'Christian' band, 'Emo' band, do you have a NEED to categorize your music?

@mommyboo (13174)
United States
January 14, 2009 12:03pm CST
I have been into youtube a lot lately (which might explain my absence to friends here lol) and this kept cropping up. I listen to one band a lot so I was favoriting and adding comments and all I kept running into over and over were ridiculous people arguing in the comments about whether the band makes (insert word here) music, etc etc. Seriously people! Since when did an argument of semantics have to get in the way of good music?? I am very frustrated with this phenomenon BECAUSE I fear that it draws some people in while it pushes others away, and come on, a great band is a great band, a guitar riff is a guitar riff, right? Superb songwriting is a gift and vocals that make you shiver equals talent. If you love it, can't you just love it? Why label someone who is in the business just because they love it and they can? Do you label your music, do you label the artists you love?
1 person likes this
4 responses
@arkaf61 (10881)
• Canada
16 Jan 09
LOL I know what you are saying. ANd I guess a lot of people do label the music they like, or the one they dislike. Ever since I remember I was never neither a follower - music wise - or a labeller ( new word LOL ) . Most kids my age had a tendency to like the music all the other kids their age liked. It was not even necessary that they really appreciated it, it was just so they would fit in. It still happens now of course. Personally I was more interested in what I felt with each music, regardless of what kind of music it was. TOday I am still the same. Sure there are musics and musicians that I favor over other ones, but they are not all from the same " kind " of music . I am very eclectic in my music taste.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
17 Jan 09
I'm kind of eclectic too. I don't tend to follow the mainstream anyway because I'd rather things mean something to me. "Popular" just doesn't always appeal. When I find something that does, I can get a little ocd. I figure since it happens so rarely, I have a right lol. On a completely different tactic, I don't get the labelling either. When people label people, it can hurt. When people label things, it can also hurt. I don't know what the draw is but I do know there is one. From demographic information to grades in school or levels at a job, it's like humans have this overwhelming desire to do this, to compartmentalize. I don't think it serves a purpose, I think the fact that so many of us do it means we're broken in some way.
1 person likes this
@arkaf61 (10881)
• Canada
17 Jan 09
I don't see that it serves a purpose either, but you're right , it seems to be something that many people need to do to put everything in its specific shelf when we all know that each thing can have more than one place where it fits. And the thing is, we should be celebrating differences. It's from the people that think differently that most advancements have come. THe ones that seem to believe that labels should not apply. The ones that if they have to put something on a specific shelf, cross reference it in many other places.
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
23 Jan 09
with me, i do label it to a degree but if i like it i dont care what label it is i still listen. i think our taste in music is aquired by whats going on in our life at the time and our friends surroundings. like when i was younger i hated metal or hard rock. then my son listened to it so much i became used to some and started liking it. so its an aquired taste.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
24 Jan 09
I was kind of sheltered as a younger kid, so I didn't get into 'popular' music until I was about 10 or so. I have exposed my daughter to all sorts of music from before she was born. I listen to a variety, a lot of country, alternative, pop, 80s, and hair band rock. My husband has several electric guitars and an acoustic, and our son has an electric guitar. My husband played his guitar while I was pregnant, and some every now and then. Our daughter likes guitar... she has even asked for one. She also sings things like wheels on the bus (from preschool) and 'itsy bitsy spider' (ballet) and 'So What' (Pink lol) and she likes to dance to 'daddy's guitar bands'. I like having a variety, that means she will appreciate a wide range of things instead of never having heard it before and not liking whatever it is based on the fact that it's unfamiliar. I agree that it does have a lot to do with things going on in our lives and maybe friends. I listen to playlists from friends or suggestions for new music, in fact that's how I came to hear about my current favorite band.
• United States
16 Jan 09
yeah i can seem some categorizing such as rock, rap, classical, metal, christian, country, gospel, etc but to really bicker about stuff annoys me!! and it really annoys me when i am on a site and i dont know if that site will categorize marilyn manson as rock, metal, goth, emo or ?? and so i have to search through them all!!
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
17 Jan 09
I love my music... and it irritates me to see people arguing about it. I don't care what people think it is, know what I mean? Why does that matter? It doesn't change what it sounds like or how it makes me feel. LOL! I also happen to think the guys in the band are hot. Some people don't. Bleh... so what?
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
15 Jan 09
Hey mommyboo! So that's where you've been! And you didn't invite me to come with? What's Emo? I don't particularly care for labels myself since I happen to like all different kinds of music! I like what I like and it doesn't really matter to me which category it falls is! When I am looking for something in particular I just look under the artist so I can find it, not what category they're in since I usually am not even sure. Some of the catergorys or genres are so similar anyway! I don't know why it makes such a big difference. If you like the music and sound and the vocals the so what? I don't know why all the "noise" about the semantics! That's what got alot of the rap artists killed in the first place and what a waste of talent that was! I happened to be a fan of both Tupac and Biggy and since Biggy's movie is coming out Friday this all reminds me of all the bad stuff that can happen when stupid stuff goes down and lives get taken for all the wrong reasons. RIP Tupac and Big!
1 person likes this