After divorce, who should take the kids??

@loxion (1553)
India
November 17, 2008 8:02am CST
There could be some situations where parents need to be separated due to some serious misunderstanding between parents, and in situations like this the children are somehow the one's who suffer the most First they have to deal with the fact that they must live with either a single parent or separated from the other half of their blood due to maybe the attorneys involved and deciding that a certain partner take the others and vice versa And now they have to cope with the fact that their parents might hate each other and they might not know who is right and who is wrong or completely not knowing what happened to their parents for them to go their separate ways. What would you do if you meet with difficult situation like this?
6 people like this
21 responses
@ghazal2k5 (920)
• India
18 Nov 08
Well i dont have any experience of marriage or divorce but i will still express my thoughts here. I believe there should be no divorce at first hand. Its not good for the kids mental health and future. But if they do have to separate then the kid should be one to decide with whom he wants to stay. And the parents should still be friends after divorce to help raise the kid.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I think to let the kids decide will even cause more frustration to the situation itself, i mean at first the kids doesn't want their parents to separate and they love both parents but yet we ask them which parent they want to go with. I think at the end the kids might end up not knowing who to decide on. I also think that asking them will also create some hatred on the other parent which they decided against, because they might hate the other parent which is bad
• Pakistan
18 Nov 08
I would say the kids should live with their mother, provided that she is a working mother and earns enough to raise her kids. The reason I say this is that mothers are more affectionate by nature, something that comes in handy when it comes to raising kids (Fathers over there: do not throw comment daggers on me, you know what I mean).
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
Hello ProlificDude, i don't think there could be anyone attacking you here...good point you raised there, i also think that mother's have something special when it comes to caring But also i think that situation like that will create confusion to the kids because they might think that their father isn't good enough to take care of them and may think that he is a bad person or blame the situation on him, they can also create a hatred towards their father
@Nhey16 (2518)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
that would be hard for each of the person involved... but i guess each parent has a right to be with the kids.... but as a mom, i would want my kids to be with me, though their dad would always be welcome to hang out with them.... i just hope, this wouldn't happen to us... :)
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I also think that the mother's has that special caring ability, but do you think that the kids will still behave the same way as it was the case before? meaning...don't you think that they may hate their dad? because they might think that this person was incapable from the beginning and blame the whole thing on him? I think for minors situation like this will create bad image on the partner, in this case the father, because they might think he doesn't love them
@Nhey16 (2518)
• Philippines
19 Nov 08
the kids may hate their dad if the situation is not well explained to them... but i guess, the kids have the right to know what happened, so the parents should explain well to the kids everything, so as not to give any negative impact to whoever and whatsoever... :)
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
That is really a very difficult situation to be in. And what is worse in this situation is that it is the children who suffer the most from this separation that happen. They become lost and disillusioned and many children do suffer heavily from this. When parents are separated legally I guess its the mother who has the rights to the children unless otherwise the father has valid reasons that he wants to take custody of the children.
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
19 Nov 08
Legally speaking by default it is the mother who has the right for the custody of the child. Maybe the law recognizes that biologically speaking mothers are best in rearing for the child's best welfare. But if the father could provide for a proof for the mother's inability then the law may recognize the father to be the custodian of their children.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
But don't you think that will create a bad image on the father? i mean if the kids are taken by the mother for care...they might also think or have that mentality that their father wasn't good enough to care for them and that the reason why they end up with their mother? They might also blame the whole thing that happened on him and think that he was bad, and they might also be confused on how they will approach life with a single parent
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
18 Nov 08
Work it out in such a way that the children were affected as little as possible. In my case it would probably mean that the kids were with me on weekdays and that we would stay in the same area so that they don't have to change schools.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
18 Nov 08
I think your responsibility as a parent is to put the children first. So if the situation is that the other parent is a danger to the children or to you, clearly that is more important that the fact that the children are going to know something is wrong. On the other hand, if you don't want to see the person mainly because it is painful, I think the children's right to have a relationship with both parents is more important. If necessary you can always arrange for a third part to do drop offs and pick ups so that you don't have to see the other person. Plus, at least here in the US, the courts have a say so and if they say that both parents have equal custody or one parent has custody but the other has visitation, you are obligated to follow the courts ruling.
