Why earn an education when you can buy a degree for $4000?

@bayernfan (1430)
Canada
December 8, 2008 4:18pm CST
A foreign student, who came to Canada on a student visa, had his official document counterfeit ring exposed by a reporter for the Toronto Star recently: http://www.thestar.com/article/549772 Peng Sun, has been offering high quality fake Bachelor's degrees with transcripts indistinguishable from the real ones, even for York University Registrar Joanne Duklas, for $4000. Master's and PHD degrees were offered for the same $4000 rate because they cost the same amount to make as the Bachelor's degree. Are there any other University or College grads here upset that there are liars, posing as grads, gaining employment over those who went to the trouble to actually earn a degree? Is anyone else upset that some people are devaluing documents that required hard work, sacrifice and lots of money to attain? Is counterfeiting not a terrible threat to the credibility of North American Colleges and Universities as well as all grads? Can we trust that Doctor, Engineer or Pharmacist? Are North American Colleges and Universities partly to blame for exposing all of us to this threat because they spend an increasing amount of time chasing foreign students and their larger tuition contributions? [b][i]The bogus-degree market is a billion-dollar industry, authorities say, with hundreds of Internet sites pumping out an estimated200,000 fake diplomas a year around the globe. Fake degrees pose a security risk in the hands of potential terrorists, who might use them to gain entry into North America or advance into sensitive jobs. Two of the terrorists involved in the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks entered the United States on student visas. "The dangers posed by a diploma mill are real," says University of Illinois Professor George Gollin, who has studied the problem for years. "It is bad enough that persons using fake degrees obtain undeserved status or swindle unwitting victims, but there is a real danger when phony physicians treat the sick,untrained engineers design bridges or teachers with purchased credentials instruct our children."[/i][/b] These counterfeit operations and their patrons are posing a risk to national security. This isn't just an issue of certain people making money from others who want to cut corners by avoiding the real work and the true expenses of post-secondary education. Individuals and society as a whole can be directly affected by these counterfeit rings.
1 person likes this
9 responses
@Savvynlady (3684)
• United States
9 Dec 08
What I'd like to know is that when you do get a job in that certain feel, then can you do what your supposed to do? see, that kind of thing isn't right to me no matter what you say. If you want something in life, seems to me, your best bet is go out there, go to college, study for that job and get that paper which will be hard and well earned. That's just too dang much.
• United States
9 Dec 08
excuse me, Field.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
Not all jobs require the use of extensive knowledge or specific skills right away. Sometimes there is a probationary or training period to start with. Perhaps it is an entry-level position that they are applying for and extensive training will be provided. Some people who try this may only want/need to stick around long enough, before becoming fired for incompetence, until the find the next unsuspecting victim. Perhaps the idea is to do as much damage as you possibly can for as long as you can get away with it.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
Don't misunderstand me, of course it isn't right for someone to fraudulently represent themselves in order to gain employment. Unfortunately, I think this practice is becoming more and more rampant. I can't understand why the company that you worked for didn't do the required background check before they hired him in the first place. It is always easier and less costly to prevent mistakes, then to try and deal with problems after they occur. A former Liberal member of Canada's federal parliament was caught lying about his credentials. Check out Jag Bhaduria at Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jag_Bhaduria He was caught lying about his education and credentials. This was after it was discovered that he cheated in his Liberal Party nomination election by signing up people ineligible to vote, people listed with unknown addresses, people who didn't pay for party memberships and people who were unaware that they were party members. Canada's Federal Parliament doesn't even have a process to recall members for any reason let alone fraud. Talk about a disaster waiting to happen. By its own actions, the Canadian government shows time after time that it isn't serious about addressing problems with fraud. What does it take for these so called officials to take fraud seriously. It's not just degrees that are for sale. I hear that the Governor of Illinois, Rod Blagojevich, was looking to sell the Senate seat previously held by Barack Obama.
