have seen some of these and it is crazy.
I run a daycare and my rule is babies get the pacis. If you can talk, and the parents say they need a paci, they get it when the take a nap and that is all. I have one 2 yr old that asks for it all day and he only gets it at nap time. The parents give it to him all day and night when they are home. You can see that his teeth are starting to buck out. The mom says that she wishes he wouldn't need it all the time when he is home and is glad that I only give it to him at nap time.
2 people like this
@aidenofthetower (1814)
• United States
22 Oct 08
I must say that there are a lot of things to be considered. First of all, studies show that sucking a pacifier decreases the chances for SIDS. This can be a very good reason to give one at night. While it is true that babies cry for a reason, it is often because they want attention or comfort which is sometimes hard to provide for. A pacifier is a good solution some of the time. The trick is figuring out how to limit it. It is also a good idea to ween them from a pacifier early. Changing the shape of the jaw usually only happens to those who suck a pacifier with a mouthful of teeth, but if your baby doesn't take one by time he or she has a mouthful of teeth then there are fewer issues. On the other hand, the pacifier is much better then the thumb. It can really mess up teeth and jaws and is impossible to take away.
As for our son. He didn't take one. He just had no interest in it and that was that. I think this is a subject, as are many, that making an informed decision is most important and that you need to do what is best for you and your family.
2 people like this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
22 Oct 08
Hi there aidenofthetower
You make some very valid points and thank you for addressing them. Yes it would alter the childs jawline if the child has a mouthful of teeth and not prior to that, you're right. I am glad though I persevered and didn't give my sons one because I would hate to have to be the baddy to take it from them! My brother is now having this problem with his TWIN sons - double trouble.
Thanks for your response
1 person likes this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
22 Oct 08
Hi ya fourluvz and welcome to myLot
I have been in the situation before now, several times, that one of my babies has continuely cried despite going through all the possibilities of the cause of the distress and have still chosen to pace the floor continuely until he has stopped crying for whatever reason and still haven't given in to a pacifier.
1 person likes this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
22 Oct 08
Hi Humbug,
I sure did give them one all three of my kids and your very right in everything you have said which I found out to my own cost with my youngest son..I couldn't understand a word of what he spoke until he was 5 yrs old and the reason for this was because I'd given him a dummy, terrible and I went through a lot of guilt because I had given him this offending article, they really should come with a warning.
2 people like this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
22 Oct 08
Hi ya scorpio19
The thing is that when I was pregnant with all my kids not once, ever did a midwife or healthvisitor discuss the disadvantages of giving your baby a dummy!! Where are they with all that?
Thanks for your response
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
22 Oct 08
exactly Humbug..I had no intentions of ever giving my children dummies like I had every intention of not giving them chocolate, only healthy snacks now I'm not saying I constantly do give them what I know now to not be good but realistically when I had babies was a lot different than how I had thought it would be once I had actually got children and found the power of putting a dummy in their mouths when everything I'd done to soothe them had failed was a god send to me and not once was I ever told by professionals that they were damaging to their speech.
I took my son to see a speech therapist, now my son was very attached to his dummy he loved it but the day I was told it was the dummy that had caused the problem was the day my son never had a dummy, so yes where are the warnings there should be. Has we know becoming a parent does not make us experts on parenting, babies don't come with a manual we have to learn it as we go a long and not always did I get it right.
2 people like this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
23 Oct 08
I have never used a pacifier with my son…I dislike this practise for all the reasons stated by you alongwith the fear that it will of course distort his jawline and he may eventually have protruding teeth. Sometimes though some babies nag for no apparent reasons and moms do need a break and the pacifies comes in handy.
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
22 Oct 08
I had a dummy when I was a baby but I think I grew out of it after a few months. I used to give my son a dummy when he was a baby. But he did not like it much. It was used only for a few months and than grew out of it too. © ronaldinu 2008
2 people like this
@mummyofthree (2715)
•
7 Feb 09
My eldest had a dummy. It just seemed to be what every mother did so I didn't really think about it.