1 person likes this
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
But one thing that will always be there is the fact that the kids will finally realise that something is wrong between the two of you and it will get to them and obviously be affected by that. Staying in the same area also could lighten things down but what if is the situation where you don't want to see your former partner again, and all you need is a distance away from them and forget about everything? I think situations like this will at the end make the kids to somehow hate or cause hatred on the other partner, meaning if they are taken to your care...then they will feel like their other parent wasn't that good and maybe that's the reason you left them.
1 person likes this
@ch88ss (2271)
• United States
18 Nov 08
This is the very reason why I have hung on. We have our problems and have not yet separated because we are still trying to figure out what is best for the kids. Since I attend to all the kids needs, my husband has mention I keep the kids, but he has refused child support because he thinks it is my fault that I want out.
@ch88ss (2271)
• United States
25 Nov 08
That is a bit complicated if both parents wants the kid. If they could live under the same roof and behave in a civilized way, then they can both enjoy the kids. (just a thought) If not, it will get ugly and they may have to go to court. but if one of the parent can show that they can provide after school care with other family members such as grand parents, the court will usually favor that parent. Because a child with a stranger is not as a good as child with a family member.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I think that situation in somehow is not that difficult to deal with and the only difficult part of it is the child support side. But what if in situations where both parents wants to keep the kids, and they are both capable of caring for them, both financially and showing love for them. I think the kids will feel like lost, something wrong which they are doing and somehow feeling as if is their fault that their parents are separated.
@mods196621 (3652)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
If i am in that situation I prefer to get my children with me. And I will get their father's financial support. I refer it first to my attorney if I have the right to take the custody of my kids as well as the father's financial support. Before hand I think it over and I have planned already if this was happen. But I pray to God not to happen. Oh my, i'm being sad.
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
Yes, but trying to explain very well to the kids. Unlike they will see the misery inside the house and it will be more painful to them. As mother I will be responsible for them and trying to do my best to give them their needs. And the very first thing is pray hard to God.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
But don't think that will... sort of create a bad image for your kids towards their father? i mean they might think that he is incapable or maybe he doesn't love them and that's the reason why they end up with you as their mother? And again it will cause confusion on them when they will be thinking about where their future and where their life is going, and that could stress them. I think that's difficult situation no one wants to find themselves in, but yet they happen
@Ithink (9980)
• United States
17 Nov 08
It really depends on the situation as to if the children suffer and all situations are different. However in the most cases the children are left wondering what is happening to their world and why? As in the case of who gets the kids, alot of factors come into play. The best parent is normally the ones that the courts have the children full time, however the other parent almost always gets alot of visitation time unless they had abused the child or something. I dont believe it should just go to the one that is able to better care the child/children money wise either. The ones that I have heard of goes to the most caring, loving, stable person.
@loxion (1553)
• India
17 Nov 08
I think in situation where both parents are both caring people and can best take care of the kids...it will be difficult and confusing for the kids, like you said the situation will leave the kids wondering about their future, where they are heading to, how tell will handle this situation And if the kids are left to make decision, it will always create the so called hatred between them and the parent they do not choose. I think situation like this is always difficult for everyone
@Ithink (9980)
• United States
17 Nov 08
Thinking about this, yes there is discord in their lives but if nothing else most kids are really able to bounce back. Some go back and forth from parent to parent without a problem. I think those are the ones that the parents work on it and reamins at least in communication if not friends. Divorce is so common nowdays that it is sad but each relationship is unique between the adults and the kids. I think the aftermath is what the adults make it. Also kids dont normally have a say in who they go with until they are older, when younger a judge decides.
• United States
18 Nov 08
I am the child of a divorced couple. I have also been divorced. It is a hard situation for the kids. My parents didn't try to get along for the sake of the kids at all. They were too involved in their own anger to see how it was affecting us. I try very hard to get along with my ex. There isn't any reason for my kids to suffer from him and I not being able to get along. He and I are no longer together. The reasons to hate and bicker and fight are no longer there. They resulted from us being together. My ex may not see it all the same way I do, in fact, I know he doesn't. He doesn't mind arguing with me, and letting the kids know of his distaste for me. I try to keep it civil at least. As far as where the kids should live, that should be determined by the parents. A lot of things should be taken in to consideration. It is a hard situation for everyone. Unfortunately, it happens a lot. I think it is best to learn from the mistakes of our parents and take it from there.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
Sorry that you had to face difficult situation like this and i believe that it was very hard for all you and challenging when you thought about the fact that you now have to deal with the situation where you will have to be in a care of a single parent. And like you said...this happens all the time and is difficult for both parties involved
@anneshirley (1516)
• Philippines
17 Nov 08
I do agree with you that kids are the one whose sufferings from a broken family. It has a long term effect on them psychologically and socially. If parents got divorced, I think it is best to let the child choose on whom he/she wants to be with and if a child can't choose between the two, give the child to the one who is more responsible and willing to devote more time. Children from broken families need all the love and attention they can get and if they won't be able to provide it, surely the child will go astray.