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
8 Dec 08
$4000? that's a lot of money. Indeed it would be the fastest shortcut to earn a degree and I would be tempted to do the same if I got so much money in my pocket. Since the education I got from the school is actually not better than the skill I got in the real life. Well, to share some information, you could buy the bachelor degree with only $500, so if you want to get a cheaper degree you could just request for the degree from the international college, and that would be prestigeous enough for you to get a job. That's the society sickness, they tend to believe to the degree more than the skill.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
9 Dec 08
$4000 is less than tuition for one semester at many Universities in North America for citizens. Tuition for foreign students is considerably higher. Of course you can get counterfeit degrees for less money, but the forged degrees that Peng Sun was creating were so good that the registrar of a University and an expert in high-tech crime were unable to tell the difference between the real document and the fake document. "I've never seen quality like this,"Det. Mathew Ma, an expert on high-techcrime, told reporters. "I can't tell the difference between the false and the originals." I don't know where you come from but, in Canada, a degree alone won't get you the job. Good luck even trying to get an interview let alone being hired with an international degree that doesn't come from a trusted Western Nation here in Canada. Unfortunately, now it looks like documents from our own educational institutions may become suspect. There have been known cases of foreigners posing as doctors and performing surgery and cosmetic surgery on patients here in Canada. This type of fraud doesn't come victimless. I am surprised that you would openly admit to a willingness to engage in fraud. It is a serious crime in Canada to knowingly use a forged document to gain employment: "But passing off a fake degree as an original in a job application would amount to the offence of uttering a forged document. It could be as serious as using a counterfeit bill." Unfortunately, governments' and business' rush for cheap foreign labor puts the credibility of our institutions in question and the lives of our citizenry at risk.
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Dec 08
Indeed, it would do harm when people use the fake degree to take a job. But small companies seems don't care that much because these guys agreed to be paid lower than the average rate of the bachleor employees. And small companies don't really care to call the universities and make a cross check about the guy who are going to work at their place. At least that's what happened in Indonesia for now.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
Wow! klaudine, your comments about small business in Indonesia are news to me. I will have to plead ignorance as I have never visited Indonesia and I am not well versed in business practices there. I do wonder though, why bother to go through with the formalities if small business isn't really concerned with hiring actual graduates? This attitude seems quite reckless to me. If you hire an employee who is willing to lie right from the start of their new working relationship with anyone, how could you possibly trust anything coming from them later? If they conduct themselves fraudulently while searching for work, why not continue with that conduct when employed?
@kunking (1118)
• China
9 Dec 08
hi, bayernfan! i'm surprised to know this kind of cases could also happen in Canada..sorry to see that guy Peng Sun may probably be Chinese..u know, this problem has bothered us for many years in China and even nowadays u can easily get a counterfeit credential of either Bachelor, Master or PHD's degree..the fake one looks all the same with a real one that even some experts can't tell differences between them unless a very carefully checking.. i don't know why this scams could be in Canada since u've said only a college credential won't means a good job.. but here in China, perhaps its true to some extend..actually it may not promise u will certainly get that job, u are more probably not to have a chance for a job interview without a college credential...i have a high schoolmate who got his first job with a fake degree and now i got a similar one with the cost of high tutions and 7 years time to gain my master's degree..it that fair to me? i have to admit my friend is capable of that job very much with many year's experience..i mean there is no need for him to buy a fake degree if the companies don't focus on the candidate's education qualification.. terrorists will gain access to western countries using a fake degree...i think actions should be taken by Gov. as soon as possible to prevent the nation being at risk...
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
Peng Sun is a Chinese national. I am glad that the Toronto Star brought this incident to my attention, but this particular case shows that Canada, our educational institutions and our graduates aren't the only ones who are being hurt. Many of the people buying these forged degrees are going back to their home countries, in this case China was mentioned, and defrauding government and business there. There is a lot of Infrastructure being built in China at the moment. How would you feel about some fake grad working as an engineer on bridge, road, high-rise building or nuclear power plant construction? Do you really want a fake doctor or surgeon in charge of your family's health? Many professional careers cannot be entered into without a degree in that field. If your friend has many years of experience, then he must already be doing the job and he doesn't need the degree for proof. Some companies still request a degree, because they require proof of knowledge of certain standards and practices. I would really like to know what measures my government is taking to address the danger of document fraud. Do they really know who it is that they let into the country?
@soooobored (1184)
• United States
9 Dec 08
A couple of my friends sold similar degrees while living in India a few years back. They would "evaluate your life experience" to give you an "equivalent degree"... they made pretty good money, and they always wondered why people would believe that these documents could be used for advancement. They were granting "equivalent MDs", or "equivalent MAs" which are really not degrees that can be easily faked! People are stupid for buying them, and these companies are even stupider for selling them!
