What's your Birth Order?
By scorpio19
@scorpio19 (1363)
February 7, 2009 3:30am CST
Do you think Adler's theory on Birth Order (possibility of characteristics) applies to you?
ONLY CHILD: Overprotected and spoiled by parents. Has difficulty sharing. Accustomed to having own way
OLDEST: analytical, detailed, methodical, values control, may be authoritarian/strict, feelings of excessive responsibility
SECOND: more competitive, may become rebel
MIDDLE: diplomatic, dislike conflicts and seek fairness and justice; "people pleasers."
YOUNGEST: excitement seekers who crave attention; have huge plans that never work out; maybe overindulged, poor social empathy
I'm a middle child and I have to agree, I am like that (not sure about been a people pleaser though..lol), how about you ?
3 people like this
14 responses
@littleowl (7157)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi scorpio, actually I am the oldest but relate to the middle siter, and my middle is more like the oldest in character..am not sure about my youngest sister though!! hugs littleowl
2 people like this
@littleowl (7157)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi Scorpio..my sisters and I have always been like chalk and cheese! Maybe it is more to do with our bithsigns..I am a aquarian, my middle sister is pisces and my youngest sister is a leo..three totally different signs...hugs littleowl
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi Littleowl,
I wonder why that is maybe your characters are completely different so blow Alders theory out the window..lol
1 person likes this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi grace24,
I also agree with you that it does depends on the parents influences but my older sister is very like that especially the "feelings of excessive responsibility" she even now and I'm in my late 30's feels like she's the mother of myself and my sisters and thinks her word is final and we should all bow down to her wisdom..lol (needless to say, we don't) and I'm really not saying your like this because I'm sure you aren't but it is a interesting theory.
1 person likes this
@rainmark (4302)
•
7 Feb 09
I am an oldest among my siblings and yes it depends on parenting, on how the parents raised me. As an eldest daughter,my parents really expect on my to do my job when they are not around, Im in charge of my siblings and i feel im the second mother when my mum not around, im so strict and i dominate them and it needed that they always follow me,coz if they got mistake im the none who get punished.Until now that i have my own family i still the same to them.
Happy posting.
2 people like this
@p1kef1sh (45681)
•
7 Feb 09
This is an interesting one. I am the oldest. I share but can be controlling. I like to be dominated but dominate. I am usually non-confrontational and will share my last Rolo with anyone. But I do have feelings of responsibility and sometimes think that everything is all my fault. My daughter is an only child and is a great sharer. As a girl we used to insist that she shared her sweets say; and she'd often do such a good job that she would end up with none for herself! The Boss is a middle child and I would say fits the description exactly. She also can be tough and doesn't shy away from confrontation. Her younger brother is more like and eldest child based on Adler. (He wasn't any relation of Larry Adler the mouth organist?!!)
2 people like this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
7 Feb 09
Hiya p1kef1sh,
Yes different parenting has an obvious affect on Alders theory, like you have pointed out with your only daughter, she's a sharer because that's what you taught her to do but yes it's a very interesting theory and I think we can all relate with some of it, if not all.
1 person likes this
@tamarafireheart (15384)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi scorpio,
Coming from a large family of six children and I am the second youngest, I was forgotton about as everyone including myself give a lot of attention to our youngest sibling, my oler brother is a black sheep of the family so he got all the attention and fuss from my mother because he was her favourite, although mum always says she has not favourites, but I know he was, so really I was the outsider and always outside looking in and had to work darn hard to achive my goal without any help, where else my family tells me oh you can't do this, you can't do that, and just left me alone. Love and hugs.
Tamara
xxxxx
2 people like this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi Tamara,
Well you certainly proved your family wrong because you certainly have achieved alot in life and your a lovely lady too xx
1 person likes this
@Humbug25 (12540)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi ya scorpio19
Well I am the youngest in my family and I do agree with what is said about the youngest child apart from the 'poor social empathy' can you see me to be a person that doesn't take others feelings in to concideration? I am always thinking of others before myself, I think being a mother does that to you not your position in the family!! I would say that my middle child is pretty much as you have said. There is such a thing as middle child syndrome and he seems to follow that pattern too!!
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi Humbug,
No definitely not, I couldn't see you ever not having consideration for others but like you have said, which I really do agree been a mother makes us selfless.
@rainmark (4302)
•
7 Feb 09
Among my 9 siblings im the oldest, and how strange this characteristics really described me. OLDEST: analytical, detailed, methodical, values control, may be authoritarian/strict, feelings of excessive responsibility.
