sharing ideas online

United States
November 22, 2008 10:34pm CST
There are a multitude of sites online that claim to be communities for writers - Edit Red.com, Writing.com, for example - and for the most part the people who join these communities are honest people. But do you ever worry about posting story ideas online? On a "writing community" site or your blog or even here on MyLot? Not only are you putting your idea out into the world leaving it open for criticism but it's also out where anyone could steal it. I don't know about all around the world, but here in the US, all writing or artwork is automatically copyrighted once it's created, except for ideas. If I come on here and say I have an idea for a story about the history of a haunted town, that sentence is copyrighted (technically) but the idea itself is still up for grabs. Does anyone ever worry about having their ideas stolen if they post them online?
2 people like this
5 responses
@neededhope (1085)
• United States
23 Nov 08
Honestly, I'm not worried about my content being stolen. If someone really is that desperate to make some money so they have to steal "ideas" so be it. Don't get me wrong I would be upset but the way I'm looking at it is just like if someone stole something else. Like a apple from the grocery store. Or a purse out of your car. There must be a reason and that they are desperate. And maybe they need it more than we do. And I"m not condoning stealing either thought. Let me make sure I get that across. But i believe in a higher power and people who do things that they shouldn't will be judged than. And I also feel everything happens for a reason. And so if something does get stolen I'm sure there must be a higher purpose that we just do not know about. And I did not know that about the us and I live here. I know it is copyrighted if you but a c with a circle around it and the year. But not if you just put an idea out or a exact sentence. Thanks for the info.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Nov 08
I don't know how it works, as far as enforcing it, but I did learn about a simple way of protecting your copyright that is admissible in court. Just print all of your drafts of whatever it is you want to protect, stick it in a legal sized envelope, sign and date the seal, and mail it to yourself through certified mail. Then leave it sealed until you need to open it. That way if someone does steal something (like, heaven forbid, you send it to an editor who rejects it then publishes it as their own - it's not common but it does happen) you have certified, dated proof that you wrote it first. :)
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Nov 08
I think it depends on what you have written about. If it's something that has a unique idea behind it, then I wouldn't post it online. Many people use the internet to get ideas or research projects that they are working on.
• United States
24 Nov 08
They say there are no new ideas, so even if someone steals your idea, that doesn't mean they're necessarily going to use it the same way you would. Of course, if you're very specific, then you may be giving too much away. As for sharing on community sites, I don't do it. I'm at the point where I can probably sell anything I write, and I'm not going to risk having it stolen. Copyright law doesn't mean much on the web because most of the time, you don't even know your material has been stolen. And unless you do know and can prove it's yours, there's not much you can do about it. Also, you need to think about future publishing. If you want to sell your work to a publisher, they may want first rights, and if you've published it anywhere on the web, they will refuse it. Even som online publishers make that demand and are that strict about it. If you're a beginning writer, you don't need to worry about these issues so much because it's unlikely you're going to be able to compete with professional writers anyway.
• United States
25 Nov 08
My elitest a**hole of a creative writing professor said that there are only seven individual plots. What separates writers from great writers is what they are able to create using any one of those seven plots. *shrug*
• United States
23 Nov 08
People do tend to take people's ideas online. I guess it's easier to do online, than in the real world, because it won't be as easy to catch online maybe?
1 person likes this
@sooz48 (34)
28 Nov 08
I write quite a lot online and I don't know if any of my work has ever been plagiarised. If it has, I haven't found out about it yet. I wouldn't be happy if any of my work were stolen, but that is a risk you take when you put your work online. Anything I really wouldn't want stolen, I don't put online. As for ideas, if a group of people were all given the same theme or title to write to, they would all produce very different work, so I don't think that is really a problem.