Are you hesitant of responding a discussion you don't agree with?
By sanuanu
@sanuanu (11235)
India
December 22, 2008 6:32pm CST
Do you feel hesitant?
I feel hesitant and I feel that I might get a (-)ve marking so I seldom respond to the discussion which I don't agree with. It is just for my fear. Last time I had a response and the next day, I had my stars down from 9 to 7.
So, I try to protect myself. What about you?
5 people like this
39 responses
@oyenkai (4394)
• Philippines
2 Apr 09
Not at all. I don't really mind when my star rates go down - as long as I know that I have been doing well on myLot. It has happened to me many times when I posted a response that got a lot of negative rates (even though I WAS contributing to the discussion and I WAS being polite).
Thanks for the response on my discussion!
2 people like this
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
2 Apr 09
Did I respond to your discussion? Well, I didn't notice.
Anyway, Star rating is everything here for me. At least once I want to touch 10 star ranking. I don't see it happening in next 6 months or so. i want to preserve my 9 star first and then on I will try to get the next bigger level!
1 person likes this
@uicbear (1900)
• United States
3 Apr 09
To be honest, there have been several times that I have avoided topics just for this reason. Many times I will see political topics that I would love to comment on, but you can tell from the original post, that the tone is just hostile. It seems that so many times people will post a discussion just seeming to try and find people to agree with them. If you happen to try and point out an opposing view, they just tear you up and many times make it a personal attack. I don't worry too much about my star rating (although I do like my little blue star), but I don't want to be attacked for my views.
2 people like this
@sandymay48 (2030)
• Canada
3 Apr 09
I totally agree with what you said. I have seen a few that were hostile from the start and I wasnt getting in the middle of it. Im not here to make bad friends, only to contribute to discussions and have fun and make some friends. One bad discussion can upset the apple cart and I do feel some really go looking for opposition.
@EvrWonder (3571)
• Canada
9 Jan 09
As far as my choices to respond to a discussion, I generally choose discussions that are of interest to me.
If there is a discussion that I have no interest in, feel indifferent about or have no knowledge on, I wont contribute. Not to avoid a negative rating but I am on MyLot to have fun, to contribute positively and help others.
I am not here for debate.
I understand your reluctance and agree that your choice is a wise one.
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
3 Apr 09
There could be a discussion from your interest where you will find that the fact given doesn't match your thinking. That is like you disagree with the author. I am talking about those discussions.
Now, you can't say that these are out of your interest area, can you? So, the question remains, will you respond?
@rosdimy (3926)
• Malaysia
23 Dec 08
Usually I think more than twice before responding to a discussion I do not agree with. From experience in a now closed discussion site, I knew there are people who expect others to whatever they say. Any strong contradiction, even if put forward nicely, would result in them retaliating by giving negative ratings to all postings made by the 'offender'. These people act in a pack, so if you have made lots of postings then it becomes more difficult to regain the ranking we had reached. The vindictive type would wait to rate all future ratings.
Now I do not reply to controversial topics even if I can prove the other side is wrong. They would not admit it and would bring up unrelated topics or issues to support their arguments. So it is better to be safe.
all the best,
rosdimy
2 people like this
@lucy19851120 (261)
• China
2 Apr 09
hi,why not try to analy someone's idea and try to accept it,if the idea is good?
2 people like this
@dolce_vita78 (8062)
• Philippines
23 Dec 08
Hi there sanuanu!
There are instances when I come across some discussions the topics of which are those that I do not totally agree with. Nonetheless, they are worth responding to. If I really do not want to respond, I wouldn't give a negative marking just because I do not agree with the topic. I would rather give a negative marking to those who violate myLot rules based on the discussions they post. More often than not, I just ignore discussions that are not worth responding to. Happy posting!
1 person likes this
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
12 Jan 09
We choose our discussion and then respond to it. In earlier days, I used to give answers to those discussion. Like a discussion on your fav actress. The person is saying that that actress is a dumb! You would not be agree with it, the only question is that would you give answer to that!
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
3 Apr 09
I agree with dolce. There must be a sound reason for giving someone a (-) not just because you didn't agree to what someone said. What's the use of starting a discussion if you're only open for answers that are in your favor!
Some people abuse that minus sign there. I even wish mylot would just remove that one.
1 person likes this
@sirrob (4108)
• Philippines
23 Dec 08
Why are you so afraid of your rating and reputation going down? I am very much affected of it before but when I know about its not so good use and that it is easily manipulated then I care less. I don't basically hesitate to respond to any discussions as long as I have something to contribute or there are anything that I could say.
2 people like this
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
3 Apr 09
Yes, I feel hesitant especially when the discussions are attacking Catholicism. I am a catholic but I am not shoving my beliefs to anyone. It feels like a sin to be a catholic when I am not doing anyone any harm.
I barely answer posts about religion because of that reason. I also hate discussions which makes you sound like a freak if you're a virgin. I am, and it's my choice. And again I am not hurting anyone. So what if a lot of people thinks I'm boring?