And i do agree with you.
Happy posting.
2 people like this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
7 Feb 09
Hi rainmark,
Yes and I bet with there been 9 of you then you did help out more with your siblings, so more chance of you been like Alders oldest child theory I think.
1 person likes this
@PixieMischief (218)
• Canada
8 Feb 09
LOL im an only child, and I love getting things MY way hehehehe
but the rest not that true I dont mind sharing things as long as Im asked FIRST.
1 person likes this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi PixieMischief,
I think most folk like it their way or no way lol thanks for response.
@Carolyn63 (1403)
• United States
11 May 09
I am the eldest child. I was raised with one of my brothers, a year and a half younger. I have more sibling that I wasn't raised with but that is a long story. I do have to agree that I am analytical and have feelings of responsibility. Control was something I didn't have and didn't even try to have under the abuse of my adoptive parents. I would have prefered invisibility. I can't say that I am strict or methodical. I think that would cut back on my creative nature. My brother took rebellion to the extreme. He is not a good person. So I also have to agree it has to do with upbringing and the environment in which we are raised.
Blessings,
Carolyn (LLA)
@guybrush (4658)
• Australia
8 Feb 09
Yes, I definitely think birth order has an effect, Scorpio! My husband and I are BOTH eldest children and we are both reliable, organised and sensible. My parents are BOTH only children, and are very insular - preferring their own company and not wanting to make friends or have any social life. Our eldest was definitely an attention seeker, whereas the second girl was a thinker who never wanted attention (still doesn't) and enjoys daredevil activities. She didn't have any competitive streak, but just allowed her elder sister to 'get on with it', preferring to go about her own business and quietly become her own person without any fanfare. The third daughter primps and preens and likes to look her best all the time - she's extremely social, can't bear to be alone for a minute and makes friends with everybody! Our youngest is a boy - he was treated to his sisters fussing over him, and if we told him off, they'd feel sorry for him and tell us to leave him alone - hahha! He's NOT organised, NOT independent and is a total dreamer. Maybe if he'd been our firstborn, it would be a different story! It's a very interesting topic!
1 person likes this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hiya guybrush,
That's an interesting point, that if they had been born differently then would they now show different traits in their characters, I know my youngest is very much like your own, my two eldest parent him and if he's told of by me then I get told off by them, odd that it appears to be the same. Thanks for your response I really enjoyed reading it.
@TnWoman (1895)
• United States
8 Feb 09
hello scorpio
i am the YOUNGEST: excitement seekers who crave attention; have huge plans that never work out; maybe overindulged, poor social empathy and i do have to agree with that as well. it seems like every time that i get involved in something business wise, it always falls through somehow. and i am not a very social person at all at get togethers or social events that i might attend. but once i get to know a person thou i am a very friendly person to be around.
take care and have a beautiful evening.
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi TnWoman,
seems like you are a perfect example of Alders theory, although most people find it difficult to make a business successful it's hard work as I know with my own experiences. Have a lovely day.
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi anne12d,
It is only a theory so not everyone will relate to it but like you some have a little.
@jcay_lorna (433)
• Ireland
8 Feb 09
I am the oldest in the family. But I don't believe I possess any of the qualities mentioned. I can say I'm more of the characteristics mentioned in the middle child. I think it's really based on how you were raised by your parents and the different factors around you when your growing up. It can be environmental factors, social, emotional and psychological facotrs that affects your attitude in life. Anyway, have a nice day!
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi jcay_lorna,
yes I agree other factors do come into play and can affect his theory. Thanks for response you too have a lovely day.
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi reichiru,
Yes it is only a theory and not conclusive evidence but interesting that you do fit partly to it.
@kpsaran (74)
• India
8 Feb 09
hi scorpio,
I have elder sister and I am the second.I m puzzled as to which category i belong to either the "second" or "youngest".I don't think theories actually play an important role in one's life.Its about individuality ,one's own unique characteristics.Not necessary that children in "only child" category are spoilt ones.According to me we can't judge a person by some theory.But as per ur survey,i m no attention seeker.I dislike conflicts.Ya at times i become rebellious.;););)
good day!!!!!!!
1 person likes this
@scorpio19 (1363)
•
8 Feb 09
Hi kpsaran,
Like you have pointed out it is only a theory and other things do come into play and do affect his theory, I wonder if he took that into account whilst researching for this.