The catastrophe of the apostrophe in the queen's language...

@tjades (3591)
Jamaica
February 8, 2009 2:20am CST
I was totally unaware that there was a campaign in parts of England to get rid of the apostrophe 's used to show ownership in the english language. Apparently some are fed up with the apostrophe 's and want it removed from use in english while others are rallying to save the 's. Check out the story in this link. www.finda.com.au/story/2009/02/02/its-catastrophe-apostrophe/ - 50k What is your view? Do you think it is old fashioned and should go or do you agree with the purist that it ought to remain as is? The queen's English or The queens English... Which should it be....
2 responses
@ravend (658)
• Malta
8 Feb 09
It should remain. Fullstop.People who want it removed are just lazy. How do I distinguish between it's and its .. and how do I say Mary's? Marys? And would you want to confuse the minds of people learning English further more?
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
8 Feb 09
As if its not difficult for them already uh? I agree. I was really surprised to whn I heard the news. I would not have expexted that reaction from of all places England. That is one area of english I do not feel needs revising.
@ravend (658)
• Malta
8 Feb 09
English as a language per se is VERY difficult. Its nature induces people to be more dyslexic - in fact an english speaking child has been shown to have the same brain activity of an italian-speaking child who simply has reading difficulties; and dyslexia is more common in english speaking countries than italian. (quoting from my developmental psychology book here). As someone who grew up learning english, I can guarantee that homonyms are part of what really confused my learning process growing up. Keep the 's please!
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
9 Feb 09
Thats some interesting info re dyslexia and its prominenece among english speaking verus italian speaking children. Many many of our students here complain bitterly about the complexity of english as a subject and many boys tend to do far better at math. As far as they are concerned math is a logical subject which does not confuse itself so it does not confuse them in return . I am far better at english but there are aspects of the subject/course which understandably will be a challenge to persons not too keen on the subject in the first place. Removing the apostrophe at this time will only add to their confusion.
• Canada
9 Feb 09
The use of the apostrophe to show possession is esential. It cannot be deleted from the Queen's English. The addition and subtraction of words from everyday use is one thing, but there is no reason to fiddle with punctuation and the rules of grammar. Removing the apostrophe from possessive nouns will not only cause confusion for current students of the language, but for all English-speakers.