If after an arranged marriage..you can't stand your new partner?
By JenInTN
@JenInTN (27514)
United States
February 1, 2009 7:16am CST
I'm very curious about this and hope you don't mind to share with me. I would really like to know what happens in this situation. Are there certain things that your taught to help the relationship or are there rules that have to be followed? I think your answer may help others to work out their marital problems even if their partner was chosen. So how does the arranged marriage work and what are the pros and cons of it? What do you do if you marry and can't stand your partner? Are you taught any secrets to making it work out? Anyone with info is welcome to answer and will be positively rated just for participating in my discussion.
3 people like this
14 responses
@cupid74 (11388)
• Pakistan
2 Feb 09
Hi Jen
Hope u must be doing fine
well either its Arrange Marriage or Love marriage, to conitune it and to make it there are following somple Rules
1) sincerity
2) Trust
3) Tolerance
4)Care/Love
5) Adoptabilty and
6) Intention to keep it going
If u have all this then trust me, its going to be pleasent partnership and getting stronger with passage of time
The only Cons i can see in Arrange marriage is that u dont know each other well and it need time to over come teething problem and understand each other. and if u give time , then i am sure trust and love developed duruing this time is Long Lasting.
And if in worse case it dont work, then where socities have Arrange Marriage, the ONLY Secret Taught to both Boy and Girl is "COMPROMISE and Adjust"
And in worst case option on Divorce is always there though not liked by society
Take care
2 people like this
@cupid74 (11388)
• Pakistan
2 Feb 09
Hi Jen
well my marriage was arranged one and i met my wife on day of wedding. its nort that it was imposed on me or i dont have option, but trust me in society where families are close knitted and dependent on each other than Arrange marraiges are good
and trust me every parent want to have best partner for theer kid and i am sure u must agree that ur parents knows ur habits, liking and disliking.
In our side marriage is not between 2 person and based on physical relation, its infact get togather of 2 families and have social and cultural bonding too. and u r right , divorce rate in arrange marriages is very low as compare to others as othwers are always there to mediate between 2 and when u have kids, rates of divorces ereduces mmore , then both compromise for kid.
In case of love marriages, both lovers are so much involved that they ignore many things and attached tooo much expectations, which in real life cant be met , it results in Fights, and as decesion is of individual so its easy to revert it.
hope it makes thing clear
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Feb 09
Hi cupid!! Thank you so much for your response. I guess compromise and adjust is part of any marriage that you want to last. I read that the divorce rate is only 1.1% among arranged marriages. I can see where getting to know each other in the beginning would be the tough part. But you've met and actually have some say right? Or is it completely arranged? This subject is very intriguing to me. Thank you again for responding.
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
3 Feb 09
Thanks again my friend! I can see the point of your culture. Sometimes love marriages are very passionate from the git go. It is hard for me to imagine because I have never known it. I'm glad your marriage has been a pleasing one. I can see how having children can contribute to compromise too. I bet you and your wife were really nervous on the marriage day. Having all those mediators when needed would be a great help too. At what age do parents begin to choose a partner? Is it from birth or much later?
@arthi_88 (1516)
• India
2 Feb 09
Its the daughter in law too that you have to watch out for. See most of the case where mother in laws are shown as victims are movies or serials and s far as the amount of people I have seen..these two ladies spend the maximum time with each other and so have all the fights and affection too..When mother is too difficult to tolerate hen that's rare and thats because the whole family is like that...And then in Joint families there is the issue about the Lay of the house..As far as my family goes everyone seems fine in their place and pray to God I have a motherly Mother in Law!
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
1 Feb 09
I can't wait to get some responses on this too. I don't want to judge but I am very curious and I hope some of my friends here will respond. I don't really know anything about it and would like to be educated. I love learning about people and their culture. Thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@arlerambabu (1079)
• India
1 Feb 09
you said it's an arranged marriage. If it's so, along with the parents of both sides some elders also must have been present at the time of arranging the marriage.Take their help in sorting out the matters. Explain them what is that trait in the other person that you can't stand out.Discussions involving the concerned will sort out the problems. A High degree of caution has to be exercised as it's an issue pertaining to life.