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
NO one can terminate your marriage execpt you! the couple itself. You are the one WHO made the dissicion not the court. no one can force you to terminate the marriage if you both dont like to terminate it, if you want to save your marriage unless you are not capable to be a parents of your kids. AS LONG AS YOU CAN SAVE YOUR MARRIAGE FOR YOUR KIDS.
@loxion (1553)
• India
17 Nov 08
I think letting the kids choose who they want to go with...will even add stress to the way the situation because the kids do love both parents and they do not want to see them separating and yet they must due to certain circumstances. I think it would be very difficult for the kids and they might endup making wrong decisions or totally not knowing who to go with. I think even in situation where both mother and father are responsible people and can take good care of them, it will eve make things difficult for the kids
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
Divorce? I wish that will never happen to me? I'm glad I've been enjoying a happy marriage for the last 23 years and by God's grace this is gonna be for life! It's the children more than anyone else whose going to suffer so I really am anti-divorce. However, if irreconcilable, and divorce is the only option left then I believe the parents should for the sake of their children make peace and be friends once and for all. I believe the mother (if capable both phyically and mentally) should take the children expecialy if they are still at very early age. Only a mother can give the love and care children need. Now if the children are old enough, I believe they should be given the choice where would they wanna stay with.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
A very difficult situation indeed, because i've seen lot of situations like this happen and like you said the mother are always the one's who are prefered to look after the kids. But in situations i've already seen is like it create a (hatred) between the kids and the other parent who isn't in their care. Is like the kids says...you are not good enough to look after and that's the reason why we are left to the care of our mother. And thing like this could even remain on the kids for even years to come, and what would they see everytime they think about you the other parent...? they will always feel like you where never there for them whereas is the situation between you and your partner that created all this mess. I think it might be difficult for the two partners but for the kids is even worse
@maroseqf (3657)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
I am not a pro-divorce person. I really think that relationships should be saved in order to raise your children better. I think the kids suffer the most in this situation. They get bothered by the relationship of their parents and may affect them in different ways. Married people should be more responsible and committed to the relationship. They decided to get marry and so they must be fully aware of what it entails. Marriage is a vow that should be kept.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I agree with you Maroseqf, the last everybody want to see is people separated, but things like this do happen and like you said the kids will be confused as to where their life and future is heading, and i think i will be difficult for the kids to deal with situations like those, especially when it comes to the point where they have to choose who should care for them because they do love both parents.
@Yori88 (1465)
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
If I were in a situation where my parents need to go their separate ways then I would go to the one whom I'm closer with, that's my mom. Every child of the right age should have the right to choose whom they want to be with and go with. But in case children are still minor, then lawyers should be the ones to decide on the matter. Children right of choice should not be impaired or hindered.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I agree with you when you say when children are bit older then they can decide on their own where they want to go. But making decisions for minors can cause even confusion when they grow up, because they will that their father was never there for them and he wasn't capable or either needed to care about them. and they can end up hating their father, and blaming what happened on him.
@pzygtt (193)
• China
18 Nov 08
When a man is not living up to his responsibilities as a man,when such separation occurs it would be better for the woman to care for the children because most marriages break down as a result of inadequate provision for the family by the man.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I don't think only the man should always be blamed when something wrong is happening in the family, what if the woman is irresponsible, would you still blame termination of marriage on a man?
