Baby Can Read

@kaui_808 (191)
United States
October 30, 2008 4:54pm CST
I'm a new parent, my son just made 6mos. a few days ago. Like any parent I'm real interested in giving my son every opportunity possible. So recently, we purchased those infomercial DVD's and Books: "Baby Can Read". I never thought of myself as an infomercial sucker; but didn't I say I was a new mommy? Well, just yeaterday they finally arrived. I'm super excited about getting started. We've already started on some of the books this morning. I was just wondering if any of yo MyLotters out there have purchased this educational too? and how has it been going for you? It seems a little time consuming? How do you keep from getting burnt out? How do you keep diligent? And, what's your overall thought on the product? Can't wait to hear form you!
1 person likes this
2 responses
@susiejwp (47)
• United States
30 Oct 08
As an educator, parent, consumer and all around skeptic, I'm sorry to tell you this but I have a real problem with any product that promises to teach a child as young as the ones portrayed to read. Sure, you can teach children to respond to pictures with the correct words (and notice that pictures are on the cards with the words in most cases) but to think that a child as young as 2 (or in some cases younger) can read after this program is very hard to swallow. I tested a product somewhat like this one years ago (can't give the name due to a non-disclosure agreement) and it wasn't worth the shipping the company spent to send it. A lot of hype and little results. IF this were tested in a university setting, I might buy it but right now, my doubts are greater than my support of the program.
@kaui_808 (191)
• United States
30 Oct 08
I see your point and understand your skeptacism, especially because of your previous encounters. But my thought and understanding on the matter was that the early stages were just that: visual recognition. That it worked the same way as: mommy says 'ball', baby hears sound and associates it with the round bouncy things and picks it up. ie those squiggly things we call words written on the card that mommy holds up are associated with the sounds she makes. ....I do hope this is making any sense at all because I'm not a licensed educator or dr. Plus I've always found it a little hard to express myself on paper. Anyways do you think these tools could prove helpful later on? and if so, at what age? oh and I almost forgot, I believe this was a University PHd Professor who put this whole thing together. Off the top of my head I think it was Penn State, not sure. I'm also not sure if he did a hard core analytical study on the whole thing, I think he might have. I'll have to look into that a little more and get back to you. THANKS for your response, it's causing me to think and I love that!
• United States
31 Oct 08
Unfortunately, you did just become an infomercial sucker. First, there's nothing on those DVDs that's any different from what a normal parent does for and with their child. But it's a hot market, and plenty of people are making money from it, even university professors -- if he is what he claims. A lot of them are running under phony credentials. But the most important thing is that studies have shown that there are no real benefits from any of the programs that teach your child to read earlier, boost their IQ, and whatever other claims they make. The fact that the program is time consuming is a hint that it's not something that children would naturally make use of or that they need. How do you think millions of children managed to grow up into normal adults before these new techniques were developed? If there's anything on the discs that your child enjoys watching, it's fine as an amusement for very short periods of tiem. It's recommended that children not watch TV at such an early age because it actually interferes with normal development. By the way, first-time parents are the biggst customers of these scams because they're unsure of what they should be doing for their children.
@kaui_808 (191)
• United States
31 Oct 08
Yeah, I'm sure your right, the DVDs are probably no different from what any other parent does. And I dont doubt that we grow up perfectly fine without such tools. I mean i didn't buy them thinking I'd get a super genius out of it. I also thought about making cards flash cards myself and just buying a bunch of books to read to him. I figured I wouldn't have been as diligent to read to him and get him excited about reading without it. I have trouble motivating myself to read a book with all the things I have to get done in the day. Guess your right that there are other cheaper opttions but I guess I know myself and if this will help me to interact with him about educational stuff the money waswell spent...it was either that or a new outfit! Thanx for your response