2 people like this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
1 Feb 09
So..the partner with the issue would approach the elders that arranged the marriage and express their grievance. Then the elders would advise on how to handle the situation. I see arranged marriages are arranged by more than just the parents of the couple. Are they sensitive to these trials expressed by the young couple as they have been there themselves? Thank you so much for your insight on this question.
1 person likes this
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
1 Feb 09
i think it is a horrible thing to do to young people. my gosh, it's hard enough to make a marriage work even if u are doing the choosing.they should give that old custom up. i would not go along w/it i don't care what,
@sunil_008 (1269)
• India
16 Feb 09
arrange marriages do lasts long. if you have issue about your partner go to the person who has arranged it.more than one is involved in arranging it.so it will take some time make one settlement...
after the first settlement(as it had already taken so much time) i am sure both the partners wouldn't dare to settle another thing again...
so according to me arrange marriages do lasts long no matter what... :)
1 person likes this
@sunil_008 (1269)
• India
17 Feb 09
Well, think so but who knows i might meet someone even tomorrow and fall in love...and all that i said is applied to me too...I have always felt felt arrange marriagers are better than love one's...
@sunil_008 (1269)
• India
17 Feb 09
I think so...but who knows i meet someone tomorrow and fall in love the day after...and marry her the next day...but arrange marriages are better than the love one's. that's what i have always thought.
@GADHISUNU (2162)
• India
16 Feb 09
JenIn, Arranged Marriages are common in countries like India. I will tell you some good reasons for the prevalence of Arranged Marriages in India.
In Indian society and culture,[B] the society is above the family and Family above the individual.[/B] Now, this is a given. People are conditioned by the mores. Anybody who breaks a social law (often unwritten) is seen as an outcast. To give you an idea, the social law breaker is seen almost like a person who is on unemployment dole, say, in US. You know how anybody dreads being on dole.
Since [B]Family is above the individual[/B], individual freedoms are subservient to family honor or positioning.So, a son or daughter is perceived as a keeper of family honor. When concerns more than one's desires(for the individual is desire driven)are made the cornerstone of living, people are trained-in to treat their own judgments as not sufficiently mature.Further the son/daughter consider themselves as having discharged a duty and earned the love of parents, and vice versa.
Further, the idea that is dinned in through[B] Religion and the Theory of Karma [/B](this is more applicable to Hindu marriages)is that [B] even if one makes a choice and escapes something like an unlivable marriage, different problems will surround you to make it up i.e. compensate for it.[/B] This idea is in the psyche of the Indian. So, he/she is prepared. He/She would have seen the tempestuous marriages of their own parents surviving despite all odds. As kids and adolescents we would be seeing our parents marriages hitting the rock botton and as soon we would be finding it again afloat. This reinstates the confidence in the system. It is a very interesting study, that you have undertaken. Please respond with your questions/objections: I would love to answer. I can give anecdotal examples.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
16 Feb 09
Thank you so much! That was very informative. I really have no objections persay because this is another culture we are talking about. I do have a question about the astrological factor. I have read they use horescopes as a means of choosing their son or daughters life mate. Who is this astrologer that helps with this? are they trained or considered gifted or both? Thanks again my friend.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
16 Feb 09
I had no idea there was also a marriage broker was involved. I assume this person handles the financial side of things? There are alot of people in my country that put alot of stock into astrology too..and the concept of karma. I myself believe in karma. I can truely see how all of this comes together and keeps the system going. Thanks so much for your input on this.
@GADHISUNU (2162)
• India
16 Feb 09
Yeah the astrologer and his role is one thing I have forgotten to mention in my previous post. Since the man and woman meet formally in the presence of the parents and they do not know each other much or much about each other there should be some way by which someone studies their compatibility, mental and physical.There is no concept of dating or any other physical intimacy possible in our culture. This job of "matching" is therefore done by the astrologer. There are many of them offering these services. Like the marriage brokers who look into the social side of things the astrologers take care of "matching" the horoscopes. The belief in India is that the horoscope is a very accurate record not only of the personality but also what the general future is going to be like.Again this is based on an unshakable faith in the way of Karma. Karma as you know forms the backbone of Hinduism.