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
9 Dec 08
A fool and his money are soon parted. There is a reason why the credibility of documents from non-Western foreign universities is nill in Canada. Nobody in Canada will recognize foreign credentials coming outside of trusted Western nations. Those people with unrecognized foreign credentials must retrain in Canada at considerable expense. Is it any wonder that some of these people may take the easy route and obtain forged degrees from Canadian Colleges and Universities? Soon enough it will degrees from Canada that won't be accepted in foreign nations if this problem isn't taken seriously.
• India
9 Dec 08
Shame! Shame! Yet a thing! Truth always prevails though late. I think they are the employers who can do something in such cases. Just a review of failed doubtful people for their documentation, to incorporate into the Do's of HR strategies of employes will help little. Resposiility do not end here. Such cases must be empahasized through newspaper with alarm, so that everyone get aware. Those who are qualified should also take note to oppose the drama. Of course, the examples of heavy punishments will make a fear amongst involved. Institutions should have their unique designs and such machinaries producing certificates should be uncommon. Thanks for posting such an important issue.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
You are welcome JAGANPADIR. Canadian institutions do use unique designs, watermarks, anti-counterfeit devices, exclusive raised seals, stamps and signatures to counteract forgery. Unfortunately, forgery is a lucrative business and I'm sure that the counterfeiters are capable of getting their hands on and purchasing the same type of equipment that the Colleges and Universities use. If the counterfeiting ring can get hired at the institution or have a member of the ring attend or receive a degree from that educational institution, then the ring can easily get their hands on original documents. This is why it is important to know exactly who you are dealing with and why governments need to be very selective with who they allow to enter and work in the country and businesses have to be very careful with whom they hire.
• United States
9 Dec 08
I think is ridiculous that someone will do that just because is the easiest way out of not actually going to school for it. and yes you're right its easier for terrorist to make way here. But is actually not that easy to get a job with a fake degree, i work as a Background Investigator and you won't believe how many of those people we have caught trying to work for schools as teacher, as engineers for oil companies etc. is stupid i think and once we reveal their true identity they star calling our offices demanding that we give them an explanation. But is also unfair for people that attend college or university like my self.
@bayernfan (1430)
• Canada
10 Dec 08
It's harder for people with forged documents to land a job in North America because a degree alone won't get you a job. A lot of the time, just having a degree isn't even enough to land you an interview. Most North American businesses require extensive work experience that was acquired in trusted Western nations before they will consider a candidate. Unfortunately, this isn't the case for every workplace and the rules get relaxed for institutions with quotas. What about entry-level jobs within the government? I don't know about the U.S., but our government hires plenty of immigrants to work for them so that the workplace is more representative of the community. I already know that in many cases the Canadian government can't verify all documents when allowing entry into the country. In some cases, the Canadian government allows refugees entry into the country on compassionate grounds, government officials accept people without documents altogether. The excuse given is usually that the asylum seekers had to destroy their documents to avoid detection or they had their documents confiscated by the government of the country that they are attempting to escape from. Not everyone who will attempt this fraud will be poor. If you've got the money to buy the degree, then perhaps you already have the money to start the business/practice. Of course when someone is willing to pay for a fake degree and live a lie, what stops them from going a little further and lying about work experience? I suppose this is why North American businesses refuse to accept work experience from certain nations. Peng Sun and his counterfeit ring were willing to pose as the University/College officials/contacts too and included this service in their $4000 fee. When the business/institution calls to verify the information, Peng Sun is their to answer the call. It's all in the article whose link I posted in the OP. I'm sure that this tactic can be used for fake work experience or whatever. I'm positive that some people in North America already employ this tactic. What about the people who start up their own practice/business? There have been known cases in Ontario where an unqualified person with fake degrees poses as a doctor and performs surgery on unsuspecting patients. You don't have to stay in business forever, just long enough to make a lot of money and then print up some new documents and setup shop in a new location.
@vanonas (949)
• United States
9 Dec 08
Ugh if I could buy a degree with 4000. That'd be so helpful.
• China
9 Dec 08
In my opinion, it is no meaning to buy a degree. Even if it needs only 1 dollar,i also won't to buy it.Although you have a lot of money that you can buy any degree you want, in fact you don't know anything about it, dose it have any meaning? Dose it really mean you are a scholar? It is just self-deceiving.
@piya84 (2580)
• India
9 Dec 08
education is nt a piece of paper ...u have to absorb it..people who r trying to take shortcut are loosers in long term race