• Philippines
18 Nov 08
It's so sa d tho think of divorce specially when the kids are just young to understand everything that happens to their parents.They are the ones who suffered the most and parents don't care how they feel. Well for me i think that kids under 7 years oof age should always have the mothers custody and for age above that it's for the child to choose whether he/she wants to stay with.And as for the parents always make sure that you don't talk ill about your ex's with your children, always remain civil to each other so that children s respect for their parents is always there.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
I also think that talking bad about your former or the father of your kids will even cause confusion to the kids, but you do not know what's happening behind closed doors with other people, maybe someone is talking bad about their former partner and that will always create bad image on the father. The kids will always think that their father was a bad person and that's the reason why they are taken by their mother for care. I think the whole situation will be difficult for everyone involved
@adapots (82)
• Philippines
17 Nov 08
hope all the couples knows how to handle if ever they are in the difficult situation coz it is normal to the couple to have an argument or to have a problem in the family but they need to consider the affect of it,espicially the children and hope they find a away that they must stay together and find their heart that their still a love in their heart. I WILL save my marriage for my children and husband and wife must talk about it and most espicially i will go back when the time of our courtship or the time that we are happy together what is our vows. where did we meet what is the thing we did. all the happiest moment to refresh our mind that their is love that bind us.
@loxion (1553)
• India
17 Nov 08
Yes that could and should always help, but what if the court or any other way that force the termination of marriage and each should go their ways? It will always be difficult to deal with situations like those, especially with the kids not knowing which one to choose because they love both of you and separating is the last thing they want to see.
@12148621 (15)
• Philippines
17 Nov 08
hello im single,, but i've encounter here in our province that mostly mother will take the kids..
@loxion (1553)
• India
17 Nov 08
Yes, i also think most kids would choose to go with the mother rather than daddy, simply because mothers can take good care of them and they are not that hush as compared to fathers.
@Zezloler (497)
• United Arab Emirates
17 Nov 08
I agree, divorce is a difficult situation for kids. They usually find themselves as victims of the seperation, and some may think that it's their fault their parents don't like each other anymore, but of course this isn't true. Kids have to deal with the additional pressure of living with only one parent if their parents stop living together, and may have limits on the amount of time they could spend with their mum or dad during a week. The one who should take the kids should be the more reponsible parent and the one who's able to provide a better living for the child. You can't make a generalization on this, because in some cases, the father is more responsible, and in others, the mother is. Sometimes both the mother and the father will have to share custody of the child. If you're asking how I would react in such a situation, I honestly don't know. =S Divorce isn't a good thing, but in some cases, marriges simply can't work out.
@loxion (1553)
• India
17 Nov 08
I think that's difficult to deal with and like you said the kids are the one's suffering from what could happened, but from what i've see so far is the fact that the mother turn to have the preference in situations like this And again asking the kids who they want to go with will even add more stress to them, i think the whole thing would be difficult both parties involved
• United States
18 Nov 08
I think it seriously depends on the parents themselves and the individual situation. My ex and I were never married, but we did break up after having a child together. I took our daughter because he's irresponsible. He fought me in court over it, but then ended up dropping off the face of the earth for over 4 months. But I also know some fathers who are much better parents then the mothers are. Most of the time the mother will win out in court though.
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
Yes, i also believe that in most cases the mother's are the one's who win the caring of the kids, but i also think that it create a bad image on the father because the kids will think and believe that their father was never a good parent at all, how come we are all taken to our mother to look after us. I think divorce is just a bad thing totally, because not only the kids have to deal with the situation of living with a single parent, but also the way their life will be after all has happened, the way they will approach their life from now on.
• India
17 Nov 08
beauty - this the real beauty in right manner...she is too pretty,cool,gorgeous....
kewl divorce is really a bad condition for both husband and wife...as well as their childrens...this situation ruins the whole life of both hubby and his wife....in my views after this situation kids should be kept by one who love them very much without any intension ....so that the care of kids will be best...and this will safe the childhood of the kids...
@loxion (1553)
• India
18 Nov 08
But i think is just a difficult situation in any form...what if in this case both parents have that ability to care and look after the kids?. I think the kids will somehow feel as though there is something wrong with the way they live and will always have this thinkings in their minds that... where will their life after everything, how should they handle situation like this. And they will as though their life is somehow heading to nowhere
@joystick7 (728)
• India
3 Dec 08
Extremely worse thing to happen to a child.. The person who can give the child a better life should take care of the child.. In most cases the mother can take care of the child better but if the mother cannot manage the expense of the child's education and so on then may be it might be a better option to hand the child to the father..