Everything has been codified in this science called astrology.The man and woman are
matched on 32 characteristics, and weighted average is considered to make a decision. Further they also study the periods of bad and good times in each of their lives and see that they don't occur at the same time so that day-to-day life's pressures don't put pressure on the couple to break the marriage.
1 person likes this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
2 Feb 09
Firstly you have to understand the social condition where arranged marriages take place. This is prevalent in societies where children are expected to respect majority of their parent’s decisions. From childhood, kids are taught that parents are like gods and above every other relation and it’s the duty of every child to love, respect, listen and do every bidding of their parents. So by the time the kids are of marriageable age, they may have had many ‘love’ affairs, but the choice of life partner is left to the parents.
Secondly, in such societies it is taught the marriages are made in heaven and cannot be / should not undone on earth by us. No matter what, it is a sin to abandon a life partner just because you cannot get along. Family meetings are called, friends are taken into confidence, even neighbours pitch in to save a marriage. Its more of a community thing than personal.
Thirdly, in such societies girls are not very financially well off…so its best to tolerate a little and stick on rather than moving back to the parent’s home where they will be nothing more than financial burdens.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Feb 09
So everyone gets called in on 911 to save the marriage. I did read that society looked down greatly on divorce too. I read that astrological signs are used in choosing partners for their children. Thank you for the response!I suppose in most cases a divorce would be alot harder than staying with your chosen mate. Thanks for responding.
@oldboy46 (2129)
• Australia
5 Feb 09
A friend of my partner had an arranged marriage and the couple never met before the ceremony in fact. The marriage was arranged by what I suppose would be a broken who liased with both sets of parents. The bride grew up here in Australia, and her parents returned to their home country when she was 15 because they wanted her to marry someone from the "old country". The groom was overseas so there were many differences to overcome as they lives had been different. The bride was 17 and the groom 21 when they married.
A couple of thing were that they had to learn about each other, their likes and dislikes as well as their strengths and weaknesses. The other thing is that they are both very determined people and within a year of their marriage, they came to Australia. That I think from what they have said upset their families but they believe it is the best decision they ever made. They were alone or away from their families and the only people they knew were the few friends she had from her school days. So basically they had to rely on each other.
I am not sure if it is a common practice or not, but this couple did not consumate their marriage for some time after the actual ceremony. Both were very shy and wanted to know each other better first they have said and possibly that is what has made their marriage so successful.
Whoever chose them for each other hit the bulls eye as this is a love relationship and they admit it came gradually over a few years, but only after they came to live in Australia away from their families. They had 4 children, all of whom are now grown up and are married with children of their own. None of their children had an arranged marriage because although it worked for them, they knew it wasn't always the case.
It is interesting to read the first hand experience of those who are in an arranged marriage and yes there are times when they actually work out very well indeed. Our friends are a good example.
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
5 Feb 09
Wow! That is a great story! I have never known anyone personally who has been in an arranged marriage. I am very curious about the idea of it. When I read about the divorce rate and all I was even more intrigued. I think that it's great how things worked out for your friends. Thanks for responding!
@headhunter525 (3548)
• India
2 Feb 09
We don't just go blindly into a relationship. After we know the partner we try to talk on different issues. Only then we enter a relationship. So arranged marriage is generally more of a 50-50 effort of both parents and children. Our culture is that once we are married we don't divorce. We meet relatives and the elders to sort out issues when there are problems. For Christians we go to church elders to sort out differences. And most often it's sorted out.
1 person likes this
@headhunter525 (3548)
• India
3 Feb 09
The divorce percentage is low here. Yes, we do on the basis of interests,backgrounds,and astrological signs too. Background may mean the caste background and the earning of the person. Christians and Muslims, however, do not use astrological sign. In fact, Hindus will even consult astrologer to fix the wedding date.
