is it ok for the parents to read their child or children diary or journal?
By annjilena
@annjilena (5618)
United States
November 1, 2008 1:02am CST
we know our kids don,t tell us everything they tell there friends before they tell you.but is it permissible to snoop if you feel your cild arechildren are in trouble.if you suspect they are using drugs,stealing.if you suspect they,re depressed or sexually active.they say you should repect your child privacy in same way that that you want them to respect your thing.when is ok to invade your child or children privacy.it,s your house shouldn,t you know what goes on in your house.
3 people like this
14 responses
@Grandmaof2 (7579)
• Canada
2 Nov 08
In my opinion our children should be at the top of our priorities. If it meant that I suspected a problem, I'd much rather be quilty of reading my childs diary than see my child hit disaster. It doesn't matter to me whos house I'm in, I would do wherever and whatever it takes to save my child from something I could have control in. This is just Grandmaof2 talking. Take care.
2 people like this
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
you are right grandma,we have do whatever we can to keep our love one on the right track as you said you will respect your child to a point if you see a problem you going to step in and deal with it and this is what i would do when kids are in your house are whoever house parent should have there limits to privacy to protect your child if need be.thank so much for sharing
@maroseqf (3657)
• Philippines
1 Nov 08
i believe that everyone of us are entitled to our own privacy. even our children sometimes ask for it. well, i think parents should not read their children's diary or journal especially without their children's knowledge and permission. i think the things written on it are too personal and is none of anyone else's business.
i think parents should teach their children to respect privacy and so they must start it on themselves.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
4 Nov 08
Hmmmmm well ya gave them the advice thats about al ya can do.
But I asked my daughter was it right to read a kids diary adn she blew a casket and she is 43 now.
No way do you go in and read it.
If you think they are lieing to you I guess you will hav eto keep a eye on them more and close to home! Where ya can make sure they are in BEFORE dark oh I know they can do things in the daytime to ! you will just hav eto keep them closer to you .
I knew where my kids were all the time if I couldnt see them I would holler at them till they got in my site!
I was very strict. On my last 2 and I think that was for my first 3 got taken from my babysitter while I was working by thioer fathter and then he took them back to our state and put them up for adoption! my last 2 I kept very very close!
Took me 27 yearsto find my 3 boys!
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
1 Dec 08
yup I am very glad to have found them. my 2nd son now lives here in Vegas so we do get to spend holidays together and some other visits too . His work hours now are just about as bad when he was in the Sevice but at lest he is home and not going to be deployed any more
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
30 Nov 08
oh wow 27 years to find your children i know this bothered you not knowing was they safe and was they ok iam glad at least you found them thats wonderful thank you for sharing
@msmargo (361)
• United States
30 Nov 08
That's a good question annjilena. Reminds me that I made a good decision when I decided not to have kids. I think if your child is having the problems that you listed, and the child is forthcoming to the parent, I believe the parent has the write to read a diary. My sister did this when her 12 year old daughter began having problems in school and at home. Her sweet, out going, achieving child began to become withdrawn, hate school and socializing with friends. She was having thoughts of killing herself. She was cutting herself. Ultimately her daughter was diagnosed as being bipolar. She has been in and out of hospitals, special schools, on numerous medications, seen many doctors, and gone through many different treatments. My sister's reading of the diary early on, out of desparation, enabled her to get a grip on the type of problem her daughter was having. At age 16 now, my niece is showing signs of improvement, and just this year began going to a normal high school.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
30 Nov 08
this is wonderful news she readthe diary to see what was going on with her child and she found a way to help her child thats great thank you for sharing
@eddie42 (270)
• United States
3 Nov 08
i believe every parent should know whats going on in their house esppecially if their child is changing because kids don,t tell their parents everything if you want to know then you have to keep our eyes open so we can know whats happening even reading the diarary or journal.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
30 Nov 08
I wouldn't do it just because I was curious about their life but if I suspected there was a dangerous issue going on...I'd be in there with a magnifying glass reading every word! I'd read it backwards if I thought there was anything to it..lol I think that as parents we have a responsibility to keep our children safe and it may call for extreme measures from time to time.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
30 Nov 08
well my friend son was talking about killing himself and his parents it was all written down in his diary.he would never tell anyone what he was really thinking.as a parent i would do what i have to read their diary whatever to protect him and others simply inoring the problem its, not going to go away.this is my house the child don,t pay any bill for a parent to simple say they didn,t know is not good enough when your child is getting in trouble.thank you for sharing happy mylotting
@lira23 (208)
• United States
2 Nov 08
I don't think that a parent should read their child's diary or journal unless you suspect something, even then its invasion of privacy. In mine though I'm near mid twenties I write about people such as my mother etc who I still live with.My own mom read my diary and used stuff in there against me,and I think thats wrong,to this day we don't talk really or get along so just be careful.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