Stuffs like that, I just skip them. That's really the only best thing to do.
1 person likes this
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
7 Apr 09
Well we can't help it if they are in the mood to criticise. It's probably in their doctrine that to not criticize is a sin. So if that's what they believe, we can't do anything about it.
I do hope people will just understand each other regardless of religion.
@donnakristel (1704)
• Philippines
4 Apr 09
yes, sometimes. because i want to answer discussions that interests me. if i don't like to respond to that discussion and especially when i don't agree with. i try to also protect myself. of course, a little fear is present.i want to be as nice as possible.
and yes, i don't want to receive a negative mark too. and everybody is given a chance to air their views, positive or negative ones. we are entitled to our own opinions. let us respect each other here.
1 person likes this
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
4 Apr 09
One of the point in the topic "How to get more responses for discussion" was that "Be nice with other people and don't participate in controvertial discussions".
yet, I like hot discussion, atleast in reading they are good and interesting ones too, don't you think?
@ranviruchauhan (1407)
• India
7 Apr 09
I dont feel hesitant to respond negatively. I m here to improve my communication skill. If i present something nicely without hurting feeling of others than its very good. It very important skill of person who can share his/her thoughts,either it is negative or positive.I never consider my rank but consider my skill.Have a gr8 day!
1 person likes this
@taki_takaishi (1279)
• Philippines
3 Apr 09
Hmmm... For me, I don't feel hesitant, because you are expressing your opinion honestly to the person, it is for the person to figure or think if it a negative or not. I mean, it is a persons opinion. There is nothing wrong to express. This is a free expression world, if this world is not free expressing world, then I guess people wouldn't care right?
Hehehe. That is why when I post I always tell them that it is my opinion and all so that it would be clear because every person has its own opinion to tell. Hehehe.
1 person likes this
@taki_takaishi (1279)
• Philippines
3 Apr 09
True. But, the question is, why discuss if you don't want to receive honest and hurting opinions right?
1 person likes this
@deedeehall (1144)
• United States
3 Apr 09
i think you can disagree in a positive way after all it is your opinion they are looking for . it just needs to be in a friendly non argumintive way.so i would not shy away from these kinds of discusions .the worst is you could get a neg mark you want go to jail. the good part is you could respond with the best response.take care.
1 person likes this
@bookreadermom08 (5614)
• United States
3 Apr 09
I am hesitant as well when it comes to something that I dont agree with, unless it is something that I know alot about and can voice my opinion in a positive way, if I cant or dont know much about it then I dont feel that I could do a quality response and pretty much stay away from those discussions.
I know what you mean and I feel the same way as well.
happy mylotting.
1 person likes this
@VANILLAREY (1470)
• India
3 Apr 09
Sometimes I am a bit hesistant about writing something which disagrees with the person who started the discussion. I also avoid writing, if I feel my opinion would not make any difference. But I try to write in such a manner that would not insult the other person. I also hope that Mylot admin verify which comments deserve negative markings and are able to reverse it if the comment did not deserve the negative marking.
1 person likes this
@sandymay48 (2030)
• Canada
3 Apr 09
Yes...sometimes I dont like to respond to discussions that I dont agree with. I would rather keep quiet. I dont want to make bad friends on here and sometimes people can misunderstand what you are trying to say and get defensive.
Although I will sometimes speak my mind if I feel someone is being totally unfair.
1 person likes this
@rashmie (947)
• United Arab Emirates
4 Apr 09
For me, it is always fine to take part in those discussion with which I don't conform. The discussion becomes salty, sweety or tasty..if there is views on all spectrum of topic in reference. Sometime, one see a comment or response, that is so much indignified that there can not be any option other than placing your views.
As for negative point..it matters. Sometime, I feel a inferiority complex, when I saw someone with greater star...though I know they deserve like you...
The discussion on the next PM in which you also dropped like an uninvited guest or ripe mango led me to the reduction of 9 rating points in a single day. I can say that, reduction was all because of that, since I did not take part in other discussions.
However, one thing is certain I will keep posting on contentious discussions...I am a fan of constructive criticism...
1 person likes this
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
4 Apr 09
I saw that discussion and dropped my comment there too but no one dared to comment back on me. Guess they were busy rating you -.
That is the problem of people here. They don't really want to make a healthy discussion. All they want is that all of should praise them. Since that discussion, I think I have also started doing some hot discussion these days. Although, I don't go for discussion started by users other than my friends.
As for your inferiority complex, all I can say is that it is still early days for you. I was on 7 star when I had 581 against my name. My experience says that with spending more time, the - rating effect become lessor as time progresses.
I am a big fan of yours and always looking to read your posting as you provide not only comments but facts in support of them too!
Cheers! not many good writers like you get even 7 star. I know a very good writer who is sitting at 5 star rating. Sad but true.
1 person likes this