My middle lad refused anything apart from my boob in his mouth and solid food when he was a bit older until he was eleven months old!
My youngest found her thumb within minutes of being born so she never had one... although in some ways I wish I'd tried to get her on a dummy as She'll probably suck her thumb forever now!
It's different things for different kids! None of mine have been damaged by having things different.
I must say I do object to mothers that let their kids run around with dummys at the age of 4 and 5. That to me is not nice to see. But just my opinion
1 person likes this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi ya mummyofthree
Hahahaha you having fun checking out my discussions?
Anyway, at least if your daughter would have taken the dummy it would have been easier to take it away from her as you can't take her thumb away eh? lol I have got two friends who had daughters 3 weeks apart from each other and they both had a dummy. They both had awful trouble getting them to give them up. I think they were both near to starting school when they were eventually dummy free! I am glad I didn't have to got through all that with mine!
Thanks mummy
@bieke81 (1067)
• Belgium
22 Oct 08
No I did not, well, not for the oldest. He didn't even want it. The first few days, when I was still in hospital, he would want food every two hours which is too fast so the nurses would give him a pacifier, but as soon as they left the room I would take it out and comfort him (I also had a extra bottle in the room and milk so I could feed him if he was hungry, nurse or no nurse, I was a bad mommy ). I didn't want him to get used to it, if it wasn't necessary.
The second one did have a pacifier for three weeks, because he couldn't suck hard enough and he needed to 'practise' (can't find a better word). As soon as I felt that he could do without I stopped giving it and I never had a problem with it.
Have a nice day
@tanmay0312 (67)
• India
23 Oct 08
i would like to have baby when i grow up....but wen they cries....it can be annoying...but its d responsibility of parents to know the reason 4 y r they crying.....as we know hat wen we wer babies even our parents looked after us.....they didnt threw us.........
@pehpot (4762)
• Philippines
23 Oct 08
I already have three kids and no I have not given any one of them a pacifier, they say it has psychological impact on the baby and that if he is always on pacifier he will never learn how to soothe himself, and some kids become really dependent with it, as for thumb sucking it is natural and most of the kids out grew it, if you see them thumb suck and gave them pacifier them may get dependent to it and it will be hard for you to take it away
@lilcee (2703)
• United States
22 Oct 08
Hi Humbug. I never gave my kids a pacifier. I don't like to see kids walking around with them in their mouths. I used to work in a day care and some of them would come in with nasty looking pacifiers. They would get all sticky and yucky. Also, they can get lost or dropped. If the child is used to having one, then they would be upset if they lost it. My kids sucked their thumbs. That's probably not good either but they had it with them all the time and never lost it LOL. Take care and have a good lotting day.
2 people like this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
22 Oct 08
Hi there lilcee
That would be nightmare going around looking for pacifiers all day in a daycare centre!! I can't imagine how much money people spend on pacifiers throughout their babies pacifier sucking days throught the loss of them!
thanks for your response
1 person likes this
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
22 Oct 08
NEVER! im like you in that whole idea and sense of it. i've seen so much of this. i had 5 kids and not one had one.
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
23 Oct 08
Hi there bunnybon7
5 Kids and not one pacifier/dummy good going. I think even if I had, had 10 kids there wouldn't have been one in sight. Yes you need patience and a lot of it but it is worth it not to stick a pacifier/dummy in their mouths eh?
Thanks for your response
@hildas (3031)
•
22 Oct 08
My daughters, except my eldest had them (as she sucked her finger). I couldn't take it off her, and by sucking her index finger made her front teeth stick out. (fixed now). As for my other three children I was able to take them away from about 3 years of age. There teeth where all fine? I think it's a hard call.
@delmeg10 (112)
• United States
23 Oct 08
I tried to give my son a pacifier once and he didn't like it. I didn't mind though. I only offered it to him since it was given to me at my shower. I'm actually glad he didn't take it since I know it isn't good to get babies hooked on them. I can't stand to see 2 and 3 year olds that still use them. Besides, it does really mess up their mouth, teeth when they get older.
1 person likes this