lira, life is to short for you not to be talking to your mother she loves you if you was in trouble would you not want your mother to know how to help you.what i see here lira is you are of age but if you want privicy you need your own place thats moms house she have right to know whats going on in her house because she is a parent this is what parents do try to protect their chilldren don,t not talk to your mom because of this remember she loves you very much.life is a blink of an eye don,t waste it.thank you for sharing lira
@mercuryman3a (2477)
• India
2 Nov 08
You should respect your child's pivacy alright but I think reading your child's diary is not in essence an invasion of his privacy. Yes if yu start reqactign to everything your child has written in teh diary and confront yor child with it then it is an invasion of his privacy. REad te diary but reserve yor judgement. Find other means to rectify the child's participation in wrong activities without letting the child know that you have read teh diary. If teh child knows that you have read teh diary, he will stop trusting you. Do not let that happen.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
this is my house my son reside here as long he is in my house i will know whats going on it was he who broke the trust when he was sneeking out the window at night.iam thinking he is in bed he out partying on school nights.i read his diary and i will read it again if i feel he is getting into trouble doing things he have no business.i was in and out family court. i had no choice he was hiding everthing.but thank you for sharing this information i will remember what you said.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
not this day and age parents need to know whats going on in her house especially know what your child is doing.the court rooms of full of children these days because parents give to much freedom.thank you for sharing
@iamfine (740)
• China
2 Nov 08
When I was a child, I had such an argue with my parents for their reading my diary without permission. I made me feel like they don't trust me, and my secret expose to every one.
Every body wants to keep some secret, they don't want even their best friends to know their true feeling inside their heart. We need to respect their little world.
but some case are exception, like if you find your child becomes bad, so have wierd behaviour, go read his diary is a good way to know what's going one, and think a way to solove such situation .
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
i too keep a diary and when my son decide to keep a diary it was kool but when he started acting out i asked what was wrong he would always say nothing i knew something was bothering him ,what it was they was picking at him and school because he was petite in size and he is very femine and he is so handsome to be a boy but low and behold he never felt like a boy he said he feels like he is a girl this wasn,t a shock to me i been knew but he wouldn,t talk about it until one day i had talk with him about how he feels.after that he have been find.
@icedcoffeemallows (649)
• Philippines
2 Nov 08
I think privacy is really a matter concerning a lot of teenagers nowadays. I believe that good parent-child relationship is the key. There must be a strong bonding, caring, loving relationship that is developed within the family so that the child will not have a difficulty to open-up and share whatever feelings/things concerns him. Family is the basic unit of the society so trust and respect must start at home.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
yes it does but when your child start hanging around with the crowd and picking up there disrespectful ways you will see a different in your child bad association spoils youthful habits.if they have a secert and don,t want you know they will shut you out to keep that secert.
@nankai627 (3)
• China
3 Nov 08
But some children are shy.They do not know how to express themselves.Talks might be uneffective.Then parents should understand them by other meaninigs such as Reading diaries .however,parents must not read diary untill they be allowed by their children.parents should respect kids.
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
what if their secert is so deep they feel their parents will not understand how they feel.so they start acting out in other ways.thanks
@nankai627 (3)
• China
2 Nov 08
That depends!Iam a girl .I tell every thing to my mother,and simetimes I also communicate with my father .Therefore I nearly have no secret.My parents read my notes sevral times.I do not think they invade me.My parents only have one child.That isI!They love me and want to protect me from danger.However,parents should communicate with child rather than read their notes.Communication can express your affection.What you read your children diary might deteriate your relation.They do not consider your behavior as affection.On the contray,they think you want to find their secret .In a word,if you want to understand your kids,communicate with them .
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
what if their secert is so deep they feel their parents will not understand how they feel.so they start acting out in other ways.thanks
@wujinbo (341)
• China
2 Nov 08
as we all know that all childens have their privacy,so their parents should respect their childens privacy.but sometimes parents make some suspection about their childens unusual actions,they should spare time to talk to their childens and know about what they are doing,and why they do like that.and parents and childens are good relationships,or they both will break up their relationships ,making the families look so bad and cant have a good time.....
@annjilena (5618)
• United States
4 Nov 08
if you trust your child and your child break the trust you have in them you will start wondering whats going on with them and why are they acting this way.we love our kids and want the best for them but even parents can only do so much when their child shut them out and turn to their friends thinking they care more then the parents.thank you for sharing.