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
3 Feb 09
Hi headhunter! Thanks for your response. I guess the elders can really help with sorting these things out as they have been there themselves. I do understand that your culture has a little to none divorce percentage. I read that couples are matched based on interests,backgrounds,and astrological signs..among a few other things. Was that true?
@DonnaLawson (4032)
• United States
2 Feb 09
I don't really understand that much about arranged marriages, but I do think they are barbaric and outdated traditions.. I don't think that you have any say-so in a marriage of this type, I believe any of your own thoughts, ideas and hopes are gone, because you were about the same as sold to your husband and you have no choices or voice in any of the matters pertaining to your future.. I can't think of anything good to come of a marriage like that unless your arranged husband was so good to you that you did fall in love with him and be able to live happily with him, other than that, I can't see how it would work with both parties being happy during this arrangement..
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Feb 09
It is hard for me to understand too but I'm hoping to get a better idea through this thread. I am curious as to how this type of marriage lasts and what happens if they can't stand each other.Do they fall in love after a time?Hmmm I'm anxious to see what my responses will be. Thanks for responding Donna!
@mercuryman3a (2477)
• India
3 Feb 09
Arranged marriages rarely fail the way love marriages do. In an arranged marriage you often do not know each other before marriage so yo are really not aware of each other's strengths and weaknesses. you are confronted with both at the same time after marriage. You learn to compromise with the weaknesses while strengthening the marriage with the strengths. You start accepting the person for what he or she is and not for what you thought he or she woudl be. you do not have any preconcieved ideas about the person so you accept the person as you find that person to be after marriage.
1 person likes this
@arthi_88 (1516)
• India
2 Feb 09
I don't think there can be any bound rule to make an arranged marriage successful..All my relatives here have had arranged marriages and luckily most of them are quite successful except for one where we had a divorce case..I guess in case of arrange marriages the partners should meet each other alone several times in various situations to get to know each other properly before marriage so that if you can't stand the person you can move out before committing...And anyway all marriages takes some amount of compromises from the partners either its love or arranged marriage. Have a nice day!
@arthi_88 (1516)
• India
2 Feb 09
They had met around four to five times in temples and restaurants...In Hindus divorce is not allowed but legal procedure is there so they got divorced in the court..Its very rare here though and divorce has just become socially acceptable..Hope nobody has to go through anything like that!Have a nice day!
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Feb 09
Hi arthi! I wondered how many times the couple actually got to meet each other before the marriage. I guess it just depends. Compromise is definately needed to make any marriage work. Who allows the divorce? Is there a legal path to follow? Thanks for responding.
@bamrahkirti (1821)
• India
2 Feb 09
I am an Indian and i had an arranged marriage.Our marriage was arranged by a common relative and but we did not know each other before marriage.After our marriage was solemnized we were rather strangers .It took us almost one year to know about each other's interests,likings,disliking,turn off,turns on,hobbies etc.But we always gave time and liberty to prove each other.It has been two years since our marriage taken place and we are happy with each other.We are blessed with a son who is 1 year old.
We are still exploring each other with usual and not so usual ups and downs in life.We do fight on trivial issues but have made certain agendas and these always help us to come out of our animosities and frustrations.
So the golden rule is giving time to your partner.Anything done in haste will prove fatal for the relationship.Each day is a new learning process so never give up even if you find something not so good about your partner.
@makeupbycher (165)
• Philippines
2 Feb 09
although i wasn't in an arranged marriage, it's so wonderful to read your post. it's because our culture doesn't have arranged marriage and thru you i was able to learn a lot.
i'm happy that still it worked out for the 2 of you and with a new baby too! cheers!
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
2 Feb 09
Wow..Thank you for that post. I guess part of the "fun" in a relationship is getting to know each other. I am so glad you are happy with one another and that you have a child. I guess anything done in haste is fatal to a relationship whether your in a love marriage or not. Thank you so much for sharing with us.
@sarowhu1990 (6)
• Hong Kong
2 Feb 09
Well ,just try not to get married before you make sure that you 'll in love with him. As a very traditional girl ,I never thought about divorce.If you can't stand your new partner .Say good bye and find the right guy.However ,this should be done before you get married
